Menu
Volkswagen XL Sport Concept Car Stuns at Paris Motor Show

Volkswagen XL Sport Concept Car Stuns at Paris Motor Show

Mila Kunis and Ashton Kutcher Welcome Baby

Mila Kunis and Ashton Kutcher Welcome Baby

iPhone 6c is possible as iPhone 5c Sales Surge

iPhone 6c is possible as iPhone 5c Sales Surge

Jeff Goldblum Stars in funny GE Link Ad

Jeff Goldblum Stars in funny GE Link Ad

Lamborghini Asterion Plug-in Hybrid has 910hp

Lamborghini Asterion Plug-in Hybrid has 910hp

Beware Wildly Irrational Tech Mergers

Feb 21 2014, 2:51pm CST | by , in News | Technology News

Beware Wildly Irrational Tech Mergers
 
 

YouTube Videos Comments

Full Story

Beware Wildly Irrational Tech Mergers

In the last year, we’ve seen some mega-tech deals come down the pike, such as Comcast’s announcement to buy Time Warner Cable for $45 billion, Verizon’s purchase of Vodafone’s stake in Verizon Wireless for $130 billion, the privatization of Dell for $25 billion. Despite the dollar figures of these deals, the acquirers tended to be large, public, entities of long standing with billion dollar businesses acquiring large, public entities of long standing with billion dollar businesses.

We’ve also seen billion dollar deals for unique tech products without much revenue. These are standard deals when a large, established company with plenty of resources decides it has a hole in its portfolio that a unique startup can quickly fill and bring about a competitive edge. Google, for instance, said it would buy Nest, a maker of Internet connected thermostats, for $3.2 billion a few weeks ago.

It takes particular conditions in the marketplace to agree to such large deals. Debt tends to be cheap, valuations hardy. When investors reward these potentially risky moves, we may see announcements of large deals in rapid succession.

Though I wouldn’t characterize other megadeals of 2013 and 2014 as irrational, I would in the case of Facebook’s announcement on Wednesday that it will acquire WhatsApp, a mobile messaging company rumored to have generated $20 million in annual sales, for $19 billion.

If the tides turn for Facebook, the WhatsApp deal will not be remembered favorably. At some point, pundits must put rationalizations aside and just look at the numbers. Is the valuation sane? Is Facebook a disciplined acquirer? Allow the Zen of a $19 billion acquisition for a $20 million in sales wash over you.

13 years ago, I began working as an M&A reporter at a startup called The Deal. I had taken a few years off from reporting, so it caught me by surprise when Nortel Networks, a Canadian telecom equipment manufacturer, bought a startup called Alteon Websystems for $8 billion. Alteon made on product, a content web switch, and was rumored to have generated $110 million in annual sales.

I wondered what Nortel was buying in a $110 million business that could make an $8 billion price tag worth it. Nothing was the ultimate answer. It was July 2000, the heady days of the dot.com boom and networks were hot. Nortel’s stock price was $73 per share. The last time I’d written a story about a big, telecom equipment acquisition, it was 1997, and Ascend acquired a mature, public company, Cascade Communications, for less than half what it paid for Alteon.

Three months later, the dot.com bubble burst and Nortel was brought down in part by numerous overpriced acquisitions and goodwill charges in the multiples tens of billions of dollars. It declared bankruptcy in 2009.

I don’t mean to suggest that Facebook is in the same predicament as Nortel. But I think the idea of a crazy acquisition can be like your nose, easy to overlook from the vantage point of your eyes. If Facebook isn’t considering M&A carefully, always keeping in mind return to shareholders, it may have to learn the hard way.

Facebook and WhatsApp did not return requests for comment.

Source: Forbes

 

Updates


Sponsored Update


Advertisement


More From the Web

Shopping Deals

 
 
 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/31" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Kenya Moore gets a more Permanent Role in RHOA
Kenya Moore gets a more Permanent Role in RHOA
With the release of the new trailer for Season 7 of the Real Housewives of Atlanta, we will see Kenya Moore and her fellow newbie stars in more permanent roles than some much more experienced stars that have been bumped off the show.
 
 
50 Cent Calls Jay Z and Dr. Dre to Dream school
50 Cent Calls Jay Z and Dr. Dre to Dream school
50 Cent Calls Jay Z and Dr. Dre to Dream school
 
 
Tiffany Fallon And Joe Don Welcome Their New Baby Girl Devon Olivia
Tiffany Fallon And Joe Don Rooney Welcome Their New Baby Girl Devon Olivia
This is the Tiffany Fallon’s third child with Joe Don Rooney and she was born on the 29th September.
 
 
Madison Bumgarner Records Shutout in Win Over Pittsburgh Pirates
Madison Bumgarner Records Shutout in Win Over Pittsburgh Pirates
San Francisco Giants lefty Madison Bumgarner allowed just four hits in an 8-0 shutout win over the Pittsburgh Pirates in the National League Wild Card game on Oct. 1. The Giants will move on to face the Washington Nationals in the NLDS.