Menu
Trending: Holiday Gifts | CES 2015 | Super Bowl 2015 Ads More Topics: Apple | Cars | TV Shows | Politics
Star Wars Christmas Lights Video Goes Viral

Star Wars Christmas Lights Video Goes Viral

CES 2015: LG will unveil its New 4K Ultra HD TV with Quantum Dot Technology

CES 2015: LG will unveil its New 4K Ultra HD TV with Quantum Dot Technology

Budweiser Super Bowl 2015 Ad leaks

Budweiser Super Bowl 2015 Ad leaks

The Best 2014 Super Bowl Ads

The Best 2014 Super Bowl Ads

Tesla Roadster Makes Comeback

Tesla Roadster Makes Comeback

Android Tablet Ads VS. iPad Ads: A Dissection

Apr 11 2011, 5:04pm CDT | by , in News | Tablets

Android Tablet Ads VS. iPad Ads: A Dissection
 
Buy iPad from Amazon Cyber Monday and Black Friday Now
 

Guess who keeps doing it wrong.

Earlier today I touched on something in my coverage of Gartner's latest tablet predictions. There's a major difference between the way Apple markets the iPad, and the way Android tablet-makers market their products. Let's take a look...

The original iPad commercial opens with this:

A plain, white screen with big friendly letters that set up what you're about to see: an assortment of applications juxtaposed with their real-world uses. At all times, the focus is on what the tablet is doing. One picture, followed by a one-word description. As effective as it was, the ad could have easily been designed by someone using a $500 laptop and pirated video editing software. It is simple.

Now, let's look at the Samsung Galaxy Tab's first TV spot. It opens with this:

No focus on the product, no focus on the brand. Just a big glass building with some hip suit-wearing dude walking out. Samsung's ad starts off-message, establishing the atmosphere before they show us the product. This is a critical flaw that we'll see just a little bit later with Motorola's ad. To its credit, the Galaxy Tab ad gets better from that opening.

We quickly move to the Galaxy Pad in use. Here Samsung's focus is flawless. They keep the product center-stage for the rest of the commercial, and do an admirable job of showcasing its uses. But the voiceover is still a problem here. Too many words, and it makes the add far too reliant on volume. Millions of us keep the TV muted when commercials are on. Half of us probably skip ahead on the DVR. Apple's ads work as well on mute as they do with sound.

Speaking of Apple, let's move on to the second iPad 2 commercial. Here's how it opens:

An iPad 2 'waking up' in a dark room, its black bezel faded almost entirely into the surrounding environment. This will be a theme for the remainder of the commercial. The visual emphasis is always on how unobtrusive the iPad 2 is.

The actual tablet itself disappears into the background in every shot. The focus almost always rests on what the iPad 2 can do, and how elegantly it does it. There's a voice-over on this one, but you don't need it to pick up on any key point. By the time Apple's voice actor says, "When technology gets out of the way...everything becomes more delightful" your brain has already picked up on that fact. This whole commercial is about form getting out of function's way.

Now we move on to the first Motorola Xoom commercial.

Once again, we open on some meathead in fancy clothing- this time a square jawed protagonist in a slick jacket. And Johnny Rico here isn't even walking towards a Xoom tablet. He looks like he's approaching an Obelisk of Light. Do they have a lot of Nod activity, out there on the docks?

The Xoom flickers briefly into view atop the obelisk, before the perspective switches and we get our first actual look at the product.

But we're immediately pulled away from the tablet as some giant spaceship thing roars out of it and envelops Captain Shoulders. At no point does the commercial touch on real-life uses of this tablet. Focusing entirely on the Xoom as a gaming device is a bad idea, and focusing on only one game is just preposterous. People won't spend $800 on Wing Commander Tablet.

Now, we move to the last commercial in our tableau of failure. Motorola's ludicrously expensive Super Bowl commercial. It's worth noting that, with roughly 100,000 Xoom sales, Moto may have spent more on this ad than they'll ever make in profit from the tablet. Here's how this boondoggle opens:

Alright, it's a Super Bowl ad. High concept is expected. Motorola gets a pass on that. And hearkening back to Apple's famous 1984 commercial was clever, ballsy. So far we're doing alright. But then this happens:

Another male model, this one cut from a Pattisonian mould. By now you've probably noticed something interesting. iPad ads never focus on a person. The most we ever see are hands. Every single Android tablet ad starts out focused on a young, male "Protagonist". We always see Him before we see the product.

