Latest News: Technology |  Celebrity |  Movies |  Apple |  Cars |  Business |  Sports |  TV Shows |  Geek


Filed under: News


Best Buy is a Dinosaur and Canary

Jan 24 2014, 8:00am CST | by

12 Updates
Best Buy is a Dinosaur and Canary

YouTube Videos Tweets Comments

Recommend Your Tweet as Top Tweet:

Full Story

Best Buy is a Dinosaur and Canary

You might be tempted to lump recent news about Best Buy’s disappointing holiday performance into the long-running narrative about that retail giant’s slow slide toward irrelevance and extinction. Don’t. Or, at least, don’t stop there. There’s more to the story. And it makes the story even uglier—not only for Best Buy.

Yes, Best Buy is a dinosaur. But it is also a canary. The cause of its bleak quarter is an early warning for Apple, Samsung and others that hope to continue extracting riches from smartphones. It also signals strategic opportunities for Google, Microsoft, Amazon and others.


Best Buy is being slowly and perhaps inexorably Amazoned . The fact that Best Buy has survived thus far is a tribute to the great retailer that Richard Schulze, Brad Anderson and others built. Unlike Circuit City, Best Buy has yet to crash into the ground—but only because it has so far to fall.

Let’s face it: The game is rigged against Best Buy. How else to describe a competitive dynamic where it has to compete on price against Amazon? Best Buy is battling a competitor that has a structural cost advantage, higher customer satisfaction and carte blanche from its investors to operate at slim margins.

Hubert Joly, Best Buy’s latest CEO, seems to be doing a valiant job of cutting costs. To win, however, he has to become more efficient than Amazon while improving customer satisfaction and delivering the higher margins that his own investors demand. What are the odds of that?

There will be ups and downs for traders in Best Buy’s stock (as the last 12 months demonstrate) but for long-term investors and the company itself, the trajectory is not promising.


Smartphones will follow a path toward faster, better, cheaper and less-profitable models. This is an inevitable consequence of Moore’s Law . Best Buy’s bleak performance signals how surprisingly fast that is happening. It is a warning that others must also face: Demand is softening, competition is intensifying and profits are shrinking.

Best Buy was particularly hurt by these factors because of its suspect business model. But Best Buy, which had committed to matching others on pricing, got its fair share of the market; the problem was that demand was soft across the board.

Looking forward, other players will have to contend with the rapidly changing smartphone market, too.

Smartphone industry players will be faced with more and more saturated developed markets in the US and Europe. Penetration has reached an estimated 60 to 70 percent in the US and Europe. Growth will become restricted by contract-renewal cycles and will require stealing customers, as opposed to meeting new demand. Qualcomm has already announced that it anticipates a slowdown in smartphones.

There are massive market opportunities in China, India, Brazil and other emerging regions. But these markets have a different dynamic and do not offer the rich veins of profits that Apple and, to a lesser extent, Samsung has enjoyed to date. Emerging-market consumers and mobile operators are more price-sensitive. Emerging markets are also filled with local competitors that are armed with faster, better and cheaper technology than Steve Jobs could have imagined in 2007 and that are ready to adapt to local tastes and conditions. These conditions do not bode well for Apple’s reliance on older iPhone models to compete in markets like India.

The more interesting competitive market laboratory is in China. Apple’s China Mobile deal now fuels an intense competitor ecosystem. Apple might do well for a time because of pent-up demand in a brand-conscious market. Over time, however, formidable competitors will emerge out of the intense competition for such a large, lucrative market.

In both developed and emerging markets, the rapidly maturing technology will force the industry to contend with a version of the rigged game that Best Buy is losing against Amazon—and this might be the biggest game changer of all. Instead of Amazon, the industry’s arch nemesis is Google.

Google, armed with Motorola, has the luxury of viewing smartphones as a channel for its core search business. It doesn’t have to make money on the devices. It just wants to push users to the Internet. Google will inevitably push smartphone prices as low as possible. Motorola CEO, Dennis Woodside, is already talking about a $50 smartphone .

This is analogous to Las Vegas casinos giving away fine dinners and great shows to draw customers to their casinos. It is just a matter of time before other major players, like Microsoft (armed with Nokia), Amazon (armed with the Kindle Fire) and Alibaba, adopt the same strategy.

The confluence of these trends will strike hard at the industry’s bottom line. Apple and Samsung enjoy more than 100 percent of industry profits, and these profits represent a significant portion of their respective corporate earnings. Samsung has already announced that its latest-quarter results declined both over the previous quarter and over the prior year. It is estimated that smartphone profits account for more than half of Samsung’s earnings. Because of intensifying competition, others might win market share, but expect more and more of the profit pool to be competed away.

The Need for New Killer Apps

Apple, Samsung, Qualcomm and others are not doomed to follow Best Buy to extinction. Unlike Best Buy, their assets and scale remain immensely valuable. Apple, in particular, is at the top of its game. It will undoubtedly announce another “best quarter ever” next week. It still has much work to do to reap the benefits of its China Mobile deal, but no competitor or new business model has yet turned its strengths into liabilities.

The importance of Best Buy’s canary-in-the-coal-mine warning is that it signals that now is the time to get very serious about the Next Big Thing. There is bound to be one after smartphones, and, by all rights, today’s leaders have first rights to invent it.

Can they do it?  Please share your comments below.

* * *

Chunka Mui is the coauthor of The New Killer Apps: How Large Companies Can Out-Innovate Start-Ups . Follow him at Facebook , Twitter @chunkamui  or at Google+ .

For more on the challenges of translating success in one computing class (e.g. mainframes, minicomputers, personal computers, smartphones, etc.) into the next, see his earlier articles Tim Cook, Apple and wearable computing:

Will Tim Cook Be the Next Steve Ballmer?

Will Wearable Computing Be Tim Cook’s Rubicon or Waterloo?

Source: Forbes


You Might Also Like


Sponsored Update

Update: 12




Update: 11

Buyer's Guide: Discounts on Retina MacBook Pro, iPad, Apple Accessories, and More [Mac Blog]

Source: MacRumors

Trey Songz Performs On Stage And Talks Target Exclusive Deluxe Album Edition Of "Trigga" At "106 & Park" Live Presented By Target At BET Experience
There are some good deals on Apple-related accessories this week, as well as some decent discounts on the Retina MacBook Pro and an iPad deal from Target that includes free gift cards. Retina MacBook Pro Like last week, several retailers are offering $100 to $150 off most Retina MacBook Pro models. The 13-inch Retina MacBook Pro with 4GB of RAM and 128 GB of storage is $1,199 at Amazon, Adorama, and B&H Photo. The 13-inch Retina MacB ...
Source: MacRumors   Full article at: MacRumors 9 hours ago, 2:26pm CDT

More From the Web

Update: 10

Toddler Finds Love at Best Buy, Puts Move on Toshiba TV Cutie

Source: The Hollywood Gossip

Love at first sight. Believe in it. You never know when, or where, you might find it, but the feeling is real. Just ask Julian, one adorable toddler, for whom it proved to be true this month. At Best Buy. 45 Adorable Kid Videos 1. Toddler Falls in Love at Best Buy A youngster named Julian falls in love with a pretty girl at Best Buy ... on a box. While toddling through the big box electronics retailer on a shopping trip with his dad, Julian suddenly made a beeline for a ...
Source: The Hollywood Gossip   Full article at: The Hollywood Gossip 9 hours ago, 2:14pm CDT

Update: 8

9to5Toys Lunch Break: JBL Lightning Speaker Dock $20, Jabra REVO BT headphones $140, Belkin WeMo Insight $49, more

Source: 9to5Mac

Creative Industries Council Launches Create UK
Be sure to follow 9to5Toys to keep up with the best gear and deals on the web: Twitter, RSS Feed, Facebook, Google+ and Safari push notifications. Today’s can’t miss deals: JBL OnBeat Micro Speaker Dock (black or white) $15 + $5 shipping (orig. $120) Jabra REVO wireless Bluetooth headphones $140 shipped (orig. $249) TigerDirect $15 off $50+: Belkin WeMo Insight $49 (Reg. $80), WD 3TB Desktop HDD $85 (Reg. $160), more Other new deals: Nexus 7 (2nd gen) 16GB, refurbished w/ 90-da ...
Source: 9to5Mac   Full article at: 9to5Mac 11 hours ago, 11:30am CDT

Update: 7

Five men suing Obama administration after falling into ‘suspicious activity’ file

Source: Russia Today

The lawsuit, filed by five Americans whose personal data has been entered into anti-terror databases for engaging in lawful behavior, aims to impose a “permanent injunction” on a government program that “targets First Amendment-protected activity, encourages racial and religious profiling, and violates federal law.” US rights groups condemn NSA spying on Muslim-Americans Since 2013, over 35,000 US citize ...
Source: Russia Today   Full article at: Russia Today 17 hours ago, 6:02am CDT

Update: 6

Here's What Weezer Is Doing; Here's What They Should Be Doing...

Source: The Daily Swarm

Stromae In Concert - New York, NY
From Consequence of Sound: I remember the last time I could say Weezer was my favorite band without being called an idiot. A little over 10 years ago, shortly after Maladroit confused fans of Weezer (The Green Album) and impressed the guitarists previously charmed by the understated six-string wizardry within Pinkerton and their blue-glazed debut. I liked this time a lot. It was nice to know that not only were Weezer a.) sophisticat ...
Source: The Daily Swarm   Full article at: The Daily Swarm 1 day ago, 7:09pm CDT

Update: 5

Best Buy $100 Gift Card Giveaway

Source: Shopping Bookmarks

Stromae In Concert - New York, NY
Enter to win a $100 Best Buy Gift Card! Giveaway is available for participating members only, greatly increasing your odds of winning! No purchase necessary. Source: → | ∞ PermalinkMore About: sweepstakes give ...
Source: Shopping Bookmarks   Full article at: Shopping Bookmarks 2 days ago, 5:12am CDT

Update: 4

9to5Toys Last Call: Apple is back on eBay, Philips and Jawbone Bluetooth speakers: $50, SmartHome deals and more

Source: 9to5Mac

"The Jersey Devil" Trailer Release Party
Be sure to follow 9to5Toys to keep up with the best gear and deals on the web: Twitter, RSS Feed, Facebook, Google+ and Safari push notifications. Today’s can’t miss deals: In late 2012 we uncovered an eBay store that was selling Apple certified refurbished products (iPad, MacBook, iPod, more). Though never officially confirmed by Apple itself, this storefront had all the makings of being officially tied to Apple in some capacity. This store is still live on eBay, but has not offered an item ...
Source: 9to5Mac   Full article at: 9to5Mac 3 days ago, 12:15pm CDT

Update: 3

The mysterious case of the vanishing PS Vitas

Source: BGR

Prince Charles Visits Sony UK Technology Centre
If you've waited until now to try to get your hands on Sony's latest portable console, you might be out of luck. Polygon has noted that even though the PS Vita was recently re-released with a slimmer frame and improved battery life, the Borderlands 2 bundle is currently out of stock at every major online retailer, including Target, Walmart, Best Buy and GameStop. The listing on Target even states that the ...
Source: BGR   Full article at: BGR Jul 3 2014, 3:34pm CDT

Update: 2

Buyer's Guide: 4th of July Discounts on iMac, MacBook Air, Apps, Accessories, and More [Mac Blog]

Source: MacRumors

Stromae In Concert - New York, NY
There are some solid deals on Apple-related software and accessories this week due to the Fourth of July holiday in the United States, as well as some decent discounts on the iMac, MacBook Air, and Retina MacBook Pro. iMac Best Buy is running a four-day 4th of July sale offering $120 off of Apple's entire lineup of iMacs. This drops the price of the new entry level 1.4Ghz iMac to $979.99. Similarly, B&H Photo is also offering ...
Source: MacRumors   Full article at: MacRumors Jul 3 2014, 2:08pm CDT

Update: 1

[Listen] Stromae - ta fête

Source: DJ Booth

Four years after we introduced your to the Brussels-based dance-pop phenom by way of the Kanye-assisted Alors On Danse (Remix), Stromae is finally blowing up Stateside. Earlier this year, he sold out NYC’s Best Buy theater. Overseas, of course, his popularity remains sky-high, which is why his ta fête has been selected as Belgium’s official …   Click the link ...
Source: DJ Booth   Full article at: DJ Booth Jul 3 2014, 11:30am CDT

Shopping Deals


<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/31" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.




blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Analyst Ming-Chi Kuo&#039;s take on the Apple iWatch
Analyst Ming-Chi Kuo's take on the Apple iWatch
Apple’s sapphire-covered ‘iWatch’ to enter mass production in November
Nokia Lumia 930 now available in the US for $699.99
Nokia Lumia 930 now available in the US for $699.99
The first third party retailer to sell the phone in the US is Expansys
iPhone 6 Sapphire Glass Display Gets Run Over By A Car
iPhone 6 Sapphire Glass Display Gets Run Over By A Car
After sailing through 'key and knife' and 'hammer and nail' test, the front of the iPhone 6 finally gave way to the weight of the car
Axelle Despiegelaere Model Contract Terminated
Axelle Despiegelaere Model Contract Terminated
The cute Belgian Soccer fan that scored a modeling contract after her photo went viral. Now the contract has been terminated - likely because of the Safari hunting photo. Her Facebook page is also gone.