Latest News: Technology |  Celebrity |  Movies |  Apple |  Cars |  Business |  Sports |  TV Shows |  Geek


Filed under: News


A Danger Lurks In The Righteous War Against Patent Trolls

Dec 23 2013, 7:36am CST | by

10 Updates


Recommend Your Tweet as Top Tweet:

Full Story

A Danger Lurks In The Righteous War Against Patent Trolls

Judging from events that have already occurred, and others that soon will occur, righteous forces are gathered against patent trolls as never before. It is an impassioned pursuit of a coherent legal culture to ensure real innovativeness, and to protect companies from extortion practiced by predatory business ventures.

Earlier this year, new proposals from the White House, including seven legislative recommendations and five executive actions, were hailed as healthy follow-up in the wake of the landmark Leahy-Smith America Invents Act (AIA). There’s always been consensus on the need for action, even among those who distrust big corporations that are the typical victims. Heretofore, though, judicial and legislative reform simply moved slower than the R&D held hostage by the trolls.

Yet as I have written in these pages , the real igniter of reform may well be the fact that hotels or coffee shops with Wi-Fi, or for that matter anyone who owns a computer, can be targeted . They’re the voting stakeholders who have compelled politicians to take action. Troll-related litigation costs to small business now total in the millions. (The aggregate drain caused by the trolls is estimated at $29 billion .)

In any event, the war on trolls has progressed apace since we last visited the topic. In early December, the House of Representatives overwhelmingly passed the Innovation Act , and the Senate will be turning to it within weeks. Among its provisions are significant new limits on discovery, a green light for courts to shift legal costs to the losing side (“losers pay”), and a stay of legal action against defendants’ customers.

Equally encouraging to the reformers, the Supreme Court agreed to rule on what inventions are eligible for patent protection. At issue here are the patents granted in the last decade by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) for broad business-process and software. Critics argue that those patents are untenably vague and therefore provide frivolously easy causes of action for the trolls.

It’s a purported abuse rooted in the 1998 State Street Bank case in which the Federal Circuit ruled that algorithm-based business methods are patentable. Since then, it’s been a federal court-by-federal court adventure. Most notably, in the 2007 Alice Corporation v. CLS Bank case, a ten-member Federal Circuit panel issued seven disparate opinions. It is this case that SCOTUS will rule on in 2014.

Meanwhile, global and local forces are now arrayed against the trolls. New Zealand overhauled its system to ensure that software cannot be patented. Stateside, Nebraska’s attorney general threatened one troll with legal consequences if it violates local unfair competition law by targeting area companies, while Vermont passed an anti-troll bill to help those unfairly accused of infringement counter-sue their adversaries for bad-faith litigation. Presumably, bad faith is an easier charge to make stick against patent holders who never use the technology they “own,” nor show any likelihood of doing so.

Such anti-troll activism will likely be tested in courts but, in a sense, it doesn’t matter. The forces are gathered at both the grassroots and in the corridors of power – and they won’t demobilize, period. The powers of historical inevitability have taken over. Isn’t that all good?

Well, almost.

The problem is that, in our collective zeal to disincentive extortion, we tend to assume that any small company is a troll if it holds a patent it hasn’t used, and is suing a big company that has. By such a generic and, in the current climate, perhaps inevitable expansion of the term “patent trolls,” universities can fall under the stigma, as can small- or medium-sized companies working to develop new products.

Take VirnetX as an example. Its founders were government think tank members who developed a patent portfolio while working under contract for the CIA. They labored on government salaries for years with few benefits other than the opportunity to take their patents with them when they left.

“Some companies now call VirnetX a patent troll because they don’t see it as having been successful with its product,” says Jason Cassady , a partner at Caldwell Cassady & Curry who represents VirnetX. (Full disclosure: My firm has a business relationship with Caldwell Cassady & Curry. We do not have a business relationship with VirnetX.)

Even VirnetX’s Wiki page has been edited to label it a “non-practicing entity .” So, when VirnetX sued Apple for infringement over network security technology, it seemed a prototypical case of a troll going after a fat mark. This time, however, the case went to trial (which trolls typically avoid like the plague) and the jury awarded the plaintiff $368 million. Cassady believes it is the largest judgment ever in a patent case against Apple. The verdict was upheld this February by a U.S. District Court.

It wasn’t VirnetX’s first sortie against the behemoths. The company had likewise looked like a troll without being one when it sued Microsoft in 2010 for patent infringement, also involving virtual private network technology. Here too, the case went to trial and the jury awarded VirnetX $105 million in a willful infringement verdict. The case then settled.

True, the willingness to go to trial is a strong sign that the plaintiff is not likely a troll. However, the danger is that too many meritorious claims may fall by the wayside as the multi-level crusade against trolls gains steam. “We’re trivializing what a patent troll is and what it’s not,” says Cassady. “Someone who’s trying to build something in the American way – struggling to enter the market and depending on their property rights in order to protect their investment of time and money – they are called a derogatory name and face uphill legal battles in courts of law and the Court of Public Opinion.”

If VirnetX’s good fortune is the exception that proves the rule, we have a cautionary lesson here for lawmakers, tribunals, and the public. What now seems like a war waged on behalf of innovation is being fought with a double-edged sword, as the entrepreneurs who are our most innovative trailblazers may actually wind up casualties once all the dust clears.

And that couldn’t possibly be what Congress and the President want to accomplish./>/>

Follow Richard Levick on Twitter  and circle him on Google+ , where he comments daily on regulatory issues and financial industry communications.

Richard Levick, Esq., Chairman and CEO of LEVICK , which provides public relations and communications counsel to companies throughout the world on public affairs-related issues. Mr. Levick was honored for the past four years on NACD Directorship’s list of “The 100 Most Influential People in the Boardroom ,” and has been named to multiple professional Halls of Fame for lifetime achievement. He is the co-author of three books, including The Communicators: Leadership in the Age of Crisis , and is a regular commentator on television, in print, and on the most widely read business blogs.

Source: Forbes


iPad Air Giveaway. Win a free iPad Air.

You Might Also Like


Sponsored Update

Update: 10

GLCs told to provide RM7 billion to develop Bumiputera firms

Source: Malaysia Today

EurAsia Cup presented by DRB-HICOM - Day One
(The Malaysian Insider) – Putrajaya has directed government-linked companies (GLC) to generate RM7 billion in business opportunities for Bumiputera firms this year, Prime Minister Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak... READ MO ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today 5 days ago, 2:05am CDT


Update: 9

Rafizi shows proof of Putrajaya’s hand in contentious carpet-trader loan

Source: Malaysia Today

Eileen Ng, The Malaysian Insider PKR lawmaker Rafizi Ramli today revealed documents to prove Putrajaya interfered in the RM32 million Bank Rakyat loan to ‎controversial businessman Deepak Jaikish ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today 6 days ago, 2:16am CDT

More From the Web

Update: 8

PAS MP claims Bank Rakyat loaned carpet-trader RM215m, interest free

Source: Malaysia Today

(Malay Mail Online) – Controversial businessman Deepak Jaikishan (pic) was given a whopping RM215 million interest-free loan from state-owned Bank Rakyat, a PAS lawmaker alleged today, despite Putrajaya’s claims ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today Jul 14 2014, 5:52am CDT

Update: 7

MRCB, Nusa Gapurna and PKNS settle suit over RM3 billion PJ Sentral project

Source: Malaysia Today

(The Malaysian Insider) – Malaysian Resources Corp Bhd (MRCB), Nusa Gapurna Development Sdn Bhd (NGD) and PKNS Holdings Sdn Bhd have reached an out-of-court settlement over the ownership of th ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today Jun 21 2014, 2:53am CDT

Update: 6

Story behind Syed Mokhtar’s ‘RM2.25 billion tax-exempt’ Bernas deal revealed, says PKR MP

Source: Malaysia Today

(The Malaysian Insider) – An innocuous written reply in Parliament has provided a peek into the cosy relationship between the Najib administration and Malaysia’s best-known businessman, Tan Sri Syed Mokhtar... READ MORE ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today Jun 15 2014, 12:56pm CDT

Update: 5

Constitutional monarchy still murky concept

Source: Malaysia Today

After the RM4.5 billion land sale, the Sultan of Johor secured a 15% stake in MOL Access Portal (MOL) for RM396 million and took a 20% stake in Berjaya Times... READ M ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today Jun 14 2014, 12:37am CDT

Update: 4

Sultan of Johor’s RM4.5 bil backlash?

Source: Malaysia Today

"GOLDEN ASIA" Tokyo Premiere Press Conference
Has Sultan Ibrahim of Johor’s succession of big money deals over the last six months caused the tide of public opinion to turn against Johor’s royal palace? K ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today Jun 11 2014, 8:49am CDT

Update: 3

Putrajaya denies carpet dealer given interest-free loan

Source: Malaysia Today

Eileen Ng, The Malaysian Insider Putrajaya today refuted allegations that Bank Rakyat had allowed carpet dealer Deepak Jaikishan to repay a RM32 million loan without interest following intervention from a. ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today Jun 11 2014, 5:44am CDT

Update: 2

Malaysia Spends Over $9 million on MH370 Hunt: Report

Source: NDTV

"GOLDEN ASIA" Tokyo Premiere Press Conference
Malaysia has so far spent about RM27.6 million (over $9 million) on search operations for missing Malaysia Airlines flight MH370, an official said on Mon ...
Source: NDTV   Full article at: NDTV Jun 9 2014, 3:12am CDT

Update: 1

Bill for Kidex likely to soar to RM3.4b

Source: Malaysia Today

The original RM2.4 billion tag on the proposed highway did not take into account the cost of acquiring the land mostly in the urban areas, claims an assemblywoman Fabian Comeliu ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today Jun 9 2014, 2:51am CDT

Shopping Deals


<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/31" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.




blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Leah Rimini Attacks Jennifer Lopez
Leah Rimini Attacks Jennifer Lopez
This is hilarious. Watch Leah Rimini attacking Jennifer Lopez while on vacation.
Robert Downey Jr. Again Tops Forbes&#039; List Of Highest Earning Actors
Robert Downey Jr. Again Tops Forbes' List Of Highest Earning Actors
Iron Man star Robert Downey Jr. maintained his top position on the Forbes' list Of 2014's highest earning actors with $75 million. Amazingly, Downey earns this whooping amount without starring in any movies this year.
Twickets App Review
Twickets App Review
Twickets is a UK-based service that allows individuals who no longer require the ticket of a certain event to connect with any person who needs it. Instead of getting rid of the ticket, Twicket can find you a suitable buyer.
Bio Inc. Game Review
Bio Inc. Game Review
Bio Inc. Biomedical Simulator is a revolutionary game that has been developed by the illustrious DryGin Studios. With no more than a week after its official release, it is a game that will enable you to have the first-hand experience of maneuvering with numerous infections on a victim’s body.

About the Geek Mind

Read more about The Geek Mind.