Trending

Filed under: News

 

Me Myself I: Ten Songs for Narcissistic CEOs

Jan 10 2014, 2:51pm CST | by

Me Myself I: Ten Songs for Narcissistic CEOs
Photo Credit: Forbes
 
 
 

Narcissism and chief executives are much in the news of late. Maybe it’s a hangover from the financial crisis or continuing fallout from Enron and other financial scandals. There certainly seems to be a growing interest in how proud, vain, self-obsessed, extroverted and otherwise – dare to say it – interesting characters are running our companies.

In the latest study, highlighted in The Washington Post, Alex Frino, dean of Macquarie Graduate School of Management in Sydney, ran natural language technology on quarterly earning call transcripts of America’s largest companies to calculate the ratio between CEOs’ use of  individual personal pronouns such as “I”,” me” and “mine” and collective pronouns such as “we” and “our”.

Frino was too modest to publish who came top, preferring to name Pat Gelsinger of VMware, Gregg Steinhafel of Target and Omar Ishrak of Medtronic as the three least narcissistic by that measurement, just ahead of Lockheed Martin’s Marillyn Hewson and PepsiCo’s Indra Nooyi.

However, he has taken such research to the next stage, comparing findings of such research with company performance in an Australian version of the study. Over 18 months, he found that the annualised stock returns of a group of large Australian companies headed by the least narcissistic chief executives were nearly twice that of the group of most narcissistic CEOs.

This dovetails with two academic studies published in October and highlighted by Tomas Chamorro-Premuzic, professor of business psychology at University of London in a recent Huffington Post blog entitled: “The Dark Side of Executive Narcissism: How CEOs Destroy Companies, Reputation and Employee Morale”.

In “Narcissus Enters the Courtroom: CEO Narcissism and Fraud”  Antoinette Rijsenbilt and Harry Commandeur of Erasmus University, Rotterdam, compared narcissism levels of 953 chief executives with the performances of their companies. They concluded that firms led by arrogant, self-centred CEOs tended to perform worse and – worryingly – were much likely to be convicted of corporate fraud.

Taking the opposite approach, “Expressed Humility in Organizations: Implications for Performance, Teams and Leadership,” by Bradley Owens, of the State University of New York in Buffalo and colleagues from the University of Washington in Seattle looked at the effects of humble leadership on staff morale and turnover.

They found that the most effective way to engage employees is not to rouse them through energetic, charismatic and idealistic leadership but to quietly listen, be clear about limitations and show appreciation for staff strengths and contributions. In other words, suggests Chamorro-Premuzic, “Narcissistic CEOs may be good at attracting talent but they are probably better at repelling it.”

If taken seriously, this may spell trouble for CEOs including Google’s Larry Page and Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg. They came top last September in a study by Ironfire Capital managing partner and Forbes contributor Eric Jackson of the number of times technology CEOs used “I”, “my”, “me” and “mine” as a percentage of the total of words used in questions and answers at their last four quarterly earnings calls.

On the other hand, research last August by Donald Hambrick of Penn State’s Smeal College of Business and colleagues from Germany’s University of Erlangen-Nuremberg and IMD International concluded that corporate chief executives showing narcissistic personality traits are more likely to embrace disruptive technologies than their less self-interested CEO counterparts.

Where do all these academic studies take us? Can such judgments really be made from the grammatical vocabulary employed by chief executives in off-the-cuff answers to financial questions? If so, do we want boring leaders, rather than glitzy extroverts at the helm of the world’s biggest companies? Are leaders with a cult of personality like the late Steve Jobs at Apple exceptions to the rule and if so, is the rule worth observing in the first place?

That debate will continue for some while yet so let my contribution be marrying this body of thought with that of Forbes contributor Ruth Blatt, of the University of Michigan. In a recent Forbes blog entitled “Sick of Sports: Why Rock Bands Are a Better Metaphor for Work Teams,” she argues that the language from the creative teamwork of song-writing and musicianship is more appropriate for business use than tired old phrases from the winner and loser mentality of sports.TIn that spirit and also for a bit of fun, I present a playlist of ten songs for narcissistic leaders and an alternative for humble CEO types. The next time you analyse a potentially narcissistic chief executive, check his iTunes usage. Mr Gelsinger’s probably shows up a penchant for Vangelis as he told me when I interviewed him that his favourite movie is Chariots of Fire. His favourite book meanwhile, is The Bible. I’d love to see the personal pronoun ratios for that.

Ten Songs for Narcissistic CEOs

I and I – Bob Dylan

Me Myself I – Joan Armatrading

I Me Mine – The Beatles

I Am What I Am – Gloria Gaynor

It’s All About Me – Chelsea Staub

What About Me? – Moving Pictures

I Love Myself – Chris Brown

I Am Superman – REM

Leader of the Pack – Gary Glitter

Don’t Stop Me Now – Queen

And Ten For Humble Leaders

This Is Not About Me – The Boo Radleys

It’s All About You – McFly

I Am Nothing- Katatonia

Nothing Compares to You – Sinead O’Connor

We Are What We Are – The Other Ones

We’re All In This Together – High School Musical

Us and Them – Pink Floyd

Come Together – The Beatles

Let’s Stay Together – Al Green

Are We All We Are? – Pink

Do contribute your own favourites and follow me here and on Twitter @Andycave

Source: Forbes

You Might Also Like

Updates

Shopping Deals

 
 
 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/31" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Al-Qaida Militants Killed Soldiers in Algeria
Al-Qaida Militants Killed Soldiers in Algeria
Al-Qaida militants killed 14 Algerian soldiers on Saturday night in an ambush.
 
 
Judy Greer Celebrates her Planet of the Apes Wedding
Judy Greer Celebrates her Planet of the Apes Wedding
Judy Greer celebrated her Planet of the Apes-themed wedding. She is to appear in Dawn of the Planet of the Apes soon.
 
 
Emotient&#039;s Sentiment Analysis app.for Google Glass
Emotient's Sentiment Analysis app for Google Glass
The app lets you know what people around you are feeling
 
 
Retirement Plans that get translated into Reality
Retirement Plans: Tips for Choosing a Retirement Plan
When a middle aged couple makes retirement plans, they want to make sure that they get translated into reality. That is exactly what this article will allow you to accomplish.
 
 
 

The Hottest Photos of Victoria's Secret Fashion Show 2013

 

Viral Stories the Web