Menu
Trending: Holiday Gifts | CES 2015 | Super Bowl 2015 Ads More Topics: Apple | Cars | TV Shows | Politics
The Best 2014 Super Bowl Ads

The Best 2014 Super Bowl Ads

CES 2015: LG will unveil its New 4K Ultra HD TV with Quantum Dot Technology

CES 2015: LG will unveil its New 4K Ultra HD TV with Quantum Dot Technology

Budweiser Super Bowl 2015 Ad leaks

Budweiser Super Bowl 2015 Ad leaks

Google Car Initiative to go ahead via Android

Google Car Initiative to go ahead via Android

Sony cancels The Interview Release on Christmas

Sony cancels The Interview Release on Christmas

Understanding Patent Lawsuits: Why Google Bid $900m on Nortel's Carrion

Apr 4 2011, 2:59pm CDT | by , in News | Technology News

Understanding Patent Lawsuits: Why Google Bid $900 on Nortel's Carrion
 
 

Sometimes selling out makes sense.

Today, Google announced their bid of $900 million on the remaining patent portfolio of the dying Nortel Networks. If the deal goes through, Google will find themselves armed with an additional 6,000 patents.

What the Hell is a Patent?

The grand high arbitor of truth, Wikipedia, defines a patent as "a set of exclusive rights" granted to an inventor for a "limited period of time". In practice, patents are granted to corporations for vague ideas about product features, forever. Patent lawsuits represent a sort of international trade language, a way for major corporations to work out their disagreements.

In theory, a patent must both NOVEL and NON-OBVIOUS. What those two terms mean is largely dependent upon the skill of one's lawyers.

A Fun Example:

H-W Technology recently sued Apple, Google, Motorola and pretty much every other tech company in the world for violating US Patent 7,525,955. Said patent involves an "Internet protocol (IP) phone with search and advertising capability." (a smartphone) that allows users to "receive information and offers from merchants and to complete a transaction with one of said merchants without having to generate a voice call." (that lets you order things from the Internet).

If that sounds obvious to you...you probably don't work as a patent clerk. The application was filed in 2005 and granted in 2009. Why H-W waited the additional two years to sue is anyone's guess.

Why Google is Pissed:

"Wildcard" suits like the one above involve one small, greedy company poking at fat wealth-sacks and hoping for a quick settlement. Things get more serious when a huge, greedy company decides to lawyer down. Open Source products are particularly vulnerable to IP Vampires. At least 38 Android patent lawsuits have been filed since March 2010. Microsoft recently alleged that Linux violates some 200 patents. They claim that the high quality of open source applications hinges largely on intellectual property theft.

Since Android operates on the Linux kernel, this puts them at risk for some very expensive lawsuits. We're talking Billions, with emphasis on that capital B. While Microsoft has been so far content to poke Google partners, like Barnes & Noble, a future legal clash seems inevitable. Even if Microsoft takes their sweet time, Google will still have the Oracle suit to deal with.

Oracle currently claims that Google violated seven patents in the making and distribution of Android.

Nortel is selling an Arsenal:

As noted in their blog entry, Google is a young company. They haven't had decades to build up a gigantic stockpile of defensive (and offensive) patents. This Nortel acquisition represents their best chance to avoid potentially billions in losses. It's hard to blame Google for taking an action so clearly in their best interest. But it's also hard to see how this move will do anything but perpetuate the madness of our current patent system. It's hard to see how the current legal climate does anything but stifle innovation.

James Gosling, considered by some to be the father of Java is even on record as saying, "There was even an unofficial competition to see who could get the goofiest patent through the system." during his time at Sun. The actual legitimacy of the patent doesn't matter, so much as the fact that it exists and that the company in question has enough money to defend it.

Is Google a Sell-Out or a Survivalist?

While Google has been a long-time supporter of the stalled Patent Reform Bill, their recent behavior can't help but reinforce the status quo. Google will be one more company with a major investment in keeping patent laws where they are.  Google had this to say about Microsoft's recent Barnes & Noble lawsuit:

"Sweeping software patent claims...threaten innovation".

They see this $900 million bid as a move to protect their own innovations from IP vampires. If Google sticks to their guns and refuses to file any "sweeping" claims, we can consider them true to their words. But if they counter-sue, well...at least we'll  have ringside seats for one hell of a legal fracas.

You Might Also Like

Read the Latest

ADATA to present Innovative Consumer Products at CES 2015

ADATA to present Innovative Consumer Products at CES 2015 They will unveil World’s fastest DDR4 Memory, USB 3.1, and LED lighting products in the Spotlight

7 hours ago, 11:35am CST

BlackBerry gets positive cash flows

BlackBerry gets positive cash flows BlackBerry Achieves Non-GAAP Profitability and Positive Cash Flow for the Fiscal 2015 Third Quarter

7 hours ago, 11:19am CST

CES 2015 News
Sony's CES 2015 teaser features Android TV

Sony's CES 2015 teaser features Android TV The teaser trailer is a slightly odd collection of scenes including a chameleon, a time-lapse of the Paris skyline and...

7 hours ago, 11:13am CST

Startups at the International CES 2015

Startups at the International CES 2015 Eureka Park will be the one featuring these startups which total to around 375 at this years CES.

8 hours ago, 10:53am CST

CES 2015 also to host Extreme Tech Challenge Semi-Finals

CES 2015 also to host Extreme Tech Challenge Semi-Finals The competition will bring together resources and world-class advisors to the CES 2015 platform in order to help...

8 hours ago, 10:46am CST

CES 2015 will also feature ACCESS Twine for Virtual Multiscreen Content Libraries

CES 2015 will also feature ACCESS Twine for Virtual Multiscreen Content Libraries The new ACCESS Twine will be for Virtual Multiscreen Content Libraries at the CES 2015. This will offer a single user...

10 hours ago, 8:34am CST

Sidney Crosby Comes Out of Isolation at Pittsburgh Penguins Sidney Crosby Comes Out of Isolation at Pittsburgh Penguins

11 hours ago, 7:50am CST

CES 2015: IC Real Tech will debut World’s First 720-Degree Immersive Video Camera

CES 2015: IC Real Tech will debut World’s First 720-Degree Immersive Video Camera It will be viewed and controlled via todays leading mobile devices and also delivers 3D like monitoring experience. The...

12 hours ago, 6:57am CST

Game Worn Michael Jordan Shoes sold for $33k

Game Worn Michael Jordan Shoes sold for $33k The right side foot is signed by Jordan along with ‘Best Wishes’ although it is faded now. The shoes were definitely...

12 hours ago, 6:45am CST

THX to bring new HDMI tech to CES 2015

THX to bring new HDMI tech to CES 2015 4K Interconnect program to work with 2.0 and beyond

12 hours ago, 6:42am CST

Smart Wallet tech coming to CES 2015

Smart Wallet tech coming to CES 2015 NXT-ID to unveil Wocket smart wallet

12 hours ago, 6:20am CST

CES 2015 to feature Toshiba's Wide Range of Next-Generation Innovations

CES 2015 to feature Toshiba's Wide Range of Next-Generation Innovations The Toshiba exhibition at the CES 2015 is going to include new concept innovations and solutions for energy, storage...

12 hours ago, 6:09am CST

CES 2015: ZTE to showcase Voice Controlled Star 2 with an Array of Flagship Devices

CES 2015: ZTE to showcase Voice Controlled Star 2 with an Array of Flagship Devices ZTE launched its flagship smart phone Star 2 in China on Thursday. ZTE is going to showcase an array of flagship...

13 hours ago, 5:11am CST

#Instapurge 2014: Instagram deletes Millions Of Followers from Justin Bieber, Kim Kardashian, Beyonce and Many Other Celeb's Accounts

#Instapurge 2014: Instagram deletes Millions Of Followers from Justin Bieber, Kim Kardashian, Beyonce and Many Other Celeb's Accounts An Instapurge of sorts has occurred on Instagram in the current year. And the top 100 accounts have been affected.

14 hours ago, 4:15am CST

Pepsi Hyped for Halftime campaign pushes Super Bowl 2015 Halftime Show

Pepsi Hyped for Halftime campaign pushes Super Bowl 2015 Halftime Show Pepsi has already geared up their Super Bowl 2015 campaign for the Pepsi sponsored Super Bowl 2015 halftime show...

16 hours ago, 2:18am CST

Google Car Initiative to go ahead via Android

Google Car Initiative to go ahead via Android Google is taking an initiative in its quest for a car and it is to go ahead with it via Android facility.

17 hours ago, 1:50am CST

Matt Kemp's Arthritis Diagnosis Jeopardizes Trade to San Diego Padres

Matt Kemp's Arthritis Diagnosis Jeopardizes Trade to San Diego Padres Los Angeles Dodgers outfielder Matt Kemp was diagnosed with arthritis in both of his hips on Dec. 18. The finding...

22 hours ago, 8:27pm CST

Chicago Bears Confused With Marc Trestman's Discipline Methods

Chicago Bears Confused With Marc Trestman's Discipline Methods The Chicago Bears are confused at how head coach Marc Trestman has handled several discipline cases lately. The most...

23 hours ago, 7:38pm CST

Rajon Rondo On Dallas Mavericks' Radar

Rajon Rondo On Dallas Mavericks' Radar Boston Celtics point guard Rajon Rondo has been the subject of trade rumors. One of the teams reportedly vying for his...

1 day ago, 5:56pm CST

The Funniest Commercials of the Year 2014 Airs Tonight on Spike TV

The Funniest Commercials of the Year 2014 Airs Tonight on Spike TV The Funniest Commercials of the Year 2014 show will be hosted for the first time by Gabriel Iglesias.

1 day ago, 9:04am CST

Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare is $39.99

Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare is $39.99 Today Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare is on sale for $39.99 for Xbox One, Sony PS4, Sony PS3 and Xbox 360.

1 day ago, 7:59am CST

Sony cancels The Interview Release on Christmas

Sony cancels The Interview Release on Christmas The decision was made after multiple theaters refused to screen the movie. Sony Studios has expressed its dismay over...

1 day ago, 7:58am CST

Charlie Sheen to Reprise his role from Ferris Bueller’s Day Off on the Goldbergs

Charlie Sheen to reprise role from Ferris Bueller’s Day Off on the Goldbergs His role in the movie was a side character in the movie and made out with Jennifer Grey. He will be playing the same...

1 day ago, 7:29am CST

CES 2015: JINS MEME Sensing Eyewear

CES 2015: JINS MEME Sensing Eyewear a new wearable device called JINS MEME will be presented at the CES 2015.

1 day ago, 7:24am CST

AMC Theaters and MoviePass collaborate to deliver New Subscription Service

AMC Theaters and MoviePass collaborate to deliver New Subscription Movie Service AMC Theaters and MoviePass have collaborated to deliver a new subscription service for the common people.

1 day ago, 6:56am CST

CES 2015: SecuGen to display its New U20 & SDA04PX Fingerprint Sensors

CES 2015: SecuGen to display its New U20 & SDA04PX Fingerprint Sensors The U20 and SDA04PX are OEM Fingerprint Sensors which are going to be introduced by SecuGen at the CES 2015 just like...

1 day ago, 6:55am CST

Carnival Super Bowl 2015 Ad

Carnival Super Bowl 2015 Ad Carnival Super Bowl 2015 Ad is coming. The cruise line is a newcomer to Super Bowl ads.

1 day ago, 6:53am CST

The Golic Holiday Card displays Mike Golic's Kim Kardashian Spoof Photo

The Golic Holiday Card displays Mike Golic's Kim Kardashian Spoof Photo Mike Golic did an elaborated spoof of Kim Kardashian's Paper Magazine cover last month. Now the Golic Family wears...

1 day ago, 6:15am CST

CES 2015: TRX Systems to display NEON 3D Indoor Location and Navigation Mapping

CES 2015: TRX Systems to display NEON 3D Indoor Location and Navigation Mapping TRX is also going to include Crowdsourced Navigation Mapping at the CES 2015. The TRX NEON FeatureSLAM will enable...

1 day ago, 6:10am CST

Hardent bringing top notch tech to CES 2015

Hardent bringing top notch tech to CES 2015 New IP’s to be first of its kind

1 day ago, 5:53am CST

Digital Signage China coming to CES 2015

Digital Signage China coming to CES 2015 Wholesaler coming to Vegas

1 day ago, 5:51am CST

CES 2015 will have a Virtual Rehabilitation Exhibit by CSNE

CES 2015 will have a Virtual Rehabilitation Exhibit by CSNE At CES 2015, Center for Sensorimotor Neural Engineering (CSNE) is going to unveil their new virtual rehabilitation...

1 day ago, 5:37am CST

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus