Latest News: Technology |  Celebrity |  Movies |  Apple |  Cars |  Business |  Sports |  TV Shows |  Geek


Filed under: News | Technology News


Quick Take: What's Up with Facebook's WhatsApp Deal?

Feb 28 2014, 1:56pm CST | by

11 Updates
Quick Take: What's Up with Facebook's WhatsApp Deal?

YouTube Videos Comments

Recommend Your Tweet as Top Tweet:

Full Story

Quick Take: What's Up with Facebook's WhatsApp Deal?

This article was originally posted on the Knowledge@Wharton website on February 21, 2014.

Can a text messaging service have the same value as a company that produces life-saving cancer drugs? According to Facebook, the answer is yes. When the firm announced on Wednesday that it is purchasing Mountain View, Calif.-based WhatsApp for $19 billion — $16 billion in cash and stock, and $3 billion in restricted stock units — an article in  Bloomberg  noted that such valuations have only ever been given to firms that develop drugs for illnesses such as cancer and Crohn’s disease.

WhatsApp enables users to create profiles to share text messages, photos and videos over their smartphones. With 450 million monthly users, the service is expanding rapidly in Africa, Asia and Latin America. The WhatsApp acquisition would give Facebook a much needed foothold in emerging markets, where its presence is lacking, analysts say.

Currently, WhatsApp’s service is free for the first year, and then $1 for each year thereafter. In a statement following Wednesday’s announcement, Facebook founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg said that WhatsApp is “on a path to connect one billion people” within the next few years. At the current fee, that could eventually mean $1 billion in annual sales for Facebook,Bloomberg noted. (In a previous Knowledge@Wharton story , Wharton faculty warned that Facebook inevitably will need to find revenue streams beyond advertising in order to avoid alienating users.)

“WhatsApp is the only widely used app we’ve ever seen that has more engagement and a higher percentage of people using it daily than Facebook itself,” Zuckerberg added. (According to  CNET , the engagement rate of WhatsApp’s monthly users on a daily basis is 70%, whereas Facebook’s is around 61%.) Given the potential upsides, however, does the deal make sense at such a steep price? Knowledge@Wharton asked two Wharton experts —Kartik Hosanagar , professor of operations and information management, and Lawrence G. Hrebiniak , emeritus professor of management — whether they believe the move ultimately will pay off.

Kartik Hosanagar:

“For Facebook, the acquisition makes sense for several strategic reasons, which I outline below. The valuation is hard to justify from a purely financial standpoint. In my opinion, the valuation reflects [the fact] that … Facebook was willing to pay whatever was needed to keep WhatsApp away from competitors such as Google. Secondly, Facebook has been aggressive in identifying the next big trends and startups in social [media] and trying to acquire those companies before they can eventually become serious threats to Facebook — for example, Instagram. So, Facebook paid a premium to bring a potential long-term threat in-house. So, to me, the valuation was less about financial upside but reflected a nice defensive move by Facebook.

“Now, why did acquiring WhatsApp make sense in the first place? One reason is opportunities: Growth for Facebook is going to come from emerging markets, where WhatsApp is very strong. Messaging is important for Facebook, and it has invested a lot in its standalone messenger app. Further, WhatsApp comes with [an existing] revenue model, which I suspect Facebook will not toy around with.

“There is another trend worth noting here. For a while now, Facebook has acknowledged that a one-size-fits-all Facebook doesn’t make sense going forward. People want to share different types of content with different users. There are several use cases for which Facebook is not ideal, and that creates an opening for an entrant to come in and take over the social networking space. This is especially true in mobile and, in response, Facebook has built separate apps for separate use cases (as opposed to those use cases that are features within Facebook). For example, Facebook launched Facebook Camera, and later acquired Instagram when the Camera app did not take off. It also launched Poke [a pared-down form of instant messaging], and then made an offer to acquire SnapChat when Poke failed. [Recently, the company] launched Paper, an app for news. [It also] launched its standalone messenger app. Now, it has acquired WhatsApp.”

Lawrence G. Hrebiniak:

“Facebook is paying $19 billion for a messaging company with 55 employees — a cost of approximately $345 million per employee. They must be really special and talented! The firm is buying a company with [minimal] revenue and one that has eschewed an advertising-revenue model…. Is the hot messaging technology worth such a huge amount? Is this a good move or a form of insanity? Let’s consider a few facts or motives.

“Facebook’s growth has slowed, and WhatsApp is growing — which speaks positively for the acquisition. Both of the companies are in the same business [social networking], but the communication methods or technologies are different, so Facebook is adding some new capabilities — which, again, is good. Facebook may also be trying to limit competitors’ options — for example, making a first move to keep Google and others from getting into their competitive space.

“I’m still not convinced, however, about the logic of the deal. What is the projected business model for the combined companies? Will monetization or revenue generation become a reality? Is it worth $19 billion to keep Facebook relevant and fresh in the market? $19 billion is roughly a third of Ford Motor Company’s and HP’s market cap — is this reasonable, or is the bubble inflating? There may be a strategy here, but it eludes me at the moment. The price seems way overboard, especially when put in the context of other acquisitions in the communications arena. I wish Facebook luck, but this feels like a dumbfounding deal that looks overpriced and risky.”

Source: Forbes


iPad Air Giveaway. Win a free iPad Air.

You Might Also Like


Sponsored Update

Update: 11

FB, WhatsApp keeping Indian teens up at midnight

Source: Times of India

Facebook To Buy WhatsApp For $19 Billion
For a generation that chooses Snapchat over sleep, there's now a cool Twilight-inspired term called 'vamping' to describe night-time nat ...
Source: Times of India   Full article at: Times of India 3 days ago, 8:03pm CDT


Update: 10

Back Up WhatsApp to Keep Your Precious Messages Forever

Source: Wired

Facebook To Buy WhatsApp For $19 Billion
If you're a heavy Whatsapp user you should probably be backing up your messages. Her ...
Source: Wired  Full article at: Wired Jun 26 2014, 5:48am CDT

More From the Web

Update: 9

Kaspersky Lab uncovers new Android and iOS spying tools

Source: BetaNews

Security company Kaspersky Lab has published a new report uncovering previously undiscovered Remote Control System (RCS) Trojans that work on both Android and iOS. It's also mapped their massive international command and control network. The Trojans are part of the allegedly 'legal' spyware tool, RCS, also known as Galileo, developed by the Italian company, HackingTeam. Kaspersky's researchers were able to map the presence of more than 320 RCS command ...
Source: BetaNews   Full article at: BetaNews Jun 24 2014, 11:00am CDT

Update: 7

Mohamed Salah reveals how he joined Chelsea & used WhatsApp to speak to Jose Mourinho [Video]

Source: 101 Great Goals

Egypt's Mohamed Salah (top) points as he
Mohamed Salah have revealed in an interview on Egyptian TV this weekend just how he came to join Chelsea from FC Basel last season. The 22-year-old joined the Blues for £11m in January, and Salah has now gone on the record about the exact details of how the deal came to pass. According to the winger, Chelsea boss Jose Mourinho messaged him and then called him to discuss the potential move, however Salah missed the Special One’s phone call, and be ...
Source: 101 Great Goals   Full article at: 101 Great Goals Jun 22 2014, 4:18am CDT

Update: 5

Why you might survive without any of Apple's latest software updates from WWDC 2014

Source: Asia One

Apple Hosts Its Worldwide Developers Conference
Apple on Tuesday showed off to the world its latest plans on the software front - new versions of its mobile and Mac operating systems, iOS 8 and OS X Yosemite, respectively.Like scores of other Apple fanboys across the world who stayed glued to the live stream, I clapped and cheered with every new feature Craig Federighi rattled off - a new OS X interface design slicker than Federighi's mane, better AirDrop file transfer options, ...
Source: Asia One   Full article at: Asia One Jun 6 2014, 8:28am CDT

Update: 4

WhatsApp emerges as big share driver for publishers (Ricardo Bilton/Digiday)

Source: Techmeme

Ricardo Bilton / Digiday: WhatsApp emerges as big share driver for publishers  —  Publishers tend to focus their social media strategies around the twin titans of Facebook and Twitter.  But perhaps they are ignoring WhatsApp at their own peril.  —  FTW, USA Today's viral sports site, offers a good case study for th ...
Source: Techmeme  Full article at: Techmeme May 31 2014, 11:25am CDT

Update: 3

WhatsApp to be Key Part of Mediaset España’s World Cup Social TV Strategy

Source: Lost Remote

Patricia Conde Presents 'Ciento y la Madre' Tv Show
Mediaset España this week announced a partnership with WhatsApp as the network prepares its social TV strategy ahead of the 2014 FIFA World Cup. Mediaset España, which owns Telecinco and Cuatro and has been one of the leading social TV broadcasters in Spain, will seek to tap into WhatsApp’s 26 million active Spanish users. The network has created a World Cup hub at, and fans will be able to stream up to six games at a time. Bet ...
Source: Lost Remote   Full article at: Lost Remote May 30 2014, 12:00pm CDT

Update: 2

WhatsApp & Speck: Same Building, Hugely Different Price Tags

Source: Forbes

Facebook To Buy WhatsApp For $19 Billion
Months after WhatsApp sold for $19 billion, the app’s neighbor in hardware goes for a much smaller $85 million. Software might just be eating th ...
Source: Forbes   Full article at: Forbes May 29 2014, 6:13pm CDT

Update: 1

Iran bans Instagram over ‘privacy concerns'

Source: Neowin

Facebook To Buy WhatsApp For $19 Billion
Just a few weeks after Iran banned WhatsApp, calling Mark Zuckerberg - CEO of Facebook, which is acquiring the company - an "American Zionist", an Iranian court has now ordered a ban on Instagram. ...
Source: Neowin   Full article at: Neowin May 25 2014, 12:02pm CDT

Shopping Deals


<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/31" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.




blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Johnny Manziel's Jersey is NFL's Top Seller
Johnny Manziel's Jersey is NFL's Top Seller
Cleveland Browns rookie quarterback Johnny Manziel's jersey is the NFL's top seller.
Baltimore Orioles Hope Ubaldo Jimenez Returns Soon
Baltimore Orioles Hope Ubaldo Jimenez Returns Soon
The Baltimore Orioles hope starting pitcher Ubaldo Jimenez, who hasn't taken the mound since July 5 due to a sprained right ankle, can return soon.
David Ortiz Moves Up to 36th All-Time in Home Runs
David Ortiz Moves Up to 36th All-Time in Home Runs
Boston Red Sox designated hitter David Ortiz homered twice in his team's 14-1 rout of the Toronto Blue Jays on July 21 to move up to 36th all-time in home runs, surpassing Red Sox legend Carl Yastrzemski.
George Clooney Worries About Daily Mail &#039;Bleeding Into American Press&#039;
George Clooney Worries About Daily Mail 'Bleeding Into American Press'
George Clooney gave an interview on Friday to Variety, opening up about his problems with the Daily Mail and why he's worried about journalism.

About the Geek Mind

Read more about The Geek Mind.