Trending

Filed under: News | Misc

 

NSA Used 1976 Robbery Case to Justify Spying

NSA has used the 1976 Baltimore robbery case to justify today's global government surveillance. Do this small-time 1976 robbery case really provide legal base for NSA spying?

Dec 18 2013, 7:27am CST | by

6 Updates
NSA Used 1976 Robbery Case to Justify Spying
 
 

YouTube Videos Comments

Full Story

NSA Used 1976 Robbery Case to Justify Spying

The National Security Agency has used a small robbery case as its justification for spying. The 1976 Baltimore case actually laid the legal grounds for today's global government surveillance. NSA has defended the agency’s spying policy against the rants of the critics. According to General Keith Alexander, the collection of metadata is the only method of gaining access to the terrorists.  

The director of the NSA has said that there is no better methodology of getting the terrorists among us than to track the telephone calls of Americans. Though it was an invasion of privacy yet it was a necessary step too. And NSA is using a 1976 robbery case as its justification for the collection of "metadata". How can the 1976 Baltimore purse-snatching case be relevant to NSA spying. 

Actually in 1976, the Supreme Court allowed the government to collect the phone records of purse-snatcher Michael Lee Smith for the provision of robbery evidences. And after the 9/11 attacks, NSA is using this case as legal reference for collecting telephone records of Americans and foreigners to protect the U.S. from terrorists. Hence the 1976 Baltimore robbery case is being used by US government for global surveillance.

According to the NSA General, metadata collection was the least bothersome way of gathering the necessary data about people. He also spoke of how it was a crucial step in defending the United States against its enemies. Though it was a feeble attempt at justifying what was essentially against the law of the land, General Keith Alexander was adamant. He said that if anyone could come up with a better idea he or she ought to suggest it. Unfortunately, there were none. 

However, the federal judge and even the prosecutor of the 1976 Baltimore robbery case are not favoring NSA for using such small-time old case for global government surveillance. "To say that a small-time robbery on the street is a precedent for what was then unforeseen and massive electronic surveillance is simply a stretch, to put it mildly," says former Maryland Attorney General Stephen H. Sachs, who defended the government's use of phone records to arrest and convict Smith. "For present purposes, you have to say that the trapping of information from one suspect is different, for God's sake, than trapping the data of every American who uses a telephone or the Internet. There's a distinction of volume, of context. But that's what the Supreme Court is going to have to decide."

Source: Yahoo Finance via AP

 

You Might Also Like

Updates


Sponsored Update

Update: 6

At press club event, Scalia and Ginsburg offer differing views on government surveillance

Source: TBD.com

Antonin Scalia, Associate Justice of the
WASHINGTON (AP) - The legality of government surveillance is likely to come before the Supreme Court someday, and Justices Antonin Scalia and Ruth Bader Ginsburg appear less than thrilled at the prospect. Scalia thinks the judicial branch is the least qualified government branch to balance security and intrusion. Scalia and Ginsburg, two long-time friends, aired their differing views of First Amendment rights Thursday night at the ...
Source: TBD.com   Full article at: TBD.com 1 day ago, 6:59am CDT
 


Advertisement


Update: 5

Post, Guardian win Pulitzers for NSA revelations

Source: Lebanon Daily Star

Journalists Glenn Greenwald And Lauren Poitras Receive A George Polk Award
The Washington Post and The Guardian won the Pulitzer Prize in public service for revealing the U.S. government's sweeping surveillance programs in a blockbuster series of stories based on secret documents s ...
Source: Lebanon Daily Star   Full article at: Lebanon Daily Star 4 days ago, 12:22pm CDT
 

More From the Web

Update: 4

Edward Snowden ‘vindicated’: Pulitzer Prize awarded to papers for stories based on files from NSA leaker

Source: National Post

The Washington Post and The Guardian won the Pulitzer Prize in public service Monday for revealing the U.S. government’s sweeping surveillance programs in a blockbuster series of stories based on secret documents supplied by NSA leaker Edward Snowden. The Pulitzer for breaking news was awarded to The Boston Globe for its “exhaustive and empathetic” coverage of the Boston Marathon bombing and the manhunt that followed. Two of the nation’s biggest and most distinguished newspapers, T ...
Source: National Post   Full article at: National Post 4 days ago, 7:12pm CDT
 

Update: 2

Snowden reporting lands Guardian and Post Pulitzers

Source: Ars Technica

Journalists Glenn Greenwald And Lauren Poitras Receive A George Polk Award
Edward Snowden The Nation Institute The 2014 Pulitzer Public Service Award for "meritorious public service by a newspaper or news site" was awarded Monday to the UK-based publication The Guardian and the US-based publication The Washington Post for their reporting on documents provided to them by National Security Agency whistleblower Edward Snowden. The two publications are being honored for their "revelation of widespread secret survei ...
Source: Ars Technica   Full article at: Ars Technica 4 days ago, 3:30pm CDT
 

Update: 1

Snowden: NSA lies about me not trying to spur internal investigation

Source: Russia Today

Bundeswehr Holds Alpine Adventure Camp 2014
Ahead of a 20,000-word article on the former NSA analyst expected to be published later this week, the US-based magazine has released excerpts from an interview with Snowden in which he specifically calls for the intelligence agency to come clean about allegations concerning any complaints he may have made before he began to leak classified documents to the press. Snowden, 30, said last month in testimony delivered to the European Parliament that he spoke up to "more than 1 ...
Source: Russia Today   Full article at: Russia Today Apr 9 2014, 11:21am CDT
 

Shopping Deals

 
 
 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/20" rel="author">Sumayah Aamir</a>
Sumayah Aamir (Google+) has deep experience in analyzing the latest technology trends.

 

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Nike is Not Shutting Down FuelBand, But Facing Downslide in Wearable Devices
Nike is Not Shutting Down FuelBand, But Facing Downslide in Wearable Devices
Nike has not stopped its FuelBand production. However, it seems to be facing a downslide in the department of wearable devices.
 
 
Peaches Geldof to be Laid to Rest on Easter Monday
Peaches Geldof to be Laid to Rest on Easter Monday
Peaches Geldof is to be laid to rest soon after her sudden death due to unknown causes. Some say that after being incinerated, her remains will be spread in the soil surrounding her family residence. On the other hand Peaches Geldof may be buried.
 
 
Padma Lakshmi Shows Bad Taste in Fashion
Padma Lakshmi Shows Bad Taste in Fashion
The otherwise slim and smart Padma Lakshmi showed bad taste in fashion with her latest ensemble. The midriff baring look simply did not make her appear as presentable as she ought to have been.
 
 
Idris Elba Welcomes Son Winston Elba
Idris Elba Becomes Dad Again
British actor Idris Elba has become a dad again. Elba’s girlfriend Naiyana Garth gave birth to a baby boy, named Winston Elba, on Thursday.
 
 
 

The Hottest Photos of Victoria's Secret Fashion Show 2013