Menu
Early Walmart Cyber Monday 2014 Sales Event Revealed

Early Walmart Cyber Monday 2014 Sales Event Revealed

Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare Live Action Trailer is Released

Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare Live Action Trailer is Released

Amazon Countdown to Black Friday 2014 Sale Announced

Amazon Countdown to Black Friday 2014 Sale Announced

Ju Peng Story Fabricated by Dating App Maker

Ju Peng Story Fabricated by Dating App Maker

Walmart Black Friday 2014 Ad Expected on Nov. 11

Walmart Black Friday 2014 Ad Expected on Nov. 11

Shadow Of Mordor is Basically What?

Jan 25 2014, 5:44am CST | by , in News

Shadow Of Mordor is Basically What?
 
 

Comparisons between Monolith and Warner Bros.’ upcoming open-world fantasy game Shadow of Mordor and Ubisoft’s Assassin’s Creed franchise have sprung up recently.

“Seriously, can someone tell me how Assassin’s Creed 2 code and assets are in this Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor game?” Assassin’s Creed 2 developer Charles Randall asked on Twitter the other day.

The games do look strikingly similar. Mordor’s ranger-hero Talion sneaks across ropes stretched taut between buildings, performs air assassinations, and even has an Eagle Vision-ish mode that highlights enemies.

Watching him scale the sides of buildings and perform leaping assassinations only makes the comparison more uncanny. It’s all lovely, of course, but it certainly feels like Assassin’s Creed: Mordor—minus, one hopes, any whiff of the silly Animus stuff.

Even reviewer Adam Sessler makes the comparison in his initial thoughts on the game’s first demo, though he notes that after the first few minutes of similarities the game gets interesting and exciting in its own right, with plenty of its own innovations to look forward to:

Others have pointed out that the game also resembles Warner Bros.’ own open-world franchise, the Arkham Batman games. Those games have a similar “Detective Vision” mode as well as similar platforming elements, combat, and so forth.

But while both comparisons can be made, I definitely see more of Assassin’s Creed, though the combat looks more interesting, and the Nemesis system—whereby enemies grow to know Talion and remember him and form some sort of relationship with him throughout the game—sounds like a nice touch.

And who knows? A game that looks similar certainly doesn’t mean that anything was literally stolen or copied. And Randall was quick to distance himself from any accusations on that front, adding after his Tweets drew attention, “For the record though, that Middle-earth game looks pretty damn awesome. And I love AC2 so it’s kind of a double win.”

For its part, Monolith says any comparisons to Assassin’s Creed are incidental, and that they didn’t even consider those games when designing Shadow of Mordor.

“We didn’t think much about them at all,” said design director Michael de Plater earlier this week (via Eurogamer.) “We just wanted to do a third-person, open-world action adventure. And then now, just by the time you have stealth and melee combat and you’re hunting guys behind enemy lines, the comparisons maybe come out at that point. It definitely wasn’t something we were consciously going for.”

Having not played the game, I’ll withhold judgment for now. No doubt there’s some parallels, but the devil’s in the details, and a great deal will depend on not just how the game looks but how gameplay actually feels. Certainly Assassin’s Creed is not the only third-person game with wall-climbing and so forth. And I’m hoping Mordor gives us more satisfying combat.

Nonetheless, I find it a tad difficult to believe that nobody working on Shadow of Mordor ever once even considered the Assassin’s Creed games.

I’m not a game designer, but I have a strong suspicion that developers, like any other creative people in whatever field, take into account other games from similar genres. Nobody sets out to make a giant open-world game without thinking about what’s already been done in that space.

For my part, I think that Shadow of Mordor looks pretty cool. Very “next-gen” graphically and mechanically, if it all looks and works according to plan.

On the other hand—and this “other hand” is getting more and more riled up lately—my curmudgeonly side worries that the Lord of the Rings IP is being badly watered down and mishandled by its current stewards. There is very little of Tolkien’s world here, just as there is increasingly little of it left in Peter Jackson’s films. Shadow of Mordor may take place in “Mordor” but it smacks of generic high-fantasy in many ways, including the fact that it’s all about fighting and killing and overt magical powers.


Which may be great for entertainment purposes, but maybe not so good when it comes to conveying what the original books and world were actually about.

Follow me on Twitter or FacebookRead my Forbes blog here.

Source: Forbes

Recommended For You

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus