Latest News: Technology |  Celebrity |  Movies |  Apple |  Cars |  Business |  Sports |  TV Shows |  Geek

Trending

Filed under: News | Apple

 

Apple Has Gone Mad, Someone Call Don Draper (Or Don't)

12 Updates
Apple Has Gone Mad, Someone Call Don Draper (Or Don't)
 
 

YouTube Videos Tweets Comments

Full Story

Apple Has Gone Mad, Someone Call Don Draper (Or Don't)

In the first episode of Mad Men this season, Christina Hendricks’ character is sent to meet with the head of marketing from Butler Footwear. “Advertising’s just a small piece of the marketing mixture and it might be more effective if it’s better integrated into our business,” he tells Joan.

“So are you thinking about bringing one of our account executives into our office?” she replies.

“Actually, I’d like to bring all our advertising in house.”

While Joan is successful in talking him out of it, at least for a while, in the real world, Apple’s longtime advertising agency TBWAChiatDay has apparently been less so of late. Bloomberg  reports that Apple has hired personnel away from the Media Arts Lab at ChiatDay, a unit there that only does work for Apple. And several of the recent television spots the company has run, including the recent “What will your verse be?” campaign, have been produced in house.

The machinations at Apple pre-date the most recent season of Mad Men, with the company confirming it was responsible for last October’s “Pencil” spot, highlighting the thinness of the then-new iPad Air. Still, the ties between art and life in this story are almost too bizarre to be real. Apple also acknowledged to Bloomberg through spokesperson Amy Bessette, that it’s behind the “Your Verse” campaign, in which Robin Williams does voiceover work.

Next to Apple’s iconic 1984 ad, probably the most important of its televised spots ever was “The Crazy Ones“, a 1997 ad at the centerpiece of its “Think Different” campaign, which helped bring the company back from oblivion. This past fall, The Crazy Ones would become the title of a CBS sitcom, about an ad agency, starring Robin Williams.

Whether Apple was inspired by Williams presence in a show named for an ad it ran 17 years ago isn’t clear, but there are strong parallels between the two. The Crazy Ones (the show), received a mixed critical reception and is gone. “Your Verse” contains some fantastic imagery and I said some nice things about it, but it begins to get tired as a meme. “Your Verse” has since been expanded with two new spots: one features travel and the other is music centered. They are gorgeous and they hit the right notes, forgive the pun, about experiences over technology that Apple has been trying to play off for some time.

The question is whether the references to “verse” are buying Apple anything interesting. The company markets an accessible luxury brand that at least some people find off-putting because it’s the one “pretentious” people use. Is the ongoing ask for “verses” doing anything more than reinforcing that notion? Is it bringing Apple any of the hipness Apple’s VP Phil Schiller was concerned about last year when he forwarded a Wall Street Journal article to ChiatDay’s president James Vincent titled “Has Apple Lost Its Cool to Samsung?”

It doesn’t feel that way. Instead, it seems like the actions of a bunch of folks who have lost touch with the cultural zeitgeist and aren’t precisely sure how to get it back. Apple is famous for its desire to control things from the smallest design elements of its products to its supply chain, so why not control advertising too? But placed in context of another recent report, you might start to wonder if bringing advertising in house isn’t more about Apple’s legendary reputation for arrogance, too.

Buzzfeed has a somewhat explosive story that claims the Beats deal was motivated in part by Apple’s failure to even understand the music streaming business at the executive level. The report claims Apple felt iTunes Radio would streamroll Pandora, because the internet radio pioneer was bad at making money. Worse still, Buzzfeed quotes a source saying that as recently as 2013, some Apple execs “didn’t understand how Spotify worked, which is why they thought iTunes Radio would be a Spotify killer.” Basically, the source claims, they were unaware that Spotify was more than just radio and allowed on-demand streaming from a giant library.

Apple didn’t comment on the Buzzfeed report and had little to say to Bloomberg, but it does keep producing new television advertising. The latest spot, titled “Strength” highlights the iPhone 5s and various fitness-monitoring apps and devices. The visuals are fine, sometimes even a bit cool. But the background music is a song titled “ Chicken Fat” that not only comes from the early 1960s, its every bit as dated as Season 1′s Don Draper would be if he walked into your living room. Part of President Kennedy’s effort to get young people to exercise, the song is from another time, for another generation’s children, and unlikely to motivate someone to grab their iPhone and start a new exercise program.

It’s unclear who actually put the spot together — Apple’s in-house team with the former Chiat personnel or the agency itself — but either way, senior management in Cupertino decided it was a good idea to put it on the air. They made a similar call with the recent “Gigantic“, which is about 10 million times hipper, but nevertheless uses a song by the Pixies, from the ’80s. (We could go off on a tangent that the song itself is totally inappropriate, but there’s no way to do a better job of that than Slate did.)

Apple wasn’t always choosing songs from three or five decades ago. When it used Feist’s “1234″ to advertise the iPod Nano in 2007, the song itself was from, lo, 2007! When it used “Bruises” by Chairlift a year later for the updated Nano, that song was also current. It’s certainly not the case that every single spot needs to use music from indie radio that’s on right now, but the fact that Apple’s popularity with young people was rising along with marketing that was current seems to be a lesson that’s entirely lost in the oddly retro campaigns of late. Evoking memories of Dead Poets Society and the Pixies is great 1980s nostalgia. It’s a rather oblique way to capture the next wave of youth customers who ostensibly Apple is concerned with Samsung stealing away via “The next big thing is here,” though.

This is art, not science. Microsoft has spent years using current music as if they watched those same Nano commercials and thought, “Yes! Mainstream-ish music!” As a result, they used a song about commitment phobia (Alex Clare’s “Too Close”) to try to convince people to use Internet Explorer. Now, they are using a song about coming out (Sara Bareilles “Brave”) to sell tablet computers.

There’s are numerous reasons most companies don’t do their creative work in house: You start to see the world through a very narrow lens if all you do is build ads for one company, for openers. Beyond that, though, you lose the back and forth an agency — or even a bake off between several of them — can provide. Apple may not be as out of touch as “Chicken Fat” suggests they are, but it’s a troublesome sign that every commercial could add a #TBT (that’s “throwback Thursday” for the uninitiated). Bringing on the Beats folks is no panacea either. While Dr. Dre and Jimmy Iovine are doubtless more up on the latest trends than Schiller or Tim Cook, Iovine is hardly free of his own brand of ’80s nostalgia.

Apple ends up with products that are far more appealing to young people than all this would indicate and Beats is even more popular among teens than Apple. That’s the good news. And it’s not as if any of this advertising is a disaster. Indeed, Apple is scoring above average on Ace Metrix’s scores of advertising impact and is rumored to beefing up digital efforts — where it’s been notoriously weak. It just might want to consider seriously whether a company that’s made it name building the devices people didn’t yet know they wanted should be reminding them of times they’d already long since forgotten. And maybe it should admit it can use some help to do that. Just like Butler Footwear.

Follow me on Twitter. Read the rest of my Forbes posts here.

 

iPad Air Giveaway. Win a free iPad Air.

You Might Also Like

Updates


Sponsored Update

Update: 12

Tweets

 

Advertisement


Update: 11

Rumor: 'A8' chip in Apple's 'iPhone 6' will stick to 1GB of RAM

Source: Apple Insider

A newly leaked document claiming to be a schematic for Apple's next-generation "A8" processor expected to power the "iPhone 6" claims the chip will come with 1 gigabyte of RAM, falling short of competing devices like Samsung ...
Source: Apple Insider   Full article at: Apple Insider 3 days ago, 7:32am CDT
 

More From the Web

Update: 10

Apple's Most Notable Acquisitions

Source: Forbes Real Time

From Siri to NeXT, retracing Apple's biggest acquisitions over th ...
Source: Forbes Real Time   Full article at: Forbes Real Time 3 days ago, 7:13am CDT
 

Update: 8

Xiaomi, the Chinese company behind the Mi Pad, announces iOS-like Android skin

Source: 9to5Mac

Not content with a blatant copy of the iPad mini and a smartphone called the Mi Phone, Xiaomi’s latest Android overlay – MIUI 6 – bears more than a passing resemblance to iOS 7. The flat icons, the icon screens scrolling above the fixed app tray at the bottom, the calendar, calculator, compass …  Xiaomi global VP and former Google exec Hugo Barra has said previously that suggestions that the company copies Apple’s designs are “sweeping sensationalist statements” and that similarities are ...
Source: 9to5Mac   Full article at: 9to5Mac 3 days ago, 6:00am CDT
 

Update: 7

This Is The Product That Predicts The Future Of Apple

Source: Business Insider

When it comes to Apple's future, there are two products people focus on — the iPad and the iPhone.  Combined, those products generate ~70% of Apple's sales, and they are leading the company into a "post-PC" world of mobile computing. So, when people see Android taking share in the smartphone and tablet markets, they get worried about Apple's future. After all, if people are buying Android gadgets, then they're not buying Apple gadgets.  And since Android's pric ...
Source: Business Insider   Full article at: Business Insider 3 days ago, 5:50am CDT
 

Update: 6

Alleged Schematic Shows iPhone 6 Coming with 1GB of RAM

Source: Mac Rumors

Apple's forthcoming iPhone 6 may sport 1 GB of RAM, according to a leaked schematic shared by Chinese Apple repair firm GeekBar (Google Translate, via G for Games). The chart is said to come from an internal supply chain source, however it is unknown if the schematic is intended for the 4.7-inch or 5.5-inch iPhone 6. If the chart is indeed legitimate, the iPhone 6 would join the iPhone 5, iPhone 5s, and iPhone 5c in spor ...
Source: Mac Rumors  Full article at: Mac Rumors 3 days ago, 5:45am CDT
 

Update: 5

Pokémon is on the way to iPad! Well, the other one…

Source: Fifth Gear

Pokémon fans rejoice: If you’ve been itching to take your Pocket Monsters on the road on your iPad, you’ll soon be in luck! Only it’s not quite the same Pokémon game you’ll find on your Nintendo 3DS, as The Pokémon Trading Card Game on the way to Apple’s digital slate! Ready to relive your childhood with digital Pokémon cards? Pokémon is on the way to the iPad, according to Twitter user TheJWittz. A version of the Pokémon Trading Card Game can be seen being played on ...
Source: Fifth Gear   Full article at: Fifth Gear 3 days ago, 5:15am CDT
 

Update: 4

Will the iPhone 6 include a reversible USB cable? Recent Apple patent makes it possible.

Source: 9to5Mac

The iPhone 6’s packaging might not only include a redesigned smartphone, but a redesigned USB to Lightning cable. While it’s unlikely that Apple will yet-again change the Lightning port introduced with the 2012 iPhone 5 anytime in the near future, a redesigned version of the USB plug could be ready for this fall. Sketchy photos of a reversible USB cable first surfaced on the web last week, and Sonny Dickson yesterday shared another ...
Source: 9to5Mac   Full article at: 9to5Mac 4 days ago, 9:34pm CDT
 

Update: 3

Apple wins 2014 ‘Outstanding Commercial’ Emmy Award for ‘Misunderstood’ holiday ad

Source: 9to5Mac

Here’s some good news for Apple amid several months of controversy surrounding the Cupertino-company’s marketing efforts: Apples’ 2013 Holiday season television commercial “Misunderstood” has won a Creative Arts Emmy Award for most “outstanding commercial” in 2014. The award was announced on the Emmy’s winners list last night, and the Creative Arts Emmy Awards are presented for “guest performers on tele ...
Source: 9to5Mac   Full article at: 9to5Mac 4 days ago, 3:54pm CDT
 

Update: 2

2014 Golden Globes Top 10 Worst Dressed, There Are 6 Very Good Reasons to Travel by Cargo Ship Instead of a Cruise Ship, Lightsaber Toothbrushes and more

Source: 2leep.com

2014 Golden Globes Top 10 Worst Dressed From color clashes to three-dimensional accents and even to fictional character resemblances, here are our top 10 worst dressed.more... There Are 6 Very Good Reasons to Travel by Cargo Ship Instead of a Cruise Ship Cargo ships travel to parts of the world that are not serviced by cruise ships, so you will see places you would ...
Source: 2leep.com   Full article at: 2leep.com 4 days ago, 3:43pm CDT
 

Update: 1

Inside Apple’s Next Game-changing Innovation (Hint: It’s Not The iPhone 6)

Source: Fool.com

With Apple preparing to launch the iPhone 6 and a new iPad in the months ahead, here’s how Apple HealthKit could prove it's most important ...
Source: Fool.com   Full article at: Fool.com 4 days ago, 12:25pm CDT
 

Shopping Deals

 
 
 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/31" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Windows 9 Set to be Divulged on September 30th
Windows 9 Set to be Divulged on September 30th
Microsoft Announces The Event "Threshold" Will Take Place.
 
 
Linda Cohn Files Lawsuit Against New York Ice Rink
Linda Cohn Files Lawsuit Against New York Ice Rink
ESPN broadcaster Linda Cohn is filing a lawsuit against a New York ice rink after a group of kids pushed a heavy coin machine which allegedly fell on her, resulting in a huge gash that required 25 stitches.
 
 
Nick Cannon Admits He and Wife Mariah Carey are Separated
 
 
JaMarcus Russell Does Dish Network Commercial
JaMarcus Russell Does Dish Network Commercial
Former NFL first overall pick JaMarcus Russell did a commercial for Dish Network along with Matt Leinart, Brian Bosworth and Heath Shuler which was released on Aug. 19.
 
 
 

About the Geek Mind

The “geek mind” is concerned with more than just the latest iPhone rumors, or which company will win the gaming console wars. I4U is concerned with more than just the latest photo shoot or other celebrity gossip.

The “geek mind” is concerned with life, in all its different forms and facets. The geek mind wants to know about societal and financial issues, both abroad and at home. If a Fortune 500 decides to raise their minimum wage, or any high priority news, the geek mind wants to know. The geek mind wants to know the top teams in the National Football League, or who’s likely to win the NBA Finals this coming year. The geek mind wants to know who the hottest new models are, or whether the newest blockbuster movie is worth seeing. The geek mind wants to know. The geek mind wants—needs—knowledge.

Read more about The Geek Mind.