Latest News: Technology |  Celebrity |  Movies |  Apple |  Cars |  Business |  Sports |  TV Shows |  Geek

Trending

Filed under: News | Cars & Vehicles

 

Is the BMW i3 In Trouble In California Already?

Jan 23 2014, 2:10am CST | by

11 Updates
Is the BMW i3 In Trouble In California Already?
 
 

YouTube Videos Comments

Full Story

Is the BMW i3 In Trouble In California Already?

An article from TheStreet.com  has declared that just as the i3 is launching , a “critical BMW selling point has been removed, resulting in a huge victory for Tesla as well as BMW’s other competitors.”  The BMW i3 comes in two variations: a battery electric version and a range extended version (called the i3 REx ).  The reporter, Anton Wahlman, observes that the BMW i3 REx will not qualify for a white carpool lane sticker in California.  That’s perceived by Wahlman to be a huge disadvantage for BMW.  Is it really?

First, a primer on California carpool lane stickers is needed here.  There are two carpool lane stickers available  in California.  White HOV access stickers are reserved for vehicles that meet federal Inherently Low Emissions Vehicle (ILEV)  standards and green HOV access stickers are reserved for qualifying Advanced Technology Partial Zero Emission Vehicles (AT PZEVs).  The California Air Resources Board (CARB) maintains a list of vehicles that qualify for these designations.  (As an aside, the still well-recognized yellow HOV access stickers adorning the back of many a Toyota Prius in California have now sunset and are no longer available.)

Wahlman reports that BMW was workingwith California’s regulatory bureaucrats to create a new class of car” that would qualify the i3 REx for a white sticker.  However, in conversations with CARB, I’ve learned that this is not necessarily the case.  The Street is likely referring to the regulatory category Range Extended Battery Electric Vehicle (BEVx) that was added in January 2012 .  Regardless of whether in regulatory vernacular the vehicle is a BEVx or not, in order to qualify for a white sticker the vehicle has to qualify for the federal ILEV certification.  CARB told me that BMW has worked with them over the last couple years on several different iterations of the i3 REx prior to launch and it wasn’t clear whether the vehicle would qualify for the ILEV certification.  However, the bottom line is that, in its current form, the REx does not qualify for the ILEV certification and, therefore, does not qualify for the white sticker (the i3 without the range extender, however, does qualify for the white sticker because it is all electric without emissions).

Competing With Tesla?

Wahlman does correctly point out that there is a limit of 40,000 green stickers available, and the CARB website indicates that “as of November 8, 2013, 24,452 ‘green’ stickers have been issued.”  When these will run out is a pretty good question, though at the pace that Chevrolet Volts and Prius Plug-ins (both of which qualify for green stickers) have been selling in California, it’s a safe bet that they won’t be available this time next year.

So, is the BMW i3 dead on arrival in California, as The Street would have one believe?  Far from it.  First of all, the question really comes down to this: What will be the take rate of the i3 REx versus the i3 all electric version?  Wahlman claims that the i3 REx is “likely what most prospective BMW i3 customers wanted,” but I’m not sure how he came to that conclusion.  In fact, I suspect the all-electric version will outsell the REx in California, regardless of HOV access – in part, because the performance of REx  hasn’t been getting the same rave reviews as the all-electric version , but also because it’s almost $4,000 higher in price .

Then, there is the question of whether this is a coup for Tesla.  Competitively speaking, the i3 with the range extender is still almost $25,000 less than a Model S, and the two cars have significantly different body styles.  Are they competitors?  To some degree, yes, because the EV market is still small.  But in the increasingly mature market, they are likely competing in the same way a BMW 328 Grand Turismo  competes with a Mercedes E-Class .  The small i3 hatchback will be a fit for some lifestyles (and wallets), while others will need the larger Model S.  While BMW may have been hoping for white stickers for the i3 REx, this hardly qualifies as a major setback for BMW – and it’s probably something they knew was coming.

Source: Forbes

 

iPad Air Giveaway. Win a free iPad Air.

You Might Also Like

Updates


Sponsored Update

Update: 11

2015 BMW 2-Series Active Tourer: More Details Announced

Source: Green Car Reports

BMW International Open - Day Four
BMWs are big, aggressive gas-guzzlers, right? Not so much, in recent months. The BMW i3 electric car is already finding fans, as is the plug-in hybrid i8. And while the new BMW 2-Series Active Tourer doesn't have electric drive on its side, the small, front-wheel drive BMW compact car certainly marks a departure from BMWs of old. It's engine... ...
Source: Green Car Reports   Full article at: Green Car Reports 6 days ago, 6:30am CDT
 


Advertisement


Update: 10

Tesla’s Model III To Take On BMW’s i3

Source: bidness etc

Tesla Launches Supercharger Stations On German Highway
Rumors about Tesla Motors Inc.’s (TSLA) planning to challenge competitor Bayerische Motoren Werke AG (BMW) have proven true after CEO Elon Musk’s said Tesla’s Model III would directly compete with the BMW i3, according to an interview in Auto Express. Tesla’s ‘Model III’, expected to launch in 2017, has a range of 200 miles and is priced at $35,000. The company plans to produce lithium-ion batteries in its ‘Gigafactory’ for Model III, which will make the car m ...
Source: bidness etc   Full article at: bidness etc Jul 17 2014, 10:02am CDT
 

More From the Web

Update: 9

2014 BMW i3: Is Range Extended Version Outselling Battery Only?

Source: Hybrid SUV Reports

The BMW i3 Global Reveal Event
The 2014 BMW i3 electric car has a unique feature offered by no other vehicle in the world: Buyers can choose to have it as a battery-electric vehicle, or add an optional range-extending engine that roughly doubles its rated electric range of 81 miles. With the i3 on sale now for two months, a mix of the t ...
Source: Hybrid SUV Reports   Full article at: Hybrid SUV Reports Jul 17 2014, 8:00am CDT
 

Update: 7

Audi sharpens electric car plans to take on BMW, Tesla

Source: Driving Canada

Rupert Stadler, CEO of Audi, introduces
Audi, the world’s second-largest maker of luxury vehicles, is betting that green-car fans are more interested in low emissions than distinctive designs. While electric cars like the BMW i3 and Tesla Model S garner interest because their styling stands out, Audi’s first plug-in hybrid is a modified version of its A3 hatchback that looks identical to the conventional model. The A3 Sportback E- Tron can drive emission free for ...
Source: Driving Canada   Full article at: Driving Canada Jun 27 2014, 9:00am CDT
 

Update: 6

Bill Jacobs BMW Announces Success with BMW i3 “Drive the Future Now” Test Drive Event Held June 13th

Source: PRWeb

Marc Jacobs - Front Row - Spring 2014 Collection
Last Friday, Bill Jacobs BMW of Naperville held their second BMW i3 Test Drive Event of 2014 to give customers the exclusive opportunity to try out the latest All-Electric Ultimate Driving Machines.(PRWeb June 25, 2014)Read the full story ...
Source: PRWeb   Full article at: PRWeb Jun 25 2014, 6:58am CDT
 

Update: 5

Will Hollywood Abandon Tesla Model S For BMW i3 Electric Car?

Source: Diesel Reports

The BMW i3 Global Reveal Event
Electric cars can be confusing enough to neophytes--a car that you plug in at night just like a phone ?!?!?--but when you add in social status signifiers, it can all get quite complicated indeed. Which is how we end up with a Hollywood Reporter piece that asking whether celebrities may abandon t ...
Source: Diesel Reports   Full article at: Diesel Reports Jun 19 2014, 7:00am CDT
 

Update: 4

Consumers turning to electric cars

Source: CityNews.ca

var brightcove_a113c805ccc7ae1996d5491b60d18ffe_templateLoadHandler = function () { var args = arguments; var objectStack, leafName, penultimateObject; var handlers = ["onTemplateLoaded","rdm_analytics_js_brightcove_load_handler"]; for (var i = 0; i < handlers.length; i += 1) { try { penultimateObject = window; objectStack = handlers[i].split("."); leafName = objectStack.pop(); while(objectStack.length) { penultimateObject = penultimateObject[objectSt ...
Source: CityNews.ca   Full article at: CityNews.ca Jun 15 2014, 5:58pm CDT
 

Update: 3

BMW Smartphone App Helps Cut Home Electric Car Charging Costs

Source: Hybrid SUV Reports

The BMW i3 Global Reveal Event
Unless you're a Tesla owner with access to free Supercharger fast charging stations, there's no better place to charge your electric car than at home. Pick the right electricity tariff, and charging can cost pennies on the dollar next to even the most efficient combustion-engine ...
Source: Hybrid SUV Reports   Full article at: Hybrid SUV Reports Jun 10 2014, 8:00am CDT
 

Update: 2

BMW i3 Electric Car Buyers: Mostly New To BMW (But Not i8 Owners)

Source: Green Car Reports

BMW International Open - Day Four
The 2014 BMW i3 is proving to be very effective at luring new buyers to BMW--buyers who haven't before owned one of its cars. Such buyers, known as conquests, are highly valued by carmakers, who have a much better chance of retaining a customer if they're already driving one of its vehicles. The hard part is getting them there in the firs ...
Source: Green Car Reports   Full article at: Green Car Reports Jun 9 2014, 7:30am CDT
 

Update: 1

Car Review: 2014 BMW i3

Source: Driving Canada

Nashville Predators v Vancouver Canucks
What’s a poor curmudgeon to do? Electric cars are supposed to be either dumpy little froo-froos barely evolved from a golf cart or some form of emissions-free Ferrari-baiter, replete with a price tag only a Hollywood movie director could afford. They’ve been either pathetically slow or monstrously fast, luxurious or bare bones, roomy or cramped. There’s been precious little in between. Into this polarized mar ...
Source: Driving Canada   Full article at: Driving Canada Jun 5 2014, 1:54pm CDT
 

Shopping Deals

 
 
 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/31" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

LeBron James to Wear No. 23 With Cleveland Cavaliers
LeBron James to Wear No. 23 With Cleveland Cavaliers
Four-time MVP LeBron James will wear No. 23 in his return to the Cleveland Cavaliers.
 
 
Baseball Hall of Fame Inducts 6 New Members
Baseball Hall of Fame Inducts 6 New Members
The Baseball Hall of Fame inducted new members Bobby Cox, Tony La Russa, Tom Glavine, Frank Thomas, Greg Maddux and Joe Torre on July 27 in Cooperstown, N.Y.
 
 
Frank Thomas Highlights The 2014 Hall of Fame Inductees
Frank Thomas Highlights The 2014 Hall of Fame Inductees
5 Other Players and Coaches Were Also Inducted Into The HoF
 
 
David Lee Roth Confirms New Solo Album To Be Released
David Lee Roth Confirms New Solo Album To Be Released
The Project Was Finished Over A Year Ago.
 
 
 

About the Geek Mind


Read more about The Geek Mind.