Consumer Reports: The Apple iPhone 3GS is #1

Jul 6 2009, 10:15am CDT | by Robert Evans

Consumer Reports recently compared and rated the top smartphones in the country. To no one's surprise, the iPhone 3GS was the star of the show. It beat out every other smartphone on the market in terms of overall score. What's remarkable isn't that the 3GS won, it's how narrow a margin it won by.

The test rated phones on a scale of 0 to 100. The 3GS scored a 73, the 3G and Omnia a 70, the BlackBerry 9530/G1/Bold and Samsung Epix all tied at 69, and the Pre/Curve and Insight came in at 68. The fact that none of the smartphones scored better than a 73 says that either Consumer Report's standards are too high, or that actual consumer standards are too low.

Consumer Reports changed things up a bit for this test. They tweaked their rating system to put more emphasis on things like app handling, mobile browsing, and multimedia than on call time or quality. That's just further proof that consumers are starting to value different qualities in a mobile phone than ever before.

The most surprising thing about this study to me was how poorly the Pre performed. While all of the top smartphones came in very close together, the Pre was rated below both the 3G and the T-Mobile G1, two much older phones. When the next generation of Android phones hits in force, I expect this list to change significantly. If the G1 did this well despite its outdated hardware, a brand-new smartphone loaded with an improved version of Android should clean up.

where to buy

Buy from Amazon

What Others Say about This

BlackBerry faces new challenge from US agency

Toronto: In another blow for beleaguered BlackBerry maker Research In Motion , the US federal government's main procurement agency is issuing iPhones and Android-based devices to some of its 17,000 workers. While the General Services Administration does ...
Full article at: Firstpost More like this 45 minutes ago

AMD graphics CTO leaves for unknown areas

AMD CTO Eric Demers leaves for non-GPU firm Another AMD executive departure has fueled speculation Tuesday. Graphics division CTO Eric Demers is known to be exiting the chip designer as of February 17. Former Apple executive and current primary CTO Mark ...
Full article at: Electronista More like this 45 minutes ago

Apple's Size Clouds Market

By Jonathan Cheng And Brendan Intindola In analyzing U.S. corporate earnings and stock-market trends, apples-to-apples comparisons may now require tossing out the Apple.Apple Inc.'s success selling consumer gadgets has pushed its share price above $500, ...
Full article at: Wall Street Journal More like this 45 minutes ago

Don't miss ...

Apple

iPad 3 Announcement rumored for Early March

Robert Evans
The excitement about new smartphones, tablets and anything mobile drive Robert to unearth the latest rumors and developments in this fast moving space. He adopted 4G as soon as it become available and knows where the mobile market is going.
Robert can be contacted directly at robert@i4u.com.