The fact that the first two Android tablets produced by major manufacturers have both failed isn't coincidental. From the start, Apple's would-be rivals made almost every mistake possible in marketing their products. They've shown us giant spaceships and bus stations full of robe-wearing cultists, but they haven't shown us a good reason to drop serious cash on an Android tablet. Samsung was closer to the mark than Motorola- and I have high hopes for the Galaxy Tab's ad campaign- but so far Apple's rivals have been about as off-message as possible. At this point, I can see Apple dominating the market for another four years. No one is exactly rushing up to take it from them.

You Might Also Like

Read the Latest

Tesla Roadster 3.0 Revealed

Tesla Roadster 3.0 Revealed Elon Musk and Tesla Motors have revealed the details about the new Tesla Roadster 3.0.

22 minutes ago

Xiaomi Reportedly Revealing the New Mi5 Smartphone with Sapphire Display at CES

Xiaomi Reportedly Revealing the New Mi5 Smartphone with Sapphire Display at CES 2015 The new flagship smartphone of the Chinese electronics giant will contain the sapphire screen

1 hour ago

CES 2015 News
Intelligraphics, Inc. to show Chiltepin in Vegas

Intelligraphics, Inc. to show Chiltepin in Vegas New driver graphics core to be at CES 2015

4 hours ago

New 3-D mapping tech to be featured at CES 2015

New 3-D mapping tech to be featured at CES 2015 TRX Systems will show NEON FeatureSLAM

4 hours ago

Caseco bringing smart hats to CES 2015

Caseco bringing smart hats to CES 2015 Blu-Toque winter hats have built in BluTooth tech

4 hours ago

MacKeeper coming to CES 2015

MacKeeper coming to CES 2015 New MacKeeper 3.x to be main attraction

4 hours ago

The Interview goes Viral Worlwide via Torrent Downloads

The Interview goes Viral Worlwide via Torrent Downloads Sony Pictures were looking hard for a way to distribute the movie when BitTorrent offered to put the movie in Torrent...

1 day ago, 8:10am CST

BMW will unveil 6 Series and M6 Coupe, Gran Coupe and Convertible Models at the NAIAS 2015 in Detroit

BMW will unveil 6 Series and M6 Coupe, Gran Coupe and Convertible Models at the NAIAS 2015 in Detroit At the Detroit Auto Show 2015, BMW will present the new models including BMW 6 Series Convertible, BMW 6 Series Coupe,...

1 day ago, 7:32am CST

After Christmas Sales 2014 have some Really Cool Stuff for Everyone

After Christmas Sales 2014 have some Really Cool Stuff for Everyone The after Christmas sales 2014 have some really funky and cool stuff for nearly everyone. There are gadgets and...

1 day ago, 7:03am CST

Jennifer Lawrence Kids Hospital Christmas Visit Photos go Viral

Jennifer Lawrence Kids Hospital Christmas Visit Photos go Viral The Hunger Games star visited the kids hospital in her hometown Louisville, Kentucky on Christmas Eve. She also visited...

1 day ago, 6:13am CST

Sony Xperia Z4 to Launch at CES 2015

Sony Xperia Z4 to Launch at CES 2015 Sony Xperia Z4 Ultra may see the light soon at the CES 2015 after the new leaked information.

1 day ago, 5:24am CST

Nadine Leopold Instagram Hottest Pictures

Nadine Leopold Instagram Hottest Pics Victoria’s Secret supermodel, Nadine Leopold and Harry Styles may be much more than just good friends. She may be his...

1 day ago, 5:21am CST

Kodak debuts its First Range of Android-powered Mobile Devices at CES 2015

Kodak debuts its First Range of Android-powered Mobile Devices at CES 2015 Kodak partners with Bullitt Group to launch a new range of Android powered mobile devices at CES 2015.

1 day ago, 4:36am CST

Mozilla and KDDI debut Fx0, First Firefox OS Smartphone with 4G LTE and NFC

Mozilla and KDDI debut Fx0, First Firefox OS Smartphone with 4G LTE and NFC The services, Mozilla and KDDI, have introduced first Firefox OS smartphone 'Fx0', based on Web technology...

1 day ago, 4:21am CST

Marshawn Lynch Touchdown Fine is $11,050

Marshawn Lynch Touchdown Fine is $11,050 Marshawn Lynch was awarded an $11,050 touchdown fine for bad behavior (one of the most ridiculous 79-yard runs) on the...

1 day ago, 3:41am CST

Elon Musk says new Tesla Roadster has almost 400 mile Range

Elon Musk says new Tesla Roadster has almost 400 mile Range Elon Musk tweeted that the new Tesla Roadster has almost a 400 mile range. More details of the new Tesla Roadster are...

1 day ago, 3:32am CST

CES 2015 gets Highest Honors for Creative Campaigns

CES 2015 gets Highest Honors for Creative Campaigns Tradeshow, MarCom and Visual Arts Professionals have recognized CES’s superb advertising and marketing campaigns. The...

1 day ago, 3:29am CST

Xbox and PlayStation Networks hacked by Lizard Squad on Christmas

Xbox and PlayStation Networks hacked by Lizard Squad on Christmas The Xbox and Playstation online services have unfortunately been hacked and disabled by a group of no-gooders known as...

1 day ago, 2:19am CST

Facebook launches FaceTube to compete YouTube

Facebook launches FaceTube to compete YouTube It has established that all businesses on Facebook will be offered a featured video strip with the latest videos...

1 day ago, 12:28pm CST

LG makes 4 additions to wireless speakers range for CES

LG makes 4 additions to wireless speakers range for CES The new additions include a battery-powered portable wireless speaker, two sound bars and a streaming 3D Blu-ray Player

1 day ago, 12:26pm CST

First Shelby GT 350 Mustang to be Barrett-Jackson's Scottsdale sale

First Shelby GT 350 Mustang to be Barrett-Jackson's Scottsdale sale The proceeds of the sale are going to be donated to the Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation (JDRF)

1 day ago, 11:54am CST

LG Exec Could Be Banned From CES For Sabotaging a Washing Machine

LG Exec Could Be Banned From CES For Sabotaging a Washing Machine Samsung filed a lawsuit for property damage and defamation against five LG execs back in September

2 days ago, 9:57am CST

Madonna Tracks Leak Online Again from Rebel Heart

14 More Madonna Tracks Leak Madonna’s new album Rebel Hearts has already been hacked once before. Five of the tracks were officially released on...

2 days ago, 8:38am CST

MINI John Cooper Works Hardtop to be displayed at the NAIAS Detroit 2015

MINI John Cooper Works Hardtop to be displayed at the NAIAS Detroit 2015 BMW’s famous mini cooper’s new design will be displayed at the NAIAS 2015 in Detroit.

2 days ago, 8:18am CST

Sarah Palin Channel Wardrobe Controversy Video was a Publicity Stunt?

Sarah Palin Channel Wardrobe Controversy Video was a Publicity Stunt? Most people are talking about the one term governor’s show of skin on live channel. Sarah Palin ran for the Vice...

2 days ago, 7:54am CST

Patchworks to represent North and South America at CES 2015

Patchworks to represent North and South America at CES 2015 Patchworks Global Inc. make flawlessly engineered products for iPhone Screen Protection that it will display at the CES...

2 days ago, 7:47am CST

How to Watch The Interview Online Right Now

How to Watch The Interview Online Right Now Sony Pictures announce the online release of ‘The Interview’ with the help of online sources. Google, Microsoft and...

2 days ago, 7:05am CST

Luxoft Software Development Services will also participate in CES 2015 and CTS 2015

Luxoft Software Development Services will also participate in CES 2015 and CTS 2015 It seems everyone is eager to take part in the CES 2015.

2 days ago, 6:13am CST

Peyton Manning to Return to Broncos in 2015

Peyton Manning to Return to Broncos in 2015 The player, Peyton Manning, is planning to return to Denver Broncos next year since he has no plans to leave the field...

2 days ago, 6:08am CST

First Alert also to take on the Polar Vortex at CES 2015

First Alert also to take on the Polar Vortex at CES 2015 The new Onelink Series by First Alert introduces many new products which will be displayed at the CES 2015. New Onelink...

2 days ago, 5:20am CST

Uber CEO Charged with Illegitimate Business Practice in South Korea

Uber CEO Charged with Illegitimate Business Practice in South Korea The CEO of taxi service Uber has been charged with illegitimate business practice in South Korea.

2 days ago, 5:15am CST

NBA pulls Sorority Sisters Advertising

NBA pulls Sorority Sisters Advertising NBA has announced Wednesday to pull all advertising from VH1's Sorority Sisters show.

2 days ago, 4:33am CST

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus