Menu
Trending: Holiday Gifts | CES 2015 | Super Bowl 2015 Ads More Topics: Apple | Cars | TV Shows | Politics
Star Wars Christmas Lights Video Goes Viral

Star Wars Christmas Lights Video Goes Viral

CES 2015: LG will unveil its New 4K Ultra HD TV with Quantum Dot Technology

CES 2015: LG will unveil its New 4K Ultra HD TV with Quantum Dot Technology

Budweiser Super Bowl 2015 Ad leaks

Budweiser Super Bowl 2015 Ad leaks

The Best 2014 Super Bowl Ads

The Best 2014 Super Bowl Ads

Tesla Roadster Makes Comeback

Tesla Roadster Makes Comeback

Randy Queen Bullies Feminist Comic Blog Escher Girls Through Endless DMCAs

Aug 5 2014, 12:01am CDT | by , in News | Also on the Geek Mind

Randy Queen Bullies Feminist Comic Blog Escher Girls Through Endless DMCAs
Photo Credit: Getty Images
/* Story Top Left 2010 300x250, created 7/15/10 */ google_ad_slot = "8340327155";
 
 

Randy Queen, creator of DarkChylde and comic artist, used DMCA forms to bully Escher Girls for negative critical analysis of his work. Tumblr folded quickly with no regard to "fair use."

In a bold (and ill-advised) move, comic book artist and DarkChylde creator Randy Queen decided to dump a ton of DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) requests on Escher Girls, a Tumblr account/website used to critically examine "the certain ways women are depicted in illustrated pop media."

In other words, Escher’s used to point out the misogyny and sexism in an industry constantly under the microscope for said behavior.


Apparently, Queen didn't care for the criticism.

Never mind he's a public figure and putting art out for public consumption. Never mind he bullied the blog runner, Ami Angelwings, through lawsuit threats for not being cowed into submission. Never mind the fact comic book writer Gail Simone snarked, as reviewers for many different genres banned together to say "don't be foolish."


Focus on this on fact: the man gets paid to create art, but he always wants to control intellectual property (IP) interpretation. That's right, everyone. Anyone that buys, reads, or looks at his work must bow to his vision.

Randy Queen very clearly missed the lessons on being confident in what's put out and then realizing interpretation is up to the audience.


Ask any writer about that. It's a long messy conversation, but the general opinion is once something is published, it's no longer yours to control. Leo from The Geekiary summed up the reaction to intent versus interpretation really well: "there aren’t any dire consequences from varying interpretations of a work of art."

Everyone can have an individual view of something with neither being right or wrong. The only thing one can get wrong is facts, but discussing visual media means all you have is imagery to interpret.


Anyone remember the Vincent Van Gogh episode of Doctor Who where Bill Nighy’s character did nothing but explain the artist’s work?

Leo pointed out the connection between audience and author, too.

"The author cannot take away the audience’s freedom to interpret, and the audience cannot seize the author’s creative dominion. Perspectives cannot be enforced, after all; they can only be offered."

So when Queen flipped his lid on Escher Girls, he was pretty much ignoring the basic structure of art criticism and forcing his sole intent on society. Every creator must be willing to take the bad with good. Not everyone will appreciate the work or find it to their taste.


And Tumblr's willingness to pull without reviewing policies shows a lot of cowardice, as well.

Not to mention pulling the reblogs, or ability to reblog, without providing any receipts on why. "Fair Use" protects critics and critical thinkers, whether it's a positive or negative for an artist. It is not illegal to post a picture that's promoted by creator or company, to offer a different point of view.


This isn't a case of Scans Daily, where large pages of a comic are shown. Escher Girls uses the same imagery found on Comic Vine, a database of most—if not all—comic illustrations and panels.

Ami Angelwings warned other blogs of his willful abuse of DMCAs and to be on the lookout since their pages may be removed without warning as well. In a letter to Ami, he openly believes her actions "publicly challenges my right to protect the perception of my IP as it exists today." Uh, no. There's no law for that. Ever. Sorry. Just, no.

Tech Dirt's Mike Masnick breaks it down further. "Perception is an individual thing." So, Queen's singular intent does not mean the rest of the world will follow the same intent or reasoning for his choices in artwork.


The artist then pulls out the "instead of taking shots at art someone did 18 years ago while they were still learning" card—also known as the "stop bullying me" card. You know, the one where people complain about their art and how it's "no longer representative of their current art style or direction for their character." Once something is public, especially published in print form, you can't take anything back.

Queen should remember that.

He condescendingly offers a piece of advice. "I encourage you to spend your time and energy on creating your own characters and comics which you can make your own personal sacrifices to bring to the world."


Because there's no way Ami can be a creator and critic, right? The paternalistic, dismissive tone openly sneers at the upstart who would dare look beyond his opinions.

And while he has "no problem getting legal involved for defamation," the creator should look at his own words about legality since he vaguely threatened the Escher Girls' runner. "I will ask you to please move along, as no good will come of this." How he thinks he can sue anyone is beyond comprehension since DMCA lawsuits are built for thin-skinned companies and artists who are getting ripped off by lack of monetary compensation.

Not someone offering a critical evaluation.


The U.S. Copyright Office is intentionally vague on what is considered "fair use," but Escher Girls would absolutely fall under "quotation of excerpts in a review or criticism for purposes of illustration or comment." The site's a literal illustration point. If tweaked a bit, the site could also be considered a "small part of a work to illustrate a lesson" on how to not draw a woman's body portions. (You know, the basic intent of the site from the start.)

It also seems this is not the first time Queen has taken down negative views of his work. Especially since "non-critical Tumblr posts of his art/covers and those praising his work appear to be unaffected." Hmm. So if one is overtly positive and kind, the work may stay up, but if someone expresses disbelief at artwork, off with their head?


Did the world fall into illustrations and the Red Queen take over his mind? Considering he's egregiously using DMCAs on the site, it's fair to say it's him being thin-skinned—not Escher Girls. And even warning using the legal process to try and delete the warning post on Tumblr to be taken down, even though his art is not displayed.

Intent is not interpretation. Interpretation is not intent.

Shame on Tumblr for following his tactics without seriously reviewing the content; doing so leaves them open for a flood of requests. It’s not hard to leave a platform nowadays if a user doesn’t feel heard. There’s always a new just around the corner. Ask Livejournal about losing heyday status. Or MySpace. Or Friendster.

 


And shame on a man that's been in the business for at least 18 years to use something meant to protect artist work for his inability to handle dissension.

You Might Also Like

Read the Latest

BMW will unveil 6 Series and M6 Coupe, Gran Coupe and Convertible Models at the NAIAS 2015 in Detroit

BMW will unveil 6 Series and M6 Coupe, Gran Coupe and Convertible Models at the NAIAS 2015 in Detroit At the Detroit Auto Show 2015, BMW will present the new models including BMW 6 Series Convertible, BMW 6 Series Coupe,...

11 hours ago, 7:32am CST

Sony Xperia Z4 to Launch at CES 2015

Sony Xperia Z4 to Launch at CES 2015 Sony Xperia Z4 Ultra may see the light soon at the CES 2015 after the new leaked information.

13 hours ago, 5:24am CST

CES 2015 News
Kodak debuts its First Range of Android-powered Mobile Devices at CES 2015

Kodak debuts its First Range of Android-powered Mobile Devices at CES 2015 Kodak partners with Bullitt Group to launch a new range of Android powered mobile devices at CES 2015.

14 hours ago, 4:36am CST

Mozilla and KDDI debut Fx0, First Firefox OS Smartphone with 4G LTE and NFC

Mozilla and KDDI debut Fx0, First Firefox OS Smartphone with 4G LTE and NFC The services, Mozilla and KDDI, have introduced first Firefox OS smartphone 'Fx0', based on Web technology...

14 hours ago, 4:21am CST

Elon Musk says new Tesla Roadster has almost 400 mile Range

Elon Musk says new Tesla Roadster has almost 400 mile Range Elon Musk tweeted that the new Tesla Roadster has almost a 400 mile range. More details of the new Tesla Roadster are...

15 hours ago, 3:32am CST

CES 2015 gets Highest Honors for Creative Campaigns

CES 2015 gets Highest Honors for Creative Campaigns Tradeshow, MarCom and Visual Arts Professionals have recognized CES’s superb advertising and marketing campaigns. The...

15 hours ago, 3:29am CST

Xbox and PlayStation Networks hacked by Lizard Squad on Christmas

Xbox and PlayStation Networks hacked by Lizard Squad on Christmas The Xbox and Playstation online services have unfortunately been hacked and disabled by a group of no-gooders known as...

16 hours ago, 2:19am CST

Facebook launches FaceTube to compete YouTube

Facebook launches FaceTube to compete YouTube It has established that all businesses on Facebook will be offered a featured video strip with the latest videos...

1 day ago, 12:28pm CST

LG makes 4 additions to wireless speakers range for CES

LG makes 4 additions to wireless speakers range for CES The new additions include a battery-powered portable wireless speaker, two sound bars and a streaming 3D Blu-ray Player

1 day ago, 12:26pm CST

First Shelby GT 350 Mustang to be Barrett-Jackson's Scottsdale sale

First Shelby GT 350 Mustang to be Barrett-Jackson's Scottsdale sale The proceeds of the sale are going to be donated to the Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation (JDRF)

1 day ago, 11:54am CST

LG Exec Could Be Banned From CES For Sabotaging a Washing Machine

LG Exec Could Be Banned From CES For Sabotaging a Washing Machine Samsung filed a lawsuit for property damage and defamation against five LG execs back in September

1 day ago, 9:57am CST

Madonna Tracks Leak Online Again from Rebel Heart

14 More Madonna Tracks Leak Madonna’s new album Rebel Hearts has already been hacked once before. Five of the tracks were officially released on...

1 day ago, 8:38am CST

MINI John Cooper Works Hardtop to be displayed at the NAIAS Detroit 2015

MINI John Cooper Works Hardtop to be displayed at the NAIAS Detroit 2015 BMW’s famous mini cooper’s new design will be displayed at the NAIAS 2015 in Detroit.

1 day ago, 8:18am CST

Sarah Palin Channel Wardrobe Controversy Video was a Publicity Stunt?

Sarah Palin Channel Wardrobe Controversy Video was a Publicity Stunt? Most people are talking about the one term governor’s show of skin on live channel. Sarah Palin ran for the Vice...

1 day ago, 7:54am CST

Patchworks to represent North and South America at CES 2015

Patchworks to represent North and South America at CES 2015 Patchworks Global Inc. make flawlessly engineered products for iPhone Screen Protection that it will display at the CES...

1 day ago, 7:47am CST

How to Watch The Interview Online Right Now

How to Watch The Interview Online Right Now Sony Pictures announce the online release of ‘The Interview’ with the help of online sources. Google, Microsoft and...

1 day ago, 7:05am CST

Luxoft Software Development Services will also participate in CES 2015 and CTS 2015

Luxoft Software Development Services will also participate in CES 2015 and CTS 2015 It seems everyone is eager to take part in the CES 2015.

1 day ago, 6:13am CST

Peyton Manning to Return to Broncos in 2015

Peyton Manning to Return to Broncos in 2015 The player, Peyton Manning, is planning to return to Denver Broncos next year since he has no plans to leave the field...

1 day ago, 6:08am CST

First Alert also to take on the Polar Vortex at CES 2015

First Alert also to take on the Polar Vortex at CES 2015 The new Onelink Series by First Alert introduces many new products which will be displayed at the CES 2015. New Onelink...

1 day ago, 5:20am CST

Uber CEO Charged with Illegitimate Business Practice in South Korea

Uber CEO Charged with Illegitimate Business Practice in South Korea The CEO of taxi service Uber has been charged with illegitimate business practice in South Korea.

1 day ago, 5:15am CST

NBA pulls Sorority Sisters Advertising

NBA pulls Sorority Sisters Advertising NBA has announced Wednesday to pull all advertising from VH1's Sorority Sisters show.

1 day ago, 4:33am CST

First Alert to debut Onelink Series of Smart Devices at CES 2015

CES 2015 to feature First Alert Onelink Series of Smart Devices These new and innovative products by First Alert will bring a new level of security and accessibility to Connected Home...

1 day ago, 4:27am CST

NFL Video Clips will be shown on Facebook with Verizon Wireless Ads

Facebook-NFL Deal: NFL Video Clips will be shown on Facebook with Verizon Wireless Ads Facebook is into showing NFL post game highlights and other video clips with a little advertising help from Verizon.

1 day ago, 3:35am CST

Acura NSX Production Model to debut at NAIAS 2015

Acura NSX Production Model to debut at NAIAS 2015 The luxury vehicle division of Honda Motor Company will be displaying its new model at the NAIAS 2015.

1 day ago, 3:00am CST

Renovo Coupe to be on display at CES 2015

Renovo Coupe to be on display at CES 2015 The first all-electric American supercar will be featured in the NVIDIA Booth (#30307)

1 day ago, 2:39am CST

CES 2015: SymbolShifters to unveil a New Method for connecting Traditional TV Broadcast to the Digital World

CES 2015: SymbolShifters to unveil a New Method for connecting Traditional TV Broadcast to the Digital World At CES 2015, a new American company, SymbolShifters is planning to introduce a method for connecting traditional TV...

1 day ago, 2:28am CST

PlayStation Now Game Streaming Service arriving on Samsung Smart TVs Next Year

PlayStation Now Game Streaming Service arriving on Samsung Smart TVs Next Year The Sony PlayStation game streaming service "PlayStation Now" is arriving soon on Samsung Smart TVs. In fact...

1 day ago, 1:59am CST

TRW Automotive will display its latest Automated Systems at CES 2015

TRW Automotive will display its latest Automated Systems at CES 2015 TRW Automotive will bring its new automotive innovations at the CES 2015 in Las Vegas.

1 day ago, 1:43am CST

CES 2015 garners ad campaign awards

CES 2015 garners ad campaign awards 3 major associations give CES ad awards

1 day ago, 10:56pm CST

Personal Health to be part of CES 2015

Personal Health to be part of CES 2015 TENSIO device to help high blood pressure consumers

1 day ago, 10:53pm CST

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus