Latest News: Technology |  Celebrity |  Movies |  Apple |  Cars |  Business |  Sports |  TV Shows |  Geek


Filed under: News


Product Report Card: Is It Fair To Grade Apple B- For 2013?

Jan 4 2014, 10:06am CST | by

10 Updates
Product Report Card: Is It Fair To Grade Apple B- For 2013?
Photo Credit: Forbes


Full Story

Product Report Card: Is It Fair To Grade Apple B- For 2013?

We expect a lot from our tech companies, both in terms of the products they release to consumers and the gains they return to investors. And just like high school, the expectations are highest for the head of the class. That spot, of course, has gone to Apple for many years. As we enter a new year, it’s time to ask how our prize pupil did in 2013 and whether it will retain its rank in 2014.

The markets may already be speaking. As Forbes contributor title="chuck jones on apple downgrade">Chuck Jones reported, “Wells Fargo’s Apple analyst Maynard Um downgraded Apple from Outperform to Market Perform on Monday while maintaining his $536 to $581 target price range.” Apple stock has fallen $20 this week to end near the bottom of Um’s range at $540.98.

If you follow Horace Dediu’s logic that “The diffusion of iPhones is a Learning Process ,” and that Apple has succeeded at directly transferring the consumer’s perceived value of the smartphone to its smartphone, the quality of all of Apple’s product offerings should have an immediate relation to its value. In light of this logic I was intrigued to see a post by long-time Apple product reviewer John Siracusa on his Hypercritical  blog that grades the company’s efforts in 2013. Siracusa certainly has his Apple bonafides. He has reviewed every major release of OS X for Ars Technica since 1999.

Siracusa gave grades in response to his post from last February, Apple’s 2013 To-Do List , where he details, “things I think Apple can and should do this year.”  When I tallied up the grades using a standard grading scale , I got a B–. Siracusa ends his assessment with the generous kicker, “I’d call that a solid year.”

Maybe I am suffering from a parental sense of grade inflation, but if my star student ended the year with a B– average, I would not call it a “solid year!” A look at the specific grades gives a good sense of what brought down Cupertino’s GPA in 2013.

Siracusa gave his highest grade (an A) for Apple’s efforts to “Reassure Mac Pro lovers.” He also gave A– for its delivery of iOS 7 and OS X 10.9, “with only a few minor bumps in the road,” and for keeping the iPad “on track.” The more important goal of “diversify the iPhone product line” earned a B+ with Siracusa affirming that, “The 5C is a good phone, and it’s easily distinguished from the 5S.”

The products that got Siracusa’ “solid” score of B– are the Retina Macs and the revival of iLife and iWork. Things start going south with the failure of iCloud to “just work” (C) and the “failure to make Messages work” without lots of bugs between iOS 7 and OS X Mavericks (D). The real downer, for Siracusa is Apple’s inability to “Do something about TV,” which earned a single word comment, “Sigh,” and an F.

Siracusa freely admits that, “The TV thing was always a bit of a reach, anyway,” so his assessment of solidity may have been discounting that grade. Indeed, if you throw out the lowest grade (as teachers sometimes do) Apple would get a slightly more respectable B, but that still seems to me an underperformance. I even went the extra mile and weighted these grades based on the share of Apple’s revenues that each of the products represent (iPhone revenues, for instance, are 3.6 times greater than Mac revenues) and I still only edged up to a B+.

So a critical assessments of Apple’s actual product performance in 2013 aligns quite well with the market assessment of the company. It is tracking the market not surpassing it. And, based on his analysis of P/E ratios, Dediu concludes that “the market suggests that Apple has 7 more years of current profitability and not 13.” Does this mean that Apple is losing its prized perch in the tech “class”? Not necessarily, but it does suggest that Apple needs to have a big year and open some new categories like connected car, wearables and, yes, a bigger move on TV, to avoid being unseated.

RFC (Request for Comments!): What grade would you give Apple for 2013?

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

To keep up with Quantum of Content , please subscribe to my updates on Facebook , follow me on Twitter  and  or add me on Google+ .

Source: Forbes


iPad Air Giveaway. Win a free iPad Air.

You Might Also Like


Sponsored Update

Update: 10

4 Firms In Iskandar Malaysia Get Facilitation Fund Totalling RM16.2 Million

Source: Malaysia Today

(Bernama) – Four companies have received the facilitation fund amounting to RM16.2 million from TERAJU@Iskandar Malaysia in an information sharing programme on business opportunities and a ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today 1 day ago, 7:42am CDT


Update: 9

Selangor’s Watergate about to explode

Source: Malaysia Today

Anwar brought Wan Azmi to meet Khalid to try to resolve this matter. Anwar supports the RM2.5 billion claim but Khalid is stubbornly sticking to the figure of RM250 m ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today 2 days ago, 4:12am CDT

More From the Web

Update: 8

GLCs told to provide RM7 billion to develop Bumiputera firms

Source: Malaysia Today

(The Malaysian Insider) – Putrajaya has directed government-linked companies (GLC) to generate RM7 billion in business opportunities for Bumiputera firms this year, Prime Minister Prime ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today Jul 17 2014, 2:05am CDT

Update: 7

Rafizi shows proof of Putrajaya’s hand in contentious carpet-trader loan

Source: Malaysia Today

Eileen Ng, The Malaysian Insider PKR lawmaker Rafizi Ramli today revealed documents to prove Putrajaya interfered in the RM32 million Bank Rakyat loan to ‎controversial businessman Deepak ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today Jul 16 2014, 2:16am CDT

Update: 6

PAS MP claims Bank Rakyat loaned carpet-trader RM215m, interest free

Source: Malaysia Today

(Malay Mail Online) – Controversial businessman Deepak Jaikishan (pic) was given a whopping RM215 million interest-free loan from state-owned Bank Rakyat, a PAS lawmaker alleged today, despite Putrajaya’s claims otherwise.... ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today Jul 14 2014, 5:52am CDT

Update: 5

MRCB, Nusa Gapurna and PKNS settle suit over RM3 billion PJ Sentral project

Source: Malaysia Today

(The Malaysian Insider) – Malaysian Resources Corp Bhd (MRCB), Nusa Gapurna Development Sdn Bhd (NGD) and PKNS Holdings Sdn Bhd have reached an out-of-court settlement over the ownership of the... READ M ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today Jun 21 2014, 2:53am CDT

Update: 4

Story behind Syed Mokhtar’s ‘RM2.25 billion tax-exempt’ Bernas deal revealed, says PKR MP

Source: Malaysia Today

(The Malaysian Insider) – An innocuous written reply in Parliament has provided a peek into the cosy relationship between the Najib administration and Malaysia’s best-known businessman, Tan Sri Syed Mokhtar... ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today Jun 15 2014, 12:56pm CDT

Update: 3

Constitutional monarchy still murky concept

Source: Malaysia Today

After the RM4.5 billion land sale, the Sultan of Johor secured a 15% stake in MOL Access Portal (MOL) for RM396 million and took a 20% stake in Berjaya Times... READ M ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today Jun 14 2014, 12:37am CDT

Update: 2

Sultan of Johor’s RM4.5 bil backlash?

Source: Malaysia Today

Has Sultan Ibrahim of Johor’s succession of big money deals over the last six months caused the tide of public opinion to turn against Johor’s royal palace? KiniBiz examines the... READ M ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today Jun 11 2014, 8:49am CDT

Update: 1

Putrajaya denies carpet dealer given interest-free loan

Source: Malaysia Today

Eileen Ng, The Malaysian Insider Putrajaya today refuted allegations that Bank Rakyat had allowed carpet dealer Deepak Jaikishan to repay a RM32 million loan without interest following intervention from a... READ ...
Source: Malaysia Today   Full article at: Malaysia Today Jun 11 2014, 5:44am CDT

Shopping Deals


<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/31" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.




blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

OS X Yosemite planned for late October
OS X Yosemite planned for late October
Apple is also working on a new MacBook will include a Retina Display that is approximately 12-inches diagonally
North West Baby Picture Marks a Milestone
North West Baby Picture Marks a Milestone
Kim Kardashian and Kanye West must be very happy to see their daughter North West walking. Kanye took a picture of his baby North West's first step that Kim posted on her Instagram later on.
Jennifer Lopez celebrates her Birthday with Style
Jennifer Lopez Celebrates her Birthday with Style
The songstress and actress, Jennifer Lopez celebrated her 45th birthday with style.
Cara Delevingne is in Search of a New Home
Cara Delevingne is in Search of a New Home
Cara Delevingne's parents have asked her to move out of their home. So she has to search for a new home.

About the Geek Mind

Read more about The Geek Mind.