Filed under: News | Technology News


Google's Ranking Algorithm is still Broken for Us after 5 Weeks of Panda

Google Panda Update is getting frustrating for Journalists.

Mar 31 2011, 8:30am CDT | by

Proof That Google's Ranking Algorithm is Broken

Google has a big problem with content "farmers". And they ought to. Low quality content scraping sites are a pox upon the Internet. But Google's definition of just what constitutes a content farm is more than a little fuzzy. The search engine was happy to throw out some sweeping reforms to their ranking algorithm. But they don't really seem to care about helping sites wrongly identified as content farms from getting back to their rightful place.

Some sites have been able to 'fix' their traffic by complaining loudly enough to Google. I4U was not one of those sites. Which lead to a really uncomfortable situation last week when I posted my iPad 2 in Guatemala review.

The organic search results for "iPad Guatemala" are right here. Summaries from three different news blogs show up before the original article itself. Which, by the way, ends up on the very bottom of the page. If we add "volcano" to the search terms, things get even more messed up. The first page shows ten different sites, most of which simply repackaged the same basic summary. I haven't gone further than the third page, but I4U still hadn't shown up at all by then.

My final test was "iPad 2 Guatemala Review". Surely that would return I4U at the top of the search results. Nope. Eight other sites show up before ours does. Most of them even used the exact same title as the original article did. Where is Google's support for original content? Is I4U somehow less legitimate a source than those sites feeding off my review?

Google is fond of making great, sweeping changes, but they have a bad habit of not looking before they leap. We saw it with Google Buzz and we're seeing it again with their 'war' on content farming. The purpose of this whole brouhaha is, ostensibly, to push blogs and news rags to put out more original content. I did that. And Google gave our traffic away to someone else.

Thanks for the incentive, guys.

Note from the Chief Editor:
We have been actively trying to change our site to address potential issues that are discussed as reasons for suffering from Panda. Either our actions have not been the correct ones or Google is not updating their data to help get sites out of the deep Panda hole that publish original content. Besides the financial stress Google put on us, or writers like Robert describes above are getting more and more frustrated to not get a fair chance on getting their work read.

You Might Also Like


Shopping Deals


<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/5" rel="author">Robert Evans</a>
The excitement about new smartphones, tablets and anything mobile drive Robert to unearth the latest rumors and developments in this fast moving space. He adopted 4G as soon as it become available and knows where the mobile market is going.
Robert can be contacted directly at




blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Shonda Rhimes Appears on Jimmy Kimmel Live
Shonda Rhimes Appears on Jimmy Kimmel Live
The executive producer of Scandal and Grey’s Anatomy made an appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live. Shonda Rhimes took on the rapid fire round of questions with aptness and aplomb on Jimmy Kimmel Live: Behind the Scandalabra. Scandal bloopers were also shown to audiences that were never seen before.
Lea Michele and Naya Rivera at Loggerheads on Glee Set
Lea Michele Fights with Naya Rivera on set of Glee
Lea Michele and Naya Rivera have been at loggerheads with each other of late on the set of Glee. The two have caused real life scenes beside the reel life scenes.
Apple Building Identification Feature Into iTunes
Apple Building Identification Feature Into iTunes
Future iOS devices will include a built in Shazam powered service
Joan of Shark Tagged as one of the Largest Shark
Joan of Shark: World's Largest White Shark Tagged
A shark that has been tagged recently, Joan of Shark, is slated to be one of the largest great white sharks ever seen. It has a length that is in excess of 16 feet.

The Hottest Photos of Victoria's Secret Fashion Show 2013


Viral Stories the Web