Menu
Trending: Super Bowl 2015 Ads for Geeks More Topics: Apple | Cars | TV Shows | Politics
Watch all Super Bowl 2015 Ads Online Sexiest Super Bowl 2015 Ad: Carl's Jr. Superbowl Ad with Charlotte McKinney Bud Light Super Bowl 2015 Ad Life-Sized PacMan Mercedes-Benz Super Bowl 2015 Ad Fable T-Mobile Super Bowl 2015 Ad with Kim Kardashian Budweiser Super Bowl 2015 Ad Lost Dog Victoria's Secret Super Bowl 2015 Ad All Super Bowl 2015 Advertisers All Celebrities that appear in Super Bowl 2015 Commercials
Budweiser Super Bowl 2015 Ad Lost Dog is Online

Budweiser Super Bowl 2015 Ad Lost Dog is Online

Snickers Super Bowl 2015 Ad The Brady Bunch is Hysterical

Snickers Super Bowl 2015 Ad The Brady Bunch is Hysterical

Carl's Jr. Super Bowl 2015 Ad stars Charlotte McKinney

Carl's Jr. Super Bowl 2015 Ad stars Charlotte McKinney

Minions Super Bowl 2015 Ad

Minions Super Bowl 2015 Ad

Game of War Super Bowl 2015 Ad stars Kate Upton

Game of War Super Bowl 2015 Ad stars Kate Upton

Android Tablet Ads VS. iPad Ads: A Dissection

Apr 11 2011, 5:04pm CDT | by , in News | Tablets

Android Tablet Ads VS. iPad Ads: A Dissection
 
Buy iPad from Amazon Cyber Monday and Black Friday Now
 

Guess who keeps doing it wrong.

Earlier today I touched on something in my coverage of Gartner's latest tablet predictions. There's a major difference between the way Apple markets the iPad, and the way Android tablet-makers market their products. Let's take a look...

The original iPad commercial opens with this:

A plain, white screen with big friendly letters that set up what you're about to see: an assortment of applications juxtaposed with their real-world uses. At all times, the focus is on what the tablet is doing. One picture, followed by a one-word description. As effective as it was, the ad could have easily been designed by someone using a $500 laptop and pirated video editing software. It is simple.

Now, let's look at the Samsung Galaxy Tab's first TV spot. It opens with this:

No focus on the product, no focus on the brand. Just a big glass building with some hip suit-wearing dude walking out. Samsung's ad starts off-message, establishing the atmosphere before they show us the product. This is a critical flaw that we'll see just a little bit later with Motorola's ad. To its credit, the Galaxy Tab ad gets better from that opening.

We quickly move to the Galaxy Pad in use. Here Samsung's focus is flawless. They keep the product center-stage for the rest of the commercial, and do an admirable job of showcasing its uses. But the voiceover is still a problem here. Too many words, and it makes the add far too reliant on volume. Millions of us keep the TV muted when commercials are on. Half of us probably skip ahead on the DVR. Apple's ads work as well on mute as they do with sound.

Speaking of Apple, let's move on to the second iPad 2 commercial. Here's how it opens:

An iPad 2 'waking up' in a dark room, its black bezel faded almost entirely into the surrounding environment. This will be a theme for the remainder of the commercial. The visual emphasis is always on how unobtrusive the iPad 2 is.

The actual tablet itself disappears into the background in every shot. The focus almost always rests on what the iPad 2 can do, and how elegantly it does it. There's a voice-over on this one, but you don't need it to pick up on any key point. By the time Apple's voice actor says, "When technology gets out of the way...everything becomes more delightful" your brain has already picked up on that fact. This whole commercial is about form getting out of function's way.

Now we move on to the first Motorola Xoom commercial.

Once again, we open on some meathead in fancy clothing- this time a square jawed protagonist in a slick jacket. And Johnny Rico here isn't even walking towards a Xoom tablet. He looks like he's approaching an Obelisk of Light. Do they have a lot of Nod activity, out there on the docks?

The Xoom flickers briefly into view atop the obelisk, before the perspective switches and we get our first actual look at the product.

But we're immediately pulled away from the tablet as some giant spaceship thing roars out of it and envelops Captain Shoulders. At no point does the commercial touch on real-life uses of this tablet. Focusing entirely on the Xoom as a gaming device is a bad idea, and focusing on only one game is just preposterous. People won't spend $800 on Wing Commander Tablet.

Now, we move to the last commercial in our tableau of failure. Motorola's ludicrously expensive Super Bowl commercial. It's worth noting that, with roughly 100,000 Xoom sales, Moto may have spent more on this ad than they'll ever make in profit from the tablet. Here's how this boondoggle opens:

Alright, it's a Super Bowl ad. High concept is expected. Motorola gets a pass on that. And hearkening back to Apple's famous 1984 commercial was clever, ballsy. So far we're doing alright. But then this happens:

Another male model, this one cut from a Pattisonian mould. By now you've probably noticed something interesting. iPad ads never focus on a person. The most we ever see are hands. Every single Android tablet ad starts out focused on a young, male "Protagonist". We always see Him before we see the product.

