Menu
Jeff Goldblum Stars in funny GE Link Ad

Jeff Goldblum Stars in funny GE Link Ad

iPhone 6c is possible as iPhone 5c Sales Surge

iPhone 6c is possible as iPhone 5c Sales Surge

Pee-Wee Herman stars in New TV on the Radio Video

Pee-Wee Herman stars in New TV on the Radio Video

Windows 10 Preview Download Release is Today

Windows 10 Preview Download Release is Today

William Shatner and Leonard Nemoy to Star in New Volkswagen e-Golf Commercial

William Shatner and Leonard Nemoy to Star in New Volkswagen e-Golf Commercial

Microsoft's Xbox One Almost Went Entirely Disc-less After E3

Jan 3 2014, 9:16am CST | by , in News

Microsoft's Xbox One Almost Went Entirely Disc-less After E3
Photo Credit: Forbes
 
 
Full Story

Microsoft's Xbox One Almost Went Entirely Disc-less After E3

Microsoft was scrambling in the wake of E3 to alter the Xbox One after a wave of negative feedback about the company’s policies regarding the system. According to a new OXM interview with Microsoft Studios general manager Phil Spencer, one radical idea was seriously considered.

“Obviously, after the announcement and E3, there was some feedback about what people wanted to change. There was a real discussion about whether we should have an optical disc drive in Xbox One or if we could get away with a purely disc-less console, but when you start looking at bandwidth and game size, it does create issues.”

It seems odd that it was after the E3 controversy that a disc-less console was being considered. That essentially would have meant Microsoft would have been going all-in on the very policies people were so upset about. A disc-free console would have made sense as with “always on” DRM and activation codes, discs were essentially worthless under the original system.

Eventually, Spencer and the Microsoft team decided against the idea, for seemingly obvious reasons:

“We decided – which I think was the right decision – to go with the Blu-ray drive and give the people an easy way to install a lot of content. From some of those original thoughts, you saw a lot of us really focusing on the digital ecosystem you see on other devices – thinking of and building around that.”

I can understand the base desire to make the Xbox One a disc-less console. There’s something futuristic about the idea, and its undoubtedly where media is heading, someday. Despite the public outcry about the loss of used games, it could have really differentiated the system from its competition if they had an effective, easy way to download games straight to the console. They could have made the PS4 and Wii U feel old-fashioned after a time, and people adjusted to sitting on their couch downloading games rather than driving to the store for them.

That said, though I do believe this is the future of gaming, admittedly it’s something of a distant future at this point.

Spencer is right when he talks about the limitations of bandwidth and game size. Estimations put the capability of a 500 GB hard drive at about 10-12 games stored. Probably less, if you factor in how much of that 500GB is “usable.” While that’s enough for this initially launch window, or the next year or two for many gamers, that’s going to fill up quickly, especially if you add in DLC and the like.

The larger problem is the internet, especially in places like the US which are struggling to give its population the fast broadband speeds of more plugged in nations like South Korea. We’ve already seen issues with this crop up, like GTA V’s digital launch which resulted in stalled or incomplete downloads of the massive game. And “massive” in this case was only 18 GB. What happens when the file size is 30, 40 or 50 GB?

Our internet (and to be honest, the servers of most game publishers) aren’t at the point yet where a disc-less, download-only console is viable. While it may be fine for Steam, I can’t see that success translating into the console realm at this point. The technology just isn’t there to make such a service reliable. Had Microsoft gone down that path with the Xbox One, in addition to the backlash they would have faced from consumers, it’s entirely possible a mad rush to download any of their launch games or widely anticipated future titles would have led to bandwidth or server-based disaster.

It’s hard to believe that Microsoft was even considering going completely disc-less, given the infrastructure required to make such a thing work seamlessly. And it seems like an incredibly last-minute decision if it was being made after E3, less than half a year before launch.

The public wasn’t ready for a disc-less console, and neither were the hard drives of either system, nor the ISPs who can barely handle Netflix HD streaming as is. We’ll get there someday, but now that all three next-gen consoles are committed to physical discs, it’s going to be a while.

Follow me on Twittersubscribe to my Forbes feed, and pick up a copy of my sci-fi novel, The Last Exodus, and its sequel, The Exiled Earthborn.

Source: Forbes

Updates

Shopping Deals

 
 
 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/31" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Steve Smith on Release From Carolina Panthers: 'It Was Personal'
Steve Smith on Release From Carolina Panthers: 'It Was Personal'
Baltimore Ravens wide receiver Steve Smith opened up about his release from the Carolina Panthers on Charlotte radio station WFNZ on Oct. 1. Smith said, "It was personal" and felt he "was stabbed in the back."
 
 
Jay Z Profiled
Jay Z Profiled
Luckier than the Luckiest Chap on Earth!
 
 
Microsoft teases Windows 10 phone and Xbox interfaces
Microsoft teases Windows 10 phone and Xbox interfaces
Some subtle changes can be seen in the updated interface
 
 
Isla Fisher Pregnant with Third Child with Sacha Baron Cohen
Isla Fisher Pregnant with Third Child with Sacha Baron Cohen
It is a big 24 hours for Celebrity pregnancy news. Now news break that Isla Fisher is pregnant.