Menu
Trending: Holiday Gifts | CES 2015 | Super Bowl 2015 Ads More Topics: Apple | Cars | TV Shows | Politics
Star Wars Christmas Lights Video Goes Viral

Star Wars Christmas Lights Video Goes Viral

CES 2015: LG will unveil its New 4K Ultra HD TV with Quantum Dot Technology

CES 2015: LG will unveil its New 4K Ultra HD TV with Quantum Dot Technology

Budweiser Super Bowl 2015 Ad leaks

Budweiser Super Bowl 2015 Ad leaks

The Best 2014 Super Bowl Ads

The Best 2014 Super Bowl Ads

Tesla Roadster Makes Comeback

Tesla Roadster Makes Comeback

Shark Week: Fake Discovery Documentaries Abound

Aug 17 2014, 4:02pm CDT | by , in News | Latest TV News

Shark Week: Fake Discovery Documentaries Abound
Photo Credit: Getty Images
/* Story Top Left 2010 300x250, created 7/15/10 */ google_ad_slot = "8340327155";
 
 

Thanks to the liberal use of CGI, fans of Shark Week are catching on to the fake set ups--and io9 found the proof.

Shark Week's one of the most anticipated events of the year, where the network adds a new documentaries and one-off shows into rotation. Shark Week is a non-stop infomercial on the awe-inspiring predators.

Viewers may find the documentaries featuring actual scientists as interesting learning tools. Who doesn't trust an expert, right? But the interviewed scientists told everyone to be wary since you shouldn't trust the filmed information…at all.

Earlier this week, io9.com reported clever editing managed to twist scientist words to fit into a faux documentary, while lying to the expert on what the subject was really about.


Take Jonathan Davis, for instance.

Davis currently works for the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department, but was approached by the network to do a documentary on the sharks of Louisiana—his area of expertise.

Asking questions on the overall project's goal, he never received a "straight answer and the producer seemed to avoid the question." After some persistence, production explained it would be part of a larger documentary on Louisiana shark research.

Reasonable, right? The show’s produced numerous specials about shark species where a group of scientists describe how research connects the dots.

Instead, the network eventually produced the 2013 special called Voodoo Sharks about Rookin, a mythical monster stalking the bayous. Splicing the interview about real situations and possibilities with local fisherman, Rookin seemed to be a "race between his team of researchers and the fishermen to see who could catch the mythical voodoo shark faster."


Davis explained about the filming process. "I was fed certain words to rephrase my sentences in ways that the producer thought would spark more interest." Makes sense from a monetary side for advertising, even if he refused to use their lies. Also seems a little bit like an episode of Big Brother.

In the beginning of Voodoo Sharks, directors implied a monster lurked alone the shores of Lake Pontchartrain and they used Davis’s answers to create a narrative about the validity of Rooken. And by doing so, Discovery also managed to make it seem as if Davis believed in the mythical creature, instead of the truth.

For the record, there is no voodoo shark. So, that was a bold-faced lie.

And despite Davis's criticism, the network's continued the practice this year. Kristine Stump's working on her post-doctoral research as an assistant at the Shedd Aquarium, but Discovery used her interview to bolster Monster Hammerhead—where they claim a hammerhead's lived along the Florida coast for over 60 years.


Too bad the truth is completely different. The average life span of a hammerhead is only 44 years, so a large one living for 60 years seems very unlikely. And unlike SyFy's often humorous, campy monster flicks about a Sharknado or Mega Shark, Discovery's supposed to be a reliable source. Stump was told a "camera crew was dropping in on real scientists doing actual hammerhead research," not creating a low-budget Jaws.

“We'd talk about the research goals and the challenges we face in trying to achieve those goals." Another sleight of hand in a week meant to save sharks lives and counter the fear of a Jaws invasion in some small town.

Davis warns about the outcome of not being overly cautious. "Had I known they would combine it with those ridiculous fishermen to make a show about a mythical shark I would have had some serious second thoughts about participating."

So should scientists even consider working with the network, filming crews, and production? Davis and Stump say yes, but make sure the real truth is being described and never stop asking questions. Using deductive reasoning and put that scientific degree to work.


Stump points the lack of control in editing and presentation of facts, but she does remind other scientists to "be the difference" in the handing out information. "We can't control the editing," but "we can control what we say on-camera."

SyFy’s Swamp Shark was very entertaining, but that doesn’t make it real.

Maybe Shark Week’s not the best way to make sure the truth is out there, yet the solid research lends the "opportunity to be a voice of real science amid an otherwise sensationalist line-up." A very valid point.

Variety points out that Shark Week earned the highest ratings ever with last Sunday's opening. The night pulled a 2.27 rating among adults between 25-54 and averaged 3.64 total viewers overall. In the history of the channel, it ranked 13th highest-rated evening. And that doesn't reference the 4 million Facebook mentions by 3 million users. And 11 trending topics on Twitter that were all Shark Week related.

The audience is clearly there for the network. Discovery started out with good intentions, but somehow the science fell to the side in order to draw people in with glitz and glam.


All Discovery needs is a reminder that the public wants the truth since many will never see a shark up close and person. And if annual repeating showings of a decade-old documentary are going to be used, make sure to provide scientific evidence. If something's changed, follow up.

 

However, there's no need to lie to the public in order to gain ratings. Remember that people are still convinced mermaids are real after the faux documentary was shown on Animal Planet. And the best way to save a shark's life is to provide evidence, not make something up to fit a false narrative.

You Might Also Like

Read the Latest

Facebook launches FaceTube to compete YouTube

Facebook launches FaceTube to compete YouTube It has established that all businesses on Facebook will be offered a featured video strip with the latest videos...

7 hours ago, 12:28pm CST

LG makes 4 additions to wireless speakers range for CES

LG makes 4 additions to wireless speakers range for CES The new additions include a battery-powered portable wireless speaker, two sound bars and a streaming 3D Blu-ray Player

8 hours ago, 12:26pm CST

CES 2015 News
First Shelby GT 350 Mustang to be Barrett-Jackson's Scottsdale sale

First Shelby GT 350 Mustang to be Barrett-Jackson's Scottsdale sale The proceeds of the sale are going to be donated to the Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation (JDRF)

8 hours ago, 11:54am CST

LG Exec Could Be Banned From CES For Sabotaging a Washing Machine

LG Exec Could Be Banned From CES For Sabotaging a Washing Machine Samsung filed a lawsuit for property damage and defamation against five LG execs back in September

10 hours ago, 9:57am CST

Madonna Tracks Leak Online Again from Rebel Heart

14 More Madonna Tracks Leak Madonna’s new album Rebel Hearts has already been hacked once before. Five of the tracks were officially released on...

11 hours ago, 8:38am CST

MINI John Cooper Works Hardtop to be displayed at the NAIAS Detroit 2015

MINI John Cooper Works Hardtop to be displayed at the NAIAS Detroit 2015 BMW’s famous mini cooper’s new design will be displayed at the NAIAS 2015 in Detroit.

12 hours ago, 8:18am CST

Sarah Palin Channel Wardrobe Controversy Video was a Publicity Stunt?

Sarah Palin Channel Wardrobe Controversy Video was a Publicity Stunt? Most people are talking about the one term governor’s show of skin on live channel. Sarah Palin ran for the Vice...

12 hours ago, 7:54am CST

Patchworks to represent North and South America at CES 2015

Patchworks to represent North and South America at CES 2015 Patchworks Global Inc. make flawlessly engineered products for iPhone Screen Protection that it will display at the CES...

12 hours ago, 7:47am CST

How to Watch The Interview Online Right Now

How to Watch The Interview Online Right Now Sony Pictures announce the online release of ‘The Interview’ with the help of online sources. Google, Microsoft and...

13 hours ago, 7:05am CST

Luxoft Software Development Services will also participate in CES 2015 and CTS 2015

Luxoft Software Development Services will also participate in CES 2015 and CTS 2015 It seems everyone is eager to take part in the CES 2015.

14 hours ago, 6:13am CST

Peyton Manning to Return to Broncos in 2015

Peyton Manning to Return to Broncos in 2015 The player, Peyton Manning, is planning to return to Denver Broncos next year since he has no plans to leave the field...

14 hours ago, 6:08am CST

First Alert also to take on the Polar Vortex at CES 2015

First Alert also to take on the Polar Vortex at CES 2015 The new Onelink Series by First Alert introduces many new products which will be displayed at the CES 2015. New Onelink...

15 hours ago, 5:20am CST

Uber CEO Charged with Illegitimate Business Practice in South Korea

Uber CEO Charged with Illegitimate Business Practice in South Korea The CEO of taxi service Uber has been charged with illegitimate business practice in South Korea.

15 hours ago, 5:15am CST

NBA pulls Sorority Sisters Advertising

NBA pulls Sorority Sisters Advertising NBA has announced Wednesday to pull all advertising from VH1's Sorority Sisters show.

15 hours ago, 4:33am CST

First Alert to debut Onelink Series of Smart Devices at CES 2015

CES 2015 to feature First Alert Onelink Series of Smart Devices These new and innovative products by First Alert will bring a new level of security and accessibility to Connected Home...

16 hours ago, 4:27am CST

NFL Video Clips will be shown on Facebook with Verizon Wireless Ads

Facebook-NFL Deal: NFL Video Clips will be shown on Facebook with Verizon Wireless Ads Facebook is into showing NFL post game highlights and other video clips with a little advertising help from Verizon.

16 hours ago, 3:35am CST

Acura NSX Production Model to debut at NAIAS 2015

Acura NSX Production Model to debut at NAIAS 2015 The luxury vehicle division of Honda Motor Company will be displaying its new model at the NAIAS 2015.

17 hours ago, 3:00am CST

Renovo Coupe to be on display at CES 2015

Renovo Coupe to be on display at CES 2015 The first all-electric American supercar will be featured in the NVIDIA Booth (#30307)

17 hours ago, 2:39am CST

CES 2015: SymbolShifters to unveil a New Method for connecting Traditional TV Broadcast to the Digital World

CES 2015: SymbolShifters to unveil a New Method for connecting Traditional TV Broadcast to the Digital World At CES 2015, a new American company, SymbolShifters is planning to introduce a method for connecting traditional TV...

18 hours ago, 2:28am CST

PlayStation Now Game Streaming Service arriving on Samsung Smart TVs Next Year

PlayStation Now Game Streaming Service arriving on Samsung Smart TVs Next Year The Sony PlayStation game streaming service "PlayStation Now" is arriving soon on Samsung Smart TVs. In fact...

18 hours ago, 1:59am CST

TRW Automotive will display its latest Automated Systems at CES 2015

TRW Automotive will display its latest Automated Systems at CES 2015 TRW Automotive will bring its new automotive innovations at the CES 2015 in Las Vegas.

18 hours ago, 1:43am CST

CES 2015 garners ad campaign awards

CES 2015 garners ad campaign awards 3 major associations give CES ad awards

21 hours ago, 10:56pm CST

Personal Health to be part of CES 2015

Personal Health to be part of CES 2015 TENSIO device to help high blood pressure consumers

21 hours ago, 10:53pm CST

LG to feature Smart TV tech at CES 2015

LG to feature Smart TV tech at CES 2015 webOS 2.0 to be with simple interface

21 hours ago, 10:49pm CST

CES 2015: Prima-Temp to Introduce its Revolutionary Fertility Awareness Sensor

CES 2015: Prima-Temp to Introduce its Revolutionary Fertility Awareness Sensor This new innovation by Prima-Temp will accurately and easily inform women when they are most fertile and will be...

1 day ago, 11:52am CST

Adam Sandler tops the Most Overpaid Actors List

Adam Sandler tops the Most Overpaid Actors List Adam Sandler is the actor who has returned the least on his earnings from the movies. Sandra Bullock is the only...

1 day ago, 8:22am CST

2015 Dodge Challenger SRT Hellcat Crashed

2015 Dodge Challenger SRT Hellcat Crashed The car was brought by Lance Utley from the showroom and got in an accident in just an hour. According to reports the...

1 day ago, 7:29am CST

James Woods turns guns on Al Sharpton for NYPD Cop Deaths

James Woods turns guns on Al Sharpton for NYPD Cop Deaths Rafael Ramos and Wenjian Liu were shot dead by Ismaaiyl Brinsley. Woods balmed Al Sharpton for the anti-cop agenda and...

1 day ago, 6:48am CST

Helena Bonham Carter and Tim Burton Separate

Helena Bonham Carter and Tim Burton Separate The couple had unconventional relationships and never got married. The reps for both celebrities said they are still...

1 day ago, 5:55am CST

CES 2015 will also showcase WiTricity's Rezence-Enabled Solutions

CES 2015 will also showcase WiTricity's Rezence-Enabled Solutions WiTricity is all set to demonstrate Rezence-Enabled Solutions and A4WP reference designs at the CES 2015.

1 day ago, 5:19am CST

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus