Filed under: News | Misc


Google Wins Book-Scanning Lawsuit with ‘Fair Use’ Ruling

A book scanning lawsuit that a group of authors had brought against Google has finally ended in the search engine’s favor. Judge states many benefits of the Google book scanning and called it a 'fair use'. It had been dragging on for eight years.

Nov 15 2013, 3:57am CST | by

12 Updates
Google Wins Book-Scanning Lawsuit with ‘Fair Use’ Ruling
Image Credit: Google

YouTube Videos Tweets Comments

Full Story

Google Wins Book-Scanning Lawsuit with ‘Fair Use’ Ruling

Various disgruntled authors had joined hands to collectively sue Google for what they perceived to be copyright infringement. The lawsuit they filed against Google claimed that the search engine giant had scanned excerpts from over 20 million books without the prior permission of the authors. 

Google began the practice as a part of its book project. The execs at Google defended themselves by saying that it was a catalogue system to help the public identify books they wanted to later on buy. But the group of writers said that the snippets excerpts were lent to online browsers free of charge and without any express allowance by the authors. The judge however ruled in favor of Google. 

US Circuit Judge Denny Chin issued his ruling on Thursday morning in New York. He said, “In my view, Google Books provides significant public benefits. It advances the progress of the arts and sciences, while maintaining respectful consideration for the rights of authors and other creative individuals, and without adversely impacting the rights of copyright holders. It has become an invaluable research tool that permits students, teachers, librarians, and others to more efficiently identify and locate books. It has given scholars the ability, for the first time, to conduct full-text searches of tens of millions of books. It preserves books, in particular out-of-print and old books that have been forgotten in the bowels of libraries, and it gives them new life. It facilitates access to books for print-disabled and remote or underserved populations. It generates new audiences and creates new sources of income for authors and publishers. Indeed, all society benefits.

Freedom of information has been a controversial topic. The debate began with the inception of the Internet which has decentralized the process of information relay. What was once withheld from public scrutiny is now there for everyone to peruse in cyberspace. Google laid out the facts plainly for all to see. It had no such intention of treading on the rights of the writers. 

The excerpts and blurbs did not constitute copyright theft in any way. The judge said that since it was a cultural service that Google was rendering, the case went in its favor. However, the authors are still angry and want to appeal the case in a higher court. 

In an emailed statement, Author’s Guild Executive Director Paul Aiken said, “We disagree with and are disappointed by the court’s decision today. This case presents a fundamental challenge to copyright that merits review by a higher court. Google made unauthorized digital editions of nearly all of the world’s valuable copyright-protected literature and profits from displaying those works. In our view, such mass digitization and exploitation far exceeds the bounds of the fair use defense.

The people at Google were overjoyed to hear the news that the decision went in their favor. Google states in an email, “This has been a long road and we are absolutely delighted with today’s judgement. As we have long said Google Books is in compliance with copyright law and acts like a card catalog for the digital age – giving users the ability to find books to buy or borrow.

Source: GigaOm, Wired


You Might Also Like


Sponsored Update

Update: 12




Update: 11

Cleveland Browns NFL Draft Profile: UCF QB Blake Bortles

Source: Rant Sports

2014 NFL Combine
Getty Images The NFL Draft is less than three weeks away, which means NFL pundits are going crazy seeking scoops and insider information. The Cleveland Browns have been at the top of the list when it comes to the NFL Draft guessing game. While it’s certain that the Browns will select a quarterback with one of their two first-round choices, the questions is “who”. One possibility at the No. 4 spot is UCF quarterback Blake Bortles. Bortles, a ...
Source: Rant Sports   Full article at: Rant Sports 12 minutes ago

More From the Web

Update: 10

Chicago Blackhawks’ Jonathan Toews, Patrick Kane Look Exhausted in Game 1

Source: Rant Sports

Chicago Blackhawks v Ottawa Senators
Rob Grabowski-USA TODAY Sports After a heartbreaking 4-3 loss to the St. Louis Blues in triple overtime of Game 1, the Chicago Blackhawks have bigger things to worry about than simply being down 1-0 in the series. Jonathan Toews and Patrick Kane were non-existent after the first period. It’s probably fair to write this off as the two players simply not being in ideal game form yet, but that in itself is a major problem; with the Blackhawks already down 1-0 with another game to play in St. Louis ...
Source: Rant Sports   Full article at: Rant Sports 29 minutes ago

Update: 8

New York Yankees Use Game of Threes in Momentous Win

Source: Rant Sports

New York Yankees v Toronto Blue Jays
Getty Images Thursday night’s game between the New York Yankees and Tampa Bay Rays in St. Petersburg, Fla. was propelling for the visitors as the Yankees exploited the number three to help the team top the struggling Rays. A game of rarities was on display early when Brian Roberts blasted a triple to deep center which scored Scott Sizemore in the top of the second. Sizemore reached base with his third hit of the season. Jacoby Ellsbury made it a trend ...
Source: Rant Sports   Full article at: Rant Sports 46 minutes ago

Update: 7

Is Big Tech A Bad Investment Bet?

Source: Business Balla

Google Glasses
Intel, IBM, and Google reported recent quarterly results that were not thrilling. But this does not mean that they are all bad investments. After all, in the last year sh ...
Source: Business Balla   Full article at: Business Balla 1 hour ago

Update: 6

How to Identify Non-Ranking URL Page Types Using Google Site Search

Source: Search Engine Watch

Google Glasses
Crawling a site isn't necessarily the best first step when auditing a website, because it's hard to quantify and prioritize that data in a way that makes sense to clients. Here's how to use Google site search ...
Source: Search Engine Watch   Full article at: Search Engine Watch 1 hour ago

Update: 5

MLB.TV Plays Ball With Google’s Chromecast

Source: Broadcasting & Cable

Google Glasses
The lineup for Google’s popular Chromecast streaming adapter is still small, but it’s growing. The latest service to be optimized for the device is MLB.TV, the out-of-market Major League Baseball streaming service that features both yearly and monthly subscriptions. ...
Source: Broadcasting & Cable   Full article at: Broadcasting & Cable 1 hour ago

Update: 4

Chrome OS may kill the password with Easy Unlock smartphone option

Source: PC World

Google Glasses
Google may be opening a new front on the war against the password with a smartphone-enabled unlock option for Chrome OS PCs. Dubbed Easy Unlock, the new test feature would "instantly unlock your Chromebook when you and your phone are nearby, no password necessary."Easy Unlock is currently available in the dev channel of Chrome OS, but it isn't fully baked yet so it's not possible to try it out, according to Androi ...
Source: PC World  Full article at: PC World 1 hour ago

Update: 3

New report says sub-$100 Google Nexus smartphone is coming

Source: BGR

Google Glasses
Google may be working on a new kind of Nexus device that could be even more affordable than its predecessors, a new report from Asia says. However, the device won’t be a high-end model like the others, but rather an entry- to mid-range device that would sell for under $100, thus being significantly more affordable than any previous Nexus handsets. ...
Source: BGR   Full article at: BGR 1 hour ago

Update: 2

Is Big Tech A Bad Investment Bet?

Source: Forbes

Google Glasses
Intel, IBM, and Google reported recent quarterly results that were not thrilling. But this does not mean that they are all bad investments. After all, in the last year shares of Google (up 37%) and Intel (up 24%) have performed well; whereas those of IBM (down 10%) have been m ...
Source: Forbes   Full article at: Forbes 1 hour ago

Update: 1

FSS Google Maps Downloader (Ad-supported)

Source: Softpedia

Google Glasses
A easy to use tool designed to provide you with a simple method for downloading Google maps and saving them to your computer in JPG format ( ...
Source: Softpedia   Full article at: Softpedia 1 hour ago

Shopping Deals


<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/20" rel="author">Sumayah Aamir</a>
Sumayah Aamir (Google+) has deep experience in analyzing the latest technology trends.




blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Apple Building Identification Feature Into iTunes
Apple Building Identification Feature Into iTunes
Future iOS devices will include a built in Shazam powered service
Joan of Shark Tagged as one of the Largest Shark
Joan of Shark Tagged as World's Largest Shark
A shark that has been tagged recently, Joan of Shark, is slated to be one of the largest great white sharks ever seen. It has a length that is in excess of 16 feet.
Nike&#039;s Air Jordan Bran Introduces Jordan XX9
Jordan XX9 Introduced
Nike's Air Jordan brand as introduced 29th iteration of its franchise called Jordan XX9. Air Jordan XX9 is the world’s first basketball shoe to be tailored for flight. It will hit store shelves in September at cost price of around $225.
Mrs. Doubtfire Sequel about to Amuse Audiences
Mrs. Doubtfire Sequel about to Amuse Audiences
A sequel to the highly popular movie Mrs. Doubtfire is about to come on the scene soon. It will amuse audiences to no end.

The Hottest Photos of Victoria's Secret Fashion Show 2013