The fact that the first two Android tablets produced by major manufacturers have both failed isn't coincidental. From the start, Apple's would-be rivals made almost every mistake possible in marketing their products. They've shown us giant spaceships and bus stations full of robe-wearing cultists, but they haven't shown us a good reason to drop serious cash on an Android tablet. Samsung was closer to the mark than Motorola- and I have high hopes for the Galaxy Tab's ad campaign- but so far Apple's rivals have been about as off-message as possible. At this point, I can see Apple dominating the market for another four years. No one is exactly rushing up to take it from them.

Watch the Best Super Bowl 2015 Ads Online

You Might Also Like

Read the Latest

It's A Baby!: Justin Timberlake Confirms Jessica Biel Pregnancy on Instagram

It's A Baby!: Justin Timberlake Confirms Jessica Biel Pregnancy on Instagram Justin Timberlake celebrated his birthday by showing the world a picture of pregnant wife's belly.

1 hour ago

Game of War Super Bowl 2015 Ad stars Kate Upton

Game of War Super Bowl 2015 Ad stars Kate Upton Kate Upton is not leaving the Super Bowl 2015 to "new Kate Upton" Charlotte McKinney. We just found out that...

7 hours ago, 3:28pm CST

The Best Super Bowl 2015 Ads
Republican Representatives Call For Food Stamp Purchase Transparency

Republican Representatives Call For Food Stamp Purchase Transparency Currently, almost 47 million people receive food stamp, or Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), in the U.S...

7 hours ago, 3:24pm CST

Watch the Super Bowl 2015 Ads Online

Watch the Super Bowl 2015 Ads Online About half of the Super Bowl 2015 Ads have been released online ahead of the Super Bowl 2015 broadcast. Watch all...

7 hours ago, 2:50pm CST

Fast & Furious-Supercharged Super Bowl 2015 Ad

Fast & Furious-Supercharged Super Bowl 2015 Ad Universal Studios Hollywood will run a Fast & Furious Supercharged Super Bowl 2015 Ad in the Pre-game coverage on...

8 hours ago, 2:01pm CST

Cord Cutter can Watch Super Bowl 2015 Online for Free

Cord Cutter can Watch Super Bowl 2015 Online for Free Thanks to NBC's Super Stream Sunday, Cord Cutters can watch the Super Bowl 2015 broadcast for free online.

10 hours ago, 12:14pm CST

Doritos Super Bowl 2015 Ad Finalist Voting is Closed

Doritos Super Bowl 2015 Ad Finalist Voting is Closed The voting for the 10 Doritos Super Bowl 2015 ad finalists has closed. You can watch all 10 entries, but we will have...

11 hours ago, 11:24am CST

Most Popular Super Bowl 2015 Ads Online ahead of the Big Game

Most Popular Super Bowl 2015 Ads Online ahead of the Big Game The race between Super Bowl ads to catch the most eyeballs ahead of the Big Game on Sunday is going into the final...

12 hours ago, 9:42am CST

Charlotte McKinney Burns Up a Super Bowl 2015 Party

Charlotte McKinney Burns Up a Super Bowl 2015 Party Charlotte McKinney is stars in the sexiest Super Bowl 2015 Ad and she is also a stunner in real life. See the hot...

13 hours ago, 9:07am CST

Discover Super Bowl 2015 Ad

Discover Super Bowl 2015 Ad Discover Card is coming back to to Super Bowl after almost a 30-year break. Watch the weird teasers for the Discover...

14 hours ago, 8:13am CST

Mtn Dew Kickstart Super Bowl 2015 Ad is One Big Twerk

Mtn Dew Kickstart Super Bowl 2015 Ad is One Big Twerk The Mtn Dew Kickstart Super Bowl 2015 Ad is online as extended version. The funny Mtn Dew Kickstart Super Bowl ad will...

14 hours ago, 7:41am CST

2015 could also see an iPad Pro

2015 could also see an iPad Pro Rumors are lighting up the internet

15 hours ago, 7:33am CST

Apple will dominate Samsung

Apple will dominate Samsung Apple’s record numbers prove just that

15 hours ago, 7:30am CST

Super Bowl Team Coaches Bill Belichic and Pete Carroll can Win a Trip to Croatia

Super Bowl Team Coaches Bill Belichic and Pete Carroll can Win a Trip to Croatia Bill Belichic and Pete Carroll can not just win the Vince Lombardi Trophy on Sunday, but also a trip to Croatia.

16 hours ago, 6:07am CST

12.5 million Pizza Orders expected for Super Bowl 2015

12.5 million Pizza Orders expected for Super Bowl 2015 Americans will order 12.5 million Pizzas on Super Bowl Sunday.

16 hours ago, 5:44am CST

Super Bowl Playboy Party: See the Hot Photos

Super Bowl Playboy Party: See the Hot Photos The Super Bowl Playboy Party at the W Hotel in Scottsdale took place last night. We got the hot photos including lots...

17 hours ago, 5:20am CST

1.25 Billion Chicken Wings will be Eaten for Super Bowl

1.25 Billion Chicken Wings will be Eaten for Super Bowl Americans will be eating a unbelievable number of chicken wings on Super Bowl Sunday. 1.25 Billion Chicken Wings will...

17 hours ago, 4:54am CST

Katy Perry talks Super Bowl Halftime Show

Katy Perry talks Super Bowl Halftime Show The Super Bowl 2015 Halftime Show is right around the corner. Katy Perry talks Super Bowl in the Billboard Magazine...

18 hours ago, 4:26am CST

Binge-watch all Three Super Bowl 2015 Puppy Ads

Binge-watch all Three Super Bowl 2015 Puppy Ads There is actually a Puppy Bowl on the Animal Planet, but Super Bowl 2015 commercials make the Big Game a Puppy Bowl.

18 hours ago, 3:49am CST

The Blacklist Super Bowl Trailer

The Blacklist Super Bowl Trailer NBC will air the premiere episode of the new The Blacklist season right after the Super Bowl game. During the Big Game...

19 hours ago, 3:18am CST

Super Bowl Late Night Fun: Matt Damon Claims to be the Locker Room Guy

Super Bowl Late Night Fun: Matt Damon Claims to be the Locker Room Guy The DeflateGate is still a topic ahead of the Super Bowl 49 on Sunday. Late night shows still have a lot of fun with it...

19 hours ago, 3:00am CST

T-Mobile Super Bowl 2015 Ad Data Vulture

T-Mobile Super Bowl 2015 Ad Data Vulture Watch the T-Mobile Super Bowl 2015 Ad Data Vulture below. It will air in the online broadcast of the NBC Super Bowl...

20 hours ago, 2:06am CST

T-Mobile Super Bowl 2015 Ad features Sarah Silverman and Chelsea Handler

T-Mobile Super Bowl 2015 Ad features Sarah Silverman and Chelsea Handler T-Mobile apparently has more than one Super Bowl 2015 Ad coming at you. Besides the Kim Kardashian Super bowl...

20 hours ago, 1:48am CST

NASCAR Super Bowl 2015 Ad will not have Gluten Joke

NASCAR Super Bowl 2015 Ad will not have Gluten Joke Nick Offerman cashes in on his All American persona. He stars in NBC's NASCAR Super Bowl 2015 Ad. The commercial...

21 hours ago, 1:25am CST

Apple reveals Artists behind Jiefangbei Apple Store

Apple reveals Artists behind Jiefangbei Apple Store Apple released a video that features the two artist that created the stunning art covering the new Apple Store in the...

21 hours ago, 12:56am CST

The Best Super Bowl 2015 Ads Released So Far

The Best Super Bowl 2015 Ads Released So Far Over 20 Super Bowl 2015 commercials have been released online ahead of the Big Game. We take a first look and picked...

1 day ago, 2:44pm CST

The Funniest Super Bowl 2015 Ads so Far

The Funniest Super Bowl 2015 Ads so Far Here are the funniest Super Bowl 2015 Ads that have been released online so far.

1 day ago, 2:21pm CST

Sprint Super Bowl 2015 Ad

Sprint Super Bowl 2015 Ad Sprint released a teaser for a Sprint Super Bowl 2015 Ad. Sprint will have a commercial in the third quarter of the...

1 day ago, 1:26pm CST

Coca-Cola Super Bowl 2015 Ad Teaser Campaign features Michael Sam

Coca-Cola Super Bowl 2015 Ad Teaser Campaign features Michael Sam A new Coca-Cola Super Bowl 2015 Ad Teaser features Michael Sam. Watch the video below to hear Michael Sam talk about...

1 day ago, 1:00pm CST

FirstBank Puppy Sale Ad is more Emotional than Budweiser's Puppy Ad

FirstBank Puppy Sale Ad is more Emotional than Budweiser's Puppy Ad Good thing the First Bank Puppy Sale Commercial only airs in Colorado during the Super Bowl pre-game show. This Puppy...

1 day ago, 12:38pm CST

Avocados from Mexico Super Bowl 2015 Ad First Draft Ever Released

Avocados from Mexico Super Bowl 2015 Ad First Draft Ever Released The Avocados from Mexico Super Bowl 2015 Ad features Jerry Rice and Doug Flutie introducing the First Draft Ever. Beach...

1 day ago, 11:45am CST

Lindsay Lohan talks about Esurance Super Bowl 2015 Ad

Lindsay Lohan talks about Esurance Super Bowl 2015 Ad Lindsay Lohan will star in the Esurance Super Bowl 2015 Ad. Watch her talk about the Esurance Super Bowl ad and how it...

1 day ago, 11:29am CST

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus