Menu
Samsung Galaxy S6 and S6 Edge Hands-on Photos Leak

Samsung Galaxy S6 and S6 Edge Hands-on Photos Leak

Aston Martin Vulcan Super Car Revealed

Aston Martin Vulcan Super Car Revealed

Apple Watch gets 12-page Vogue Magazine Ad

Apple Watch gets 12-page Vogue Magazine Ad

Google DeepMind AI can learn how to Play 49 Classic Atari Games

Google DeepMind AI can learn how to Play 49 Classic Atari Games

Madonna falls off the Stage at BRIT Awards 2015

Madonna falls off the Stage at BRIT Awards 2015

Shark Week: Fake Discovery Documentaries Abound

Aug 17 2014, 4:02pm CDT | by , in News | Latest TV News

Shark Week: Fake Discovery Documentaries Abound
Photo Credit: Getty Images
/* Story Top Left 2010 300x250, created 7/15/10 */ google_ad_slot = "8340327155";
 
 

Thanks to the liberal use of CGI, fans of Shark Week are catching on to the fake set ups--and io9 found the proof.

Shark Week's one of the most anticipated events of the year, where the network adds a new documentaries and one-off shows into rotation. Shark Week is a non-stop infomercial on the awe-inspiring predators.

Viewers may find the documentaries featuring actual scientists as interesting learning tools. Who doesn't trust an expert, right? But the interviewed scientists told everyone to be wary since you shouldn't trust the filmed information…at all.

Earlier this week, io9.com reported clever editing managed to twist scientist words to fit into a faux documentary, while lying to the expert on what the subject was really about.


Take Jonathan Davis, for instance.

Davis currently works for the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department, but was approached by the network to do a documentary on the sharks of Louisiana—his area of expertise.

Asking questions on the overall project's goal, he never received a "straight answer and the producer seemed to avoid the question." After some persistence, production explained it would be part of a larger documentary on Louisiana shark research.

Reasonable, right? The show’s produced numerous specials about shark species where a group of scientists describe how research connects the dots.

Instead, the network eventually produced the 2013 special called Voodoo Sharks about Rookin, a mythical monster stalking the bayous. Splicing the interview about real situations and possibilities with local fisherman, Rookin seemed to be a "race between his team of researchers and the fishermen to see who could catch the mythical voodoo shark faster."


Davis explained about the filming process. "I was fed certain words to rephrase my sentences in ways that the producer thought would spark more interest." Makes sense from a monetary side for advertising, even if he refused to use their lies. Also seems a little bit like an episode of Big Brother.

In the beginning of Voodoo Sharks, directors implied a monster lurked alone the shores of Lake Pontchartrain and they used Davis’s answers to create a narrative about the validity of Rooken. And by doing so, Discovery also managed to make it seem as if Davis believed in the mythical creature, instead of the truth.

For the record, there is no voodoo shark. So, that was a bold-faced lie.

And despite Davis's criticism, the network's continued the practice this year. Kristine Stump's working on her post-doctoral research as an assistant at the Shedd Aquarium, but Discovery used her interview to bolster Monster Hammerhead—where they claim a hammerhead's lived along the Florida coast for over 60 years.


Too bad the truth is completely different. The average life span of a hammerhead is only 44 years, so a large one living for 60 years seems very unlikely. And unlike SyFy's often humorous, campy monster flicks about a Sharknado or Mega Shark, Discovery's supposed to be a reliable source. Stump was told a "camera crew was dropping in on real scientists doing actual hammerhead research," not creating a low-budget Jaws.

“We'd talk about the research goals and the challenges we face in trying to achieve those goals." Another sleight of hand in a week meant to save sharks lives and counter the fear of a Jaws invasion in some small town.

Davis warns about the outcome of not being overly cautious. "Had I known they would combine it with those ridiculous fishermen to make a show about a mythical shark I would have had some serious second thoughts about participating."

So should scientists even consider working with the network, filming crews, and production? Davis and Stump say yes, but make sure the real truth is being described and never stop asking questions. Using deductive reasoning and put that scientific degree to work.


Stump points the lack of control in editing and presentation of facts, but she does remind other scientists to "be the difference" in the handing out information. "We can't control the editing," but "we can control what we say on-camera."

SyFy’s Swamp Shark was very entertaining, but that doesn’t make it real.

Maybe Shark Week’s not the best way to make sure the truth is out there, yet the solid research lends the "opportunity to be a voice of real science amid an otherwise sensationalist line-up." A very valid point.

Variety points out that Shark Week earned the highest ratings ever with last Sunday's opening. The night pulled a 2.27 rating among adults between 25-54 and averaged 3.64 total viewers overall. In the history of the channel, it ranked 13th highest-rated evening. And that doesn't reference the 4 million Facebook mentions by 3 million users. And 11 trending topics on Twitter that were all Shark Week related.

The audience is clearly there for the network. Discovery started out with good intentions, but somehow the science fell to the side in order to draw people in with glitz and glam.


All Discovery needs is a reminder that the public wants the truth since many will never see a shark up close and person. And if annual repeating showings of a decade-old documentary are going to be used, make sure to provide scientific evidence. If something's changed, follow up.

 

However, there's no need to lie to the public in order to gain ratings. Remember that people are still convinced mermaids are real after the faux documentary was shown on Animal Planet. And the best way to save a shark's life is to provide evidence, not make something up to fit a false narrative.

You Might Also Like

 

Read the Latest

Apple Watch Event Scheduled for March 9

Apple Watch Event Scheduled for March 9 Apple sent out invitations to media for an March 9 media event.

4 hours ago

Samsung Electronics to freeze wages in 2015 in South Korea

Samsung Electronics to freeze wages in 2015 in South Korea Samsung electronics is going to be freezing salaries for its employees this year in South Korea and the move comes as a...

6 hours ago

Photo credit: CARL DE SOUZA/Getty Images

White Shark Attack: 18-Foot Great White Behind Fatal Seal Mauling Off Washington Coast Marine biologists in Washington State believe an enormous great white shark is likely the culprit behind a dead seal,...

6 hours ago

Focus: Will Smith and Margot Robbie battle for the Ultimate Con

Focus: Will Smith and Margot Robbie battle for the Ultimate Con Will Smith and Margot Robbie start as master and protégé in the con film and try their best to keep the game up with...

7 hours ago

 Apple Watch Edition could use up third of world’s gold

Apple Watch Edition could use up third of world’s gold Apple is targeting to sale 1 Million Watch Edition per month which may use up third of world’s gold

7 hours ago

Lindsay Lohan confuses Community Service with on Stage Performances

Lindsay Lohan has to Redo 125 hours of Community Service Lindsay Lohan served a major portion of her 240 hours of community service while performing on stage and arranging...

7 hours ago

Swatch announces to make Batteries with Unmatched Storage Capacity

Swatch announces to make Batteries with Unmatched Storage Capacity Swatch Group CEO Nick Hayek let out another bold statement after announcing a smartwatch a couple weeks ago. In a new...

8 hours ago

Photo credit: Allison Shelley/Stringer/Getty Images

Cannabis Possession Now Legal In DC: Pot Ban Lifted In Nation's Capitol In a surprise move, DC lawmakers moved ahead with passing legislation to make marijuana legal -- despite sanctions from...

8 hours ago

Imagine Dragons topple Drake to dominate on Billboard 200

Imagine Dragons topple Drake to dominate on Billboard 200 The second album ‘Smoke + Mirrors’ of the rock band Imagine Dragons secured the number one place on the Billboard 200...

8 hours ago

Sony makes Chappie the first Movie Character to Play Live on Twitch

Sony makes Chappie the first Movie Character to Play Live on Twitch Sony found a creative way to promote the upcoming movie CHAPPiE by setting up a Evolve gamer event on Twitch.

8 hours ago

Jihadi John indentified as Mohammed Emwazi from London

Jihadi John indentified as Mohammed Emwazi from London Breaking News: A new report claims to have identified the infamous Jihadi John. He appeared in several beheading videos...

8 hours ago

Bobbi Kristina Brown Still Unresponsive with No Improvement

Bobbi Kristina Brown is Still in Coma News of taking Bobbi Kristina Brown’s out of a chemically induced coma are all false, as only her meds were changed to...

9 hours ago

Facebook starts Suicide Prevention Service for Vulnerable Members

Facebook starts Suicide Prevention Service for Vulnerable Members Mark Zuckerberg’s social network, Facebook, has started a suicide prevention service for those members who are...

11 hours ago

BRIT Awards: Kanye West jumps on Table while Kim Kardashian fails to take Selfie

BRIT Awards: Kanye West jumps on Table while Kim Kardashian fails to take Selfie Kanye West and his spouse Kim Kardashian did their stuff before and during the BRIT Awards respectively. Kanye jumped...

11 hours ago

President Barack Obama to safeguard Immigrant Rights as per Policy

President Barack Obama to safeguard Immigrant Rights as per Policy The President of the United States, Barack Obama is to safeguard immigrant rights as per state policy. It is in...

13 hours ago

Margot Robbie slapped Leonardo DiCaprio  to land ‘Wolf of Wall Street’

Margot Robbie slapped Leonardo DiCaprio to land ‘Wolf of Wall Street’ The April 2015 issue of the magazine Harper’s Bazaar UK will be featuring Margot Robbie on the front cover with an...

14 hours ago

LG’s Watch Urbane LTE Smartwatch Supports Mobile Payments

LG’s Watch Urbane LTE Smartwatch Supports Mobile Payments While Apple has yet to launch its luxury smartwatch, LG announced its own luxury wearable last week, calling it the LG...

14 hours ago

Samsung Galaxy S6 and S6 Edge Hands-on Photos Leak

Samsung Galaxy S6 and S6 Edge Hands-on Photos Leak The new Samsung Galaxy S6 suffers same leak as the new HTC One ahead of the Mobile World Congress 2015 reveal. Why does...

14 hours ago

Sony will not Sell Off TV And Mobile Spinoffs

Sony will not Sell Off TV And Mobile Spinoffs Sony President Kazuo Hirai clarified on Wednesday that the company will not immediately sell off the spun out TV and...

15 hours ago

Giant Black Hole 12 Billion Times Bigger than Sun Discovered

Discovery of Supermassive Black Hole 12 Billion Times Bigger than Sun challenges Physics Scientists have discovered a giant black hole that is 12 billion times bigger than our sun. It is indeed an exciting...

15 hours ago

Apple Watch gets 12-page Vogue Magazine Ad

Apple Watch gets 12-page Vogue Magazine Ad The March issue of Vogue Magazine packs 12 pages of Apple Watch ads.

15 hours ago

Google Reportedly Launching New Payments API Called Android Pay

Google Reportedly Launching New Payments API Called Android Pay Google is the first company to test the mobile payments space. In 2011, the company launched Google Wallet, but...

16 hours ago

Zendaya Coleman appreciates Giuliana Rancic's Apology

Zendaya Coleman appreciates Giuliana Rancic's Apology Zendaya Coleman accepted the public apology by Giuliana Rancic in a positive message posted on her Instagram account.

16 hours ago

Madonna falls off the Stage at BRIT Awards 2015

Madonna falls off the Stage at BRIT Awards 2015 Madonna falls from the stage due to a wardrobe malfunction as a back-up dancer pulled her neck down.

17 hours ago

Rajon Rondo Suspended 1 Game For Conduct Detrimental To Team

Rajon Rondo Suspended 1 Game For Conduct Detrimental To Team The Dallas Mavericks suspended point guard Rajon Rondo for the Feb. 25 game against the Atlanta Hawks for conduct...

17 hours ago

Gemalto Confirms It Was Hacked

Gemalto Confirms It Was Hacked Gemalto, the world’s largest manufacturer of SIM cards, is confirming that its computer networks were indeed attacked...

20 hours ago

Detroit Lions Release Reggie Bush

Detroit Lions Release Reggie Bush The Detroit Lions released running back Reggie Bush on Feb. 25.

20 hours ago

Photo credit: Veejay Villafranca/Getty Images

'En Caul' Birth: Premature Baby Born In Amniotic Sac Leaves Doctors Speechless Baby Silas Philips is part of rare air. The pre-term baby was born in his mom's amniotic sac and is doing well...

22 hours ago

Josh Hamilton Facing Undisclosed Disciplinary Action From MLB

Josh Hamilton Facing Undisclosed Disciplinary Action From MLB Los Angeles Angels left fielder Josh Hamilton will meet Major League Baseball (MLB) officials about an undisclosed...

22 hours ago

Photo credit: THIERRY ZOCCOLAN/Getty Images

Paris Drone Sightings: 3 Arrests Not Related, UAVS 'Pose No Threat' The mystery of five drone sightings over Paris has widened. Although three arrests were made in wake of the unmanned...

1 day ago, 3:19pm CST

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus