Black Friday 2014 Ads, Sales and Deals
Menu
Walmart Black Friday Pre Sale launched Online

Walmart Black Friday Pre Sale launched Online

Amazon Black Friday 2014 Deals Week has launched

Amazon Black Friday 2014 Deals Week has launched

The Best Xbox One Black Friday Deal is not at Target or Walmart

The Best Xbox One Black Friday Deal is not at Target or Walmart

$1 Samsung Galaxy S5 Best Buy Black Friday Deal sells early on 11/23

$1 Samsung Galaxy S5 Best Buy Black Friday Deal sells early on 11/23

Luxury Camper in Line for Best Buy Black Friday 2014 Sale

Luxury Camper in Line for Best Buy Black Friday 2014 Sale

Understanding Patent Lawsuits: Why Google Bid $900m on Nortel's Carrion

Apr 4 2011, 2:59pm CDT | by , in News | Technology News

Understanding Patent Lawsuits: Why Google Bid $900 on Nortel's Carrion
 
 

Sometimes selling out makes sense.


Today, Google announced their bid of $900 million on the remaining patent portfolio of the dying Nortel Networks. If the deal goes through, Google will find themselves armed with an additional 6,000 patents.

What the Hell is a Patent?

The grand high arbitor of truth, Wikipedia, defines a patent as "a set of exclusive rights" granted to an inventor for a "limited period of time". In practice, patents are granted to corporations for vague ideas about product features, forever. Patent lawsuits represent a sort of international trade language, a way for major corporations to work out their disagreements.

In theory, a patent must both NOVEL and NON-OBVIOUS. What those two terms mean is largely dependent upon the skill of one's lawyers.

A Fun Example:

H-W Technology recently sued Apple, Google, Motorola and pretty much every other tech company in the world for violating US Patent 7,525,955. Said patent involves an "Internet protocol (IP) phone with search and advertising capability." (a smartphone) that allows users to "receive information and offers from merchants and to complete a transaction with one of said merchants without having to generate a voice call." (that lets you order things from the Internet).

If that sounds obvious to you...you probably don't work as a patent clerk. The application was filed in 2005 and granted in 2009. Why H-W waited the additional two years to sue is anyone's guess.

Why Google is Pissed:

"Wildcard" suits like the one above involve one small, greedy company poking at fat wealth-sacks and hoping for a quick settlement. Things get more serious when a huge, greedy company decides to lawyer down. Open Source products are particularly vulnerable to IP Vampires. At least 38 Android patent lawsuits have been filed since March 2010. Microsoft recently alleged that Linux violates some 200 patents. They claim that the high quality of open source applications hinges largely on intellectual property theft.

Since Android operates on the Linux kernel, this puts them at risk for some very expensive lawsuits. We're talking Billions, with emphasis on that capital B. While Microsoft has been so far content to poke Google partners, like Barnes & Noble, a future legal clash seems inevitable. Even if Microsoft takes their sweet time, Google will still have the Oracle suit to deal with.

Oracle currently claims that Google violated seven patents in the making and distribution of Android.

Nortel is selling an Arsenal:

As noted in their blog entry, Google is a young company. They haven't had decades to build up a gigantic stockpile of defensive (and offensive) patents. This Nortel acquisition represents their best chance to avoid potentially billions in losses. It's hard to blame Google for taking an action so clearly in their best interest. But it's also hard to see how this move will do anything but perpetuate the madness of our current patent system. It's hard to see how the current legal climate does anything but stifle innovation.

James Gosling, considered by some to be the father of Java is even on record as saying, "There was even an unofficial competition to see who could get the goofiest patent through the system." during his time at Sun. The actual legitimacy of the patent doesn't matter, so much as the fact that it exists and that the company in question has enough money to defend it.

Is Google a Sell-Out or a Survivalist?

While Google has been a long-time supporter of the stalled Patent Reform Bill, their recent behavior can't help but reinforce the status quo. Google will be one more company with a major investment in keeping patent laws where they are.  Google had this to say about Microsoft's recent Barnes & Noble lawsuit:


"Sweeping software patent claims...threaten innovation".

They see this $900 million bid as a move to protect their own innovations from IP vampires. If Google sticks to their guns and refuses to file any "sweeping" claims, we can consider them true to their words. But if they counter-sue, well...at least we'll  have ringside seats for one hell of a legal fracas.

Black Friday 2014 Deals

Amazon Black Friday Deals Week
Walmart Black Friday Deals and Ads
Best Buy Black Friday Deals and Ads
Target Black Friday Deals and Ads
Apple Black Friday Deals and Ads
Sears Black Friday Deals and Ads
Dell Black Friday Deals and Ads
NewEgg Black Friday Deals and Ads
Kmart Black Friday Deals and Ads
 

Read the Latest

The Best 50-inch TV Black Friday 2014 Deals

The Best 50-inch TV Black Friday 2014 Deals 50-inch TV Black Friday Deals are as low as $199.99.

57 minutes ago

40-inch TV Black Friday 2014 Deals under $200

40-inch TV Black Friday 2014 Deals under $200 These are the sub $200 40-inch TV Black Friday Deals of 2014.

1 hour ago

32-inch TV Black Friday 2014 Deals under $100

32-inch TV Black Friday 2014 Deals under $100 These are the sub-$100 32-inch TV Black Friday Deals of 2014.

1 hour ago

Video Game Black Friday 2014 Deals selling Now

Video Game Black Friday 2014 Deals selling Now Black Friday 2014 is here and with it the best time to score deals on Video Games. We have found the best video game...

2 hours ago

$98.87 Nintendo 2DS Crystal Red is on Sale in Walmart Black Friday Sale

$98.87 Nintendo 2DS Crystal Red is on Sale in Walmart Black Friday Sale The Walmart Black Friday 2014 sale launched on Friday 11/21 matches Black Friday deals of competitors or even beat...

2 hours ago

Movie Black Friday 2014 Deals selling Now

Movie Black Friday 2014 Deals selling Now Black Friday 2014 is here and with it the best time to score deals on Movie and TV Show on DVD and Blu-ray.

3 hours ago

The iPhone 6's A8 chip can play 4K video

The iPhone 6's A8 chip can play 4K video While testing the app developers found it is possible to playback 4K videos on the iPhone 6.

3 hours ago

32-inch TV Deals under $200 on Sale in Amazon Black Friday 2014 Sale Today

32-inch TV Deals under $200 on Sale in Amazon Black Friday 2014 Sale Today The Amazon Black Friday 2014 Sale has launched. The Amazon Black Friday 2014 Sale starts earlier than ever before. Here...

4 hours ago

Apple Black Friday 2014 Deals did not Leak Yet, but Store Hours

Apple Black Friday 2014 Deals did not Leak Yet, but Store Hours The Apple Store will open at 8am on Black Friday, November 28. We predict that the Apple Black Friday 2014 Sale in...

4 hours ago

$39.99 RCA RCT6773W22 is best selling Walmart Black Friday 2014 Deal

$39.99 RCA RCT6773W22 is best selling Walmart Black Friday 2014 Deal Walmart offers the RCA RCT6773W22 again for $39.99.

4 hours ago

Kmart Black Friday 2014 Sale for Members is Live

Kmart Black Friday 2014 Sale for Members is Live Shop Your Way Members get access to the Kmart Black Friday 2014 deals now online at kmart.com. You can join member...

4 hours ago

$139.99 Samsung Galaxy Tab 4 7 is Amazon Black Friday Deal Today

$139.99 Samsung Galaxy Tab 4 7 is Amazon Black Friday Deal Today The Amazon Black Friday 2014 Sale has launched. The Amazon Black Friday 2014 Sale starts earlier than ever before. Here...

5 hours ago

Best Samsung Galaxy Tab 4 10.1 Black Friday 2014 Deal is selling now on Amazon

Best Samsung Galaxy Tab 4 10.1 Black Friday 2014 Deal is selling now on Amazon The Amazon Black Friday 2014 Sale has launched. The Amazon Black Friday 2014 Sale starts earlier than ever before. Here...

5 hours ago

Apple Inc’s $450 mn e-book settlement gets final court approval

Apple Inc’s $450 mn e-book settlement gets final court approval The $400 mn from Apple comes on top of earlier settlements with 5 publishers in the case, which provided $166 million...

5 hours ago

$199 40-inch Seiki SE40FY27 LED TV is popular in Amazon Black Friday Sale Today

$199 40-inch Seiki SE40FY27 LED TV is popular in Amazon Black Friday Sale Today The Amazon Black Friday 2014 Sale has launched. The Amazon Black Friday 2014 Sale starts earlier than ever before. Here...

5 hours ago

Amazon Cyber Monday 2014 Sale to begin Nov. 29

Amazon Cyber Monday 2014 Sale to begin Nov. 29 Amazon launched the Black Friday 2014 Deals Week earlier than ever. We expect that Amazon will also launch the Cyber...

5 hours ago

The Best Xbox One Black Friday Deal is not at Target or Walmart

The Best Xbox One Black Friday Deal is not at Target or Walmart The Xbox One deals have been revealed in Black Friday 2014 Ads. Here are the best Xbox one Black Friday 2014 deals.

6 hours ago

Madonna condemns Kim K’s Naked Butt while Teachers use it to teach SAT Math

Madonna condemns Kim K’s Naked Butt while Teachers use it to teach SAT Math Catalyst Prep gathered inspiration and used her amazing butt to help students prepare for SATs. Kim Kardashian, despite...

6 hours ago

Walmart Black Friday 2014 Pre Sale Continues with these Deals

Walmart Black Friday 2014 Pre Sale Continues with these Deals The Walmart Pre-Black Friday Sale started yesterday in stores and online at walmart.com. The Pre sale continues today....

6 hours ago

Robin William’s Son Zak speaks about the Great Loss

Robin William’s Son Zak speaks about the Great Loss Robin William’s elder son stated that family is is trying to cope with his loss.

6 hours ago

19 Kids and Counting: Duggars fighting with Petitioners asking to End the Show

19 Kids and Counting: Duggars fighting with Petitioners asking to End the Show The Change.org has started a petition, one of many, urging TLC to cancel the show. The Show’s supporters have started a...

7 hours ago

The Top Black Friday 2014 Ads

The Top Black Friday 2014 Ads The Black Friday 2014 ads have been released and Black Friday 2014 Sales have started. Now is the time to make your...

7 hours ago

2 More Rape Allegations on Bill Cosby

2 More Rape Allegations on Bill Cosby It seems that the allegations just won’t stop.

7 hours ago

Sam's Club Black Friday VIP Event 2014 is Today 11/22 7am

Sam's Club Black Friday VIP Event 2014 is Today 11/22 7am Sam's Club is hosting a VIP Event for its Sam's Club Plus members. This sales event is by invitation only. We...

7 hours ago

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus