Trending

Filed under: News | Apple

 

Senator Al Franken Wrote Letter to Tim Cook Over iPhone 5S Touch ID Privacy Concerns

Senator Al Franken wrote a letter to Tim Cook expressing privacy concern over Apple's ID Touch on the iPhone 5S. Some of the questions the politico asked Tim do not have easy answers.

Sep 21 2013, 6:06am CDT | by

12 Updates
Senator Al Franken Wrote Letter to Tim Cook Over iPhone 5S Touch ID Privacy Concerns
Getty Images
 
 

YouTube Videos Tweets Comments

Full Story

Senator Al Franken Wrote Letter to Tim Cook Over iPhone 5S Touch ID Privacy Concerns

While Apple Incorporated has given a whole lot of assurance regarding its fingerprint authentication system on the iPhone 5S, Senator Al Franken thinks otherwise. This venerable politician has penned a letter to Apple CEO, Tim Cook asking clarification regarding the loopholes in this new ID system. Especially as regards privacy matters, there are some doubts that need to be addressed properly. 

The senator is a knowledgeable man who knows how to deconstruct the information given by an agency regarding its product. That is why he has asked a series of questions that go to the root of the matter. Tim Cook will have a hard time answering each and every one of the queries that Senator Al Franken lists in his letter. 

Al Franken said explicitly in the letter that while passwords are private and can be changed, fingerprints are public and cannot be changed. He was especially concerned over the fact that were some criminal to get a hold of your iPhone fingerprint system, he could use it to blackmail you or even worse commit crimes in your name. 

Some of Franken’s questions have already been answered by Apple yet some surety is needed that the system is secure. Franken ends his letter by saying that Apple respond with a rejoinder to his letter within a month’s time limit.

Below is the Al Franken's letter sent to Tim Cook.  

 

September 19, 2013

Mr. Tim Cook, CEO

Apple, Inc.

1 Infinite Loop

Cupertino, CA


Dear Mr. Cook:

I am writing regarding Apple's recent inclusion of a fingerprint reader on the new iPhone 5S. Apple has long been a leading innovator of mobile technology; I myself own an iPhone. At the same time, while Apple's new fingerprint reader, Touch ID, may improve certain aspects of mobile security, it also raises substantial privacy questions for Apple and for anyone who may use your products. In writing you on this subject, I am seeking to establish a public record of how Apple has addressed these issues internally and in its rollout of this technology to millions of my constituents and other Americans.

Too many people don't protect their smartphones with a password or PIN. I anticipate that Apple's fingerprint reader will in fact make iPhone 5S owners more likely to secure their smartphones. But there are reasons to think that an individual's fingerprint is not "one of the best passwords in the world," as an Apple promotional video suggests.

Passwords are secret and dynamic; fingerprints are public and permanent. If you don't tell anyone your password, no one will know what it is. If someone hacks your password, you can change it—as many times as you want. You can't change your fingerprints. You have only ten of them. And you leave them on everything you touch; they are definitely not a secret. What's more, a password doesn't uniquely identify its owner—a fingerprint does. Let me put it this way: if hackers get a hold of your thumbprint, they could use it to identify and impersonate you for the rest of your life. 

It's clear to me that Apple has worked hard to secure this technology and implement it responsibly. The iPhone 5S reportedly stores fingerprint data locally "on the chip" and in an encrypted format. It also blocks third-party apps from accessing Touch ID. Yet important questions remain about how this technology works, Apple's future plans for this technology, and the legal protections that Apple will afford it. I should add that regardless of how carefully Apple implements fingerprint technology, this decision will surely pave the way for its peers and smaller competitors to adopt biometric technology, with varying protections for privacy.

I respectfully request that Apple provide answers to the following questions:

(1) Is it possible to convert locally-stored fingerprint data into a digital or visual format that can be used by third parties?

(2) Is it possible to extract and obtain fingerprint data from an iPhone? If so, can this be done remotely, or with physical access to the device?

(3) In 2011, security researchers discovered that iPhones were saving an unencrypted file containing detailed historical location information on the computers used to back up the device. Will fingerprint data be backed up to a user's computer?

(4) Does the iPhone 5S transmit any diagnostic information about the Touch ID system to Apple or any other party? If so, what information is transmitted? 

(5) How exactly do iTunes, iBooks and the App Store interact with Touch ID? What information is collected by those apps from the Touch ID system, and what information is collected by Apple associated with those interactions, including identifiers or hashes related to the fingerprint data?

(6) Does Apple have any plans to allow any third party applications access to the Touch ID system or its fingerprint data?

(7) Can Apple assure its users that it will never share their fingerprint data, along with tools or other information necessary to extract or manipulate the iPhone fingerprint data, with any commercial third party?

(8) Can Apple assure its users that it will never share their fingerprint files, along with tools or other information necessary to extract or manipulate the iPhone fingerprint data, with any government, absent appropriate legal authority and process?

(9) Under American privacy law, law enforcement agencies cannot compel companies to disclose the "contents" of communications without a warrant, and companies cannot share that information with third parties without customer consent. However, the "record[s] or other information pertaining to a subscriber... or customer" can be freely disclosed to any third party without customer consent, and can be disclosed to law enforcement upon issuance of a non-probable cause court order. Moreover, a "subscriber number or identity" can be disclosed to the government with a simple subpoena. See generally 18 U.S.C. § 2702-2703

Does Apple consider fingerprint data to be the "contents" of communications, customer or subscriber records, or a "subscriber number or identity" as defined in the Stored Communications Act?

(10) Under American intelligence law, the Federal Bureau of Investigation can seek an order requiring the production of "any tangible thing[] (including books, records, papers, documents, and other items)" if they are deemed relevant to certain foreign intelligence investigations. See 50 U.S.C. § 1861. 

Does Apple consider fingerprint data to be "tangible things" as defined in the USA PATRIOT Act?

(11) Under American intelligence law, the Federal Bureau of Investigation can unilaterally issue a National Security Letter that compels telecommunications providers to disclose "subscriber information" or "electronic communication transactional records in its custody or possession." National Security Letters typically contain a gag order, meaning that recipients cannot disclose that they received the letter. See, e.g., 18 U.S.C. § 2709.

Does Apple consider fingerprint data to be "subscriber information" or "electronic communication transactional records" as defined in the Stored Communications Act?

(12) Does Apple believe that users have a reasonable expectation of privacy in fingerprint data they provide to Touch ID?

Thank you for your time and attention to these questions. I ask that Apple answer these questions within a month of receiving this letter.


Sincerely,

Al Franken

Chairman, Senate Judiciary Subcommittee

on Privacy, Technology and the Law

 

You Might Also Like

Updates


Sponsored Update

Update: 12

Tweets

 

Advertisement


Update: 11

Alleged iPhone 6 cases reflect rumored design changes, repositioned power button

Source: 9to5Mac

Apple Store Soho Presents Meet The Athlete: Pele
We’re still months away from Apple’s announcement of the  iPhone 6, but we’re already seeing ambitious manufactures designing accessories based on previous rumors. Additional silicon cases rumored to fit the iPhone 6 were recently published on NoWhereElse and provide a closer look at some of the device’s possible design changes. The case pictured above has slightly rounded edges, similar to the 5th generation iPod touch or iP ...
Source: 9to5Mac   Full article at: 9to5Mac 25 minutes ago
 

More From the Web

Update: 10

Microsoft, Apple and Google pledge to offer smartphone 'kill switch' programs in 2015

Source: Neowin

Satya Nadella Delivers Opening Keynote At Microsoft Build Conference
Microsoft, Apple and Google are among the many top hardware, software and wireless providers who have now pledged to offer access to free smartphone 'kill switch' programs af ...
Source: Neowin   Full article at: Neowin 3 hours ago
 

Update: 8

Keep Jobs' personality out of anti-poaching trial: Tech firms

Source: NDTV

BRAZIL-APPLE-STEVE JOBS
The firms said plaintiffs should not be allowed to offer evidence that Apple co-founder Steve Jobs was "a bully. ...
Source: NDTV   Full article at: NDTV 6 hours ago
 

Update: 7

Tech giants want Steve Jobs' personality out of wage-fixing suit

Source: CNet

Apple Store Soho Presents Meet The Athlete: Pele
Apple, Google, Intel, and Adobe Systems argue that the Apple co-founder’s temperament should not be fair game in the upco ...
Source: CNet   Full article at: CNet 10 hours ago
 

Update: 6

Tech giants want Steve Jobs' personality out of wage-fixing suit

Source: Car Craft

Apple Store Soho Presents Meet The Athlete: Pele
Apple, Google, Intel, and Adobe Systems argue that the Apple co-founder’s temperament should not be fair game in the up ...
Source: Car Craft   Full article at: Car Craft 10 hours ago
 

Update: 5

Local Fruit Farm Worried About Crops in Cold Weather

Source: WKEF ABC22 Dayton

Queen Sofia of Spain Visits Donana National Park
DAYTON -- The blast of cold weather over the past 24 hours has local farmers worried about their crops.  The warm weather over the weekend made buds bloom at Monnin Fruit Farm, but the brutal Winter already killed their peach crop and now they are worried about those apple buds freezing and falling off."If it had just stayed cold for a few more days, and then just stayed warm we would've been alright, ...
Source: WKEF ABC22 Dayton   Full article at: WKEF ABC22 Dayton 10 hours ago
 

Update: 4

Apple seeds OS X 10.9.3 build 13D43 to developers

Source: 9to5Mac

Apple Store Soho Presents Meet The Athlete: Pele
Approximately one week following the previous beta release, Apple has provided build 13D43 of the upcoming OS X Mavericks 10.9.3 to developers. The update is available in the Mac App Store Software Update section for those on earlier betas and can also be found on the Mac Developer Center website. Apple has not announced when 10.9.3 will be publicly released. Indications from those using the beta point to the update providin ...
Source: 9to5Mac   Full article at: 9to5Mac 11 hours ago, 6:22pm CDT
 

Update: 3

How Apple's CarPlay Could Shore Up the Car Stereo Industry

Source: Slashdot

Apple Store Soho Presents Meet The Athlete: Pele
Velcroman1 writes: "Car stereo salesmen and installers around the country are hoping Apple's CarPlay in-car infotainment system will have a big presence in the aftermarket car stereo industry. The Nikkei Asian Review reports that Alpine is making car stereo head units for between $500 – $700 that will run the iOS-like system Apple unveiled last month, and Macrumors added Clarion to the list of CarPlay supporters. Pioneer is also ge ...
Source: Slashdot   Full article at: Slashdot 11 hours ago, 6:22pm CDT
 

Update: 2

4 Reactions to Twitter's Gnip Acquisition

Source: AdWeek

Verdict Reached In Whitey Bulger Trial
Twitter's decision to purchase long-time data partner Gnip will have far-reaching implications for social media marketers, per a snap poll of industry players today. Boulder, Colo.-based Gnip is one of a limited number of vendors that access Twitter's so-called stats firehose, but it also works with data from Foursquare, Facebook, Tumblr, Instagram, YouTube, etc. What Gnip's full breadth of dat ...
Source: AdWeek   Full article at: AdWeek 11 hours ago, 6:16pm CDT
 

Update: 1

Apple, Google, Microsoft and others sign anti-phone-theft pledge

Source: The Verge

Google Glasses
A new pledge signed by nearly every major player in the phone industry is promising that after July of 2015, it will be a lot harder to steal a smartphone, according to a new report from Re/code. After that date, the companies pledge that every user will be able to remotely brick and wipe their phones in the event of a theft, features currently offered by Find my iPhone and the Android Device Manager. Apple, Google, HTC, Huawei, Motoro ...
Source: The Verge  Full article at: The Verge 11 hours ago, 6:09pm CDT
 

Shopping Deals

 
 
 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/20" rel="author">Sumayah Aamir</a>
Sumayah Aamir (Google+) has deep experience in analyzing the latest technology trends.

 

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Hot Paulina Gretzky Golf Digest Cover Shoot Video Released
Hot Paulina Gretzky Golf Digest Cover Shoot Video Released
Paulina Gretzky is on the cover Paulina Gretzky of the May issue of Golf Digest. Her sexy cover caused an uproar in the golf scene. Now Golf Digest follows up with the release of a behind the scenes video from the sexy photo shoot. Watch it below.
 
 
4K TV Line-Up Now Available for Pre-Sale by Sony
4K TV Line-Up Now Available for Pre-Sale by Sony
Sony Electronics now offers its new BRAVIA 4K Ultra HD TV line-up for pre-sale at starting price of $2,099. Sony's three new 4K TV series and total of nine models will hit market in June 2014. Sony also offers 4K Media Player and 4K Content options with its 4K TVs that gives users a complete 4K Ultra HD home entertainment experience.
 
 
Equinix Is Productizing Flash Trading Computing Architecture
Equinix Is Productizing Flash Trading Computing Architecture
In his new book, Flash Boys, Michael Lewis directs his gleeful analytic spotlight on flash trading. True to form, Lewis tells a heroic story, in this case about how a team from Royal Bank of Canada found a defense for...
 
 
World&#039;s Toughest Job Video is Awesome Tribute to Moms
World's Toughest Job Video is Awesome Tribute to Moms
A new viral video celebrates moms in a cool way. A company interviews job applicants for the World's Toughest Job: Unlimited hours, No breaks, etc. Watch the video below and do not forget Mother's Day 2014!
 
 
 

The Hottest Photos of Victoria's Secret Fashion Show 2013