Menu
Jeff Goldblum Stars in funny GE Link Ad

Jeff Goldblum Stars in funny GE Link Ad

iPhone 6c is possible as iPhone 5c Sales Surge

iPhone 6c is possible as iPhone 5c Sales Surge

Pee-Wee Herman stars in New TV on the Radio Video

Pee-Wee Herman stars in New TV on the Radio Video

Windows 10 Preview Download Release is Today

Windows 10 Preview Download Release is Today

William Shatner and Leonard Nemoy to Star in New Volkswagen e-Golf Commercial

William Shatner and Leonard Nemoy to Star in New Volkswagen e-Golf Commercial

CEO Mark Karpeles Defends Mt Gox Amid Bitcoin Criticism

Feb 13 2014, 2:41am CST | by , in News | Technology News

CEO Mark Karpeles Defends Mt Gox Amid Bitcoin Criticism
 
 

YouTube Videos Comments

Full Story

CEO Mark Karpeles Defends Mt Gox Amid Bitcoin Criticism

Mt Gox chief executive Mark Karpeles – whom some internet forum commenters have angrily criticized after the exchange blamed a flaw in Bitcoin software for a potentially serious security issue – has been in contact with Forbes with a response to the criticisms.

In an interview by email, Karpeles defends Mt Gox’s systems. The company created its own Bitcoin implementation in order to process growing transaction volumes, he says, and has attempted to keep pace with all changes initiated by the Bitcoin Foundation. He suggests the flaw ought to have been solved by the Bitcoin Foundation before, as it has been known since 2011. [The Foundation has not responded for further information on the issue at the time of writing.]

Karpeles, who is also a board member of the Bitcoin Foundation, expresses regret that the Mt Gox announcement upset “a lot of people”, but says it may have helped people recognize and tackle the issues as all parties attempt to move forward with a fully working system.

Below is the full text of the email interview with Mr Karpeles. This article does not cover the news of how the issues unfolded: for more on that, click here.

FORBES: Was Mt Gox’s coding to blame, and are other exchanges having the same problem?

Mark Karpeles: First, you need to understand that the Bitcoin implementation we use in MtGox was created back in 2011. The bitcoin client is not meant to handle the kind of load MtGox has and was having more and more troubles, lagging and crashing. We created our own implementation to solve those issues and to offer a better flexibility to our customers.

Over time Bitcoin changed and started implementing changes that would require people using previous versions of the software to upgrade. While we followed most of those update[s] we were more and more busy and couldn’t keep up with all the changes.

With bitcoin 0.8.0 (released 19 feb 2013) a breaking change has been included that would prevent transactions to be accepted if their signature did not include the right number of zeroes in front of the signature values (in an effort to reduce risks of transaction malleability). We did not notice this change but a few of the transactions we were sending would become invalid because of this.

Due to this fact we started being more transparent on the transactions we sent, and provide a publicly available list of pending transactions. Nobody was however able to tell us what went wrong at that time. Since only a few transactions were affected anyway we didn’t give it much attention (recently we were able to look more into this and fix this issue).

This meant however that some of our invalid transactions were listed publicly, making it rather easy for someone with bad intention to alter these, hence the reason why many people claim there was an issue in our code. Now, transaction malleability does not affect only us, and while it might be more difficult to affect exchanges using regular bitcoin[s], it remains rather trivial.

Is there anything the Bitcoin Foundation can do to help solve this problem?

The Bitcoin Foundation has hired Bitcoin Developers for the purpose of promoting Bitcoin use. I guess the most puzzling part is why this issue hasn’t be[en] solved since 2011.

What constructive steps are both the Bitcoin Foundation and Mt Gox taking together to resolve the issues, and to have everything working at its best or the future?

We have proposed a solution that would allow people sending bitcoins to track sent coins no matter what happens in terms of malleability (a solution that can be applied quickly and without breaking anything), and the Bitcoin developers are preparing ways to prevent modified transactions from being relayed by the network (which will take a lot of time and may break some bitcoin custom clients).

There is obviously no perfect solution in this world, however this is how things are as of today.

Note that our announce[ment], while unfortunately upsetting a lot of people, allowed other exchanges to be much more cautious when faced with failing transactions, and most likely helped a lot of people understanding and dealing with the problem.

Interested in this story? Follow me (at the top) for more breaking news and in-depth analysis, affecting technology professionals, CIOs and business decision makers. Please do share your thoughts on the topic below.

Source: Forbes

 

Updates


Sponsored Update


Advertisement


More From the Web

Shopping Deals

 
 
 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/31" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Steve Smith on Release From Carolina Panthers: 'It Was Personal'
Steve Smith on Release From Carolina Panthers: 'It Was Personal'
Baltimore Ravens wide receiver Steve Smith opened up about his release from the Carolina Panthers on Charlotte radio station WFNZ on Oct. 1. Smith said, "It was personal" and felt he "was stabbed in the back."
 
 
Jay Z Profiled
Jay Z Profiled
Luckier than the Luckiest Chap on Earth!
 
 
Microsoft teases Windows 10 phone and Xbox interfaces
Microsoft teases Windows 10 phone and Xbox interfaces
Some subtle changes can be seen in the updated interface
 
 
Isla Fisher Pregnant with Third Child with Sacha Baron Cohen
Isla Fisher Pregnant with Third Child with Sacha Baron Cohen
It is a big 24 hours for Celebrity pregnancy news. Now news break that Isla Fisher is pregnant.