Menu
Amazon Kindle Voyage Rethinks the Reading Experience

Amazon Kindle Voyage Rethinks the Reading Experience

Mat Franco won America's Got Talent

Mat Franco won America's Got Talent

SpaceX and Boeing build manned NASA Spaceships

SpaceX and Boeing build manned NASA Spaceships

Matt Damon is Jason Bourne Again

Matt Damon is Jason Bourne Again

iPhone 6 Reviews are Glowing

iPhone 6 Reviews are Glowing

Android Tablet Ads VS. iPad Ads: A Dissection

Apr 11 2011, 5:04pm CDT | by , in News | Tablets

Guess who keeps doing it wrong.

Android Tablet Ads VS. iPad Ads: A Dissection
 
Buy iPad from Amazon Cyber Monday and Black Friday Now
 

Earlier today I touched on something in my coverage of Gartner's latest tablet predictions. There's a major difference between the way Apple markets the iPad, and the way Android tablet-makers market their products. Let's take a look...

The original iPad commercial opens with this:

black;" src="http://static_1.i4u.com/sites/default/files/images/content_images/padone.jpg" alt="" width="300" height="156">

A plain, white screen with big friendly letters that set up what you're about to see: an assortment of applications juxtaposed with their real-world uses. At all times, the focus is on what the tablet is doing. One picture, followed by a one-word description. As effective as it was, the ad could have easily been designed by someone using a $500 laptop and pirated video editing software. It is simple.

Now, let's look at the Samsung Galaxy Tab's first TV spot. It opens with this:

No focus on the product, no focus on the brand. Just a big glass building with some hip suit-wearing dude walking out. Samsung's ad starts off-message, establishing the atmosphere before they show us the product. This is a critical flaw that we'll see just a little bit later with Motorola's ad. To its credit, the Galaxy Tab ad gets better from that opening.

We quickly move to the Galaxy Pad in use. Here Samsung's focus is flawless. They keep the product center-stage for the rest of the commercial, and do an admirable job of showcasing its uses. But the voiceover is still a problem here. Too many words, and it makes the add far too reliant on volume. Millions of us keep the TV muted when commercials are on. Half of us probably skip ahead on the DVR. Apple's ads work as well on mute as they do with sound.

Speaking of Apple, let's move on to the second iPad 2 commercial. Here's how it opens:

An iPad 2 'waking up' in a dark room, its black bezel faded almost entirely into the surrounding environment. This will be a theme for the remainder of the commercial. The visual emphasis is always on how unobtrusive the iPad 2 is.

The actual tablet itself disappears into the background in every shot. The focus almost always rests on what the iPad 2 can do, and how elegantly it does it. There's a voice-over on this one, but you don't need it to pick up on any key point. By the time Apple's voice actor says, "When technology gets out of the way...everything becomes more delightful" your brain has already picked up on that fact. This whole commercial is about form getting out of function's way.

Now we move on to the first Motorola Xoom commercial.

Once again, we open on some meathead in fancy clothing- this time a square jawed protagonist in a slick jacket. And Johnny Rico here isn't even walking towards a Xoom tablet. He looks like he's approaching an Obelisk of Light. Do they have a lot of Nod activity, out there on the docks?

The Xoom flickers briefly into view atop the obelisk, before the perspective switches and we get our first actual look at the product.

But we're immediately pulled away from the tablet as some giant spaceship thing roars out of it and envelops Captain Shoulders. At no point does the commercial touch on real-life uses of this tablet. Focusing entirely on the Xoom as a gaming device is a bad idea, and focusing on only one game is just preposterous. People won't spend $800 on Wing Commander Tablet.

Now, we move to the last commercial in our tableau of failure. Motorola's ludicrously expensive Super Bowl commercial. It's worth noting that, with roughly 100,000 Xoom sales, Moto may have spent more on this ad than they'll ever make in profit from the tablet. Here's how this boondoggle opens:

Alright, it's a Super Bowl ad. High concept is expected. Motorola gets a pass on that. And hearkening back to Apple's famous 1984 commercial was clever, ballsy. So far we're doing alright. But then this happens:

Another male model, this one cut from a Pattisonian mould. By now you've probably noticed something interesting. iPad ads never focus on a person. The most we ever see are hands. Every single Android tablet ad starts out focused on a young, male "Protagonist". We always see Him before we see the product.

The fact that the first two Android tablets produced by major manufacturers have both failed isn't coincidental. From the start, Apple's would-be rivals made almost every mistake possible in marketing their products. They've shown us giant spaceships and bus stations full of robe-wearing cultists, but they haven't shown us a good reason to drop serious cash on an Android tablet. Samsung was closer to the mark than Motorola- and I have high hopes for the Galaxy Tab's ad campaign- but so far Apple's rivals have been about as off-message as possible. At this point, I can see Apple dominating the market for another four years. No one is exactly rushing up to take it from them.

You Might Also Like

Updates

Shopping Deals

 
 
 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/5" rel="author">Robert Evans</a>
The excitement about new smartphones, tablets and anything mobile drive Robert to unearth the latest rumors and developments in this fast moving space. He adopted 4G as soon as it become available and knows where the mobile market is going.
Robert can be contacted directly at robert@i4u.com.

 

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Samsung Galaxy S5 Camera fails to beat iPhone 6 Camera
Samsung Galaxy S5 16MP Camera fails to beat iPhone 6 8MP Camera
iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 Plus 8MP cameras show better results than that of the Samsung Galaxy S5 16 MP camera.
 
 
Zombies with Bazookas Game Review
Zombies with Bazookas Game Review
Zombies with Bazookas is a game where gamers can get to rescue the survivors from the zombies using a helicopter. The gamers would face lots of obstacles while doing this. This is a funny game to play and can be played for a pass time. The game would not cause extra pressure in the minds of the gamers and the gamers would feel quite relaxed while playing the game.
 
 
See Jessica Biel in 7th Heaven Reunion
See Jessica Biel in 7th Heaven Reunion
The 7th Heaven cast got together for a family style dinner. See the fun photo below.
 
 
Ghost Ship salvaged from the vicinity of Golden Gate Bridge
Ghost Ship salvaged from the vicinity of Golden Gate Bridge
There have been many ghost ships salvaged from the vicinity of Golden Gate Bridge.
 
 
 

About the Geek Mind

The “geek mind” is concerned with more than just the latest iPhone rumors, or which company will win the gaming console wars. I4U is concerned with more than just the latest photo shoot or other celebrity gossip.

The “geek mind” is concerned with life, in all its different forms and facets. The geek mind wants to know about societal and financial issues, both abroad and at home. If a Fortune 500 decides to raise their minimum wage, or any high priority news, the geek mind wants to know. The geek mind wants to know the top teams in the National Football League, or who’s likely to win the NBA Finals this coming year. The geek mind wants to know who the hottest new models are, or whether the newest blockbuster movie is worth seeing. The geek mind wants to know. The geek mind wants—needs—knowledge.

Read more about The Geek Mind.