Feb 14 2014, 12:36am CST | by Forbes
If an employee is sued on the job, the employer will be too. Say a delivery driver has an accident on his route. The company and the driver will be sued.
But what if a supervisor sexually harasses an employee? This conduct may be personal, but it arises out of a working relationship and may involve company property and business trips. In both cases, the company usually covers legal bills and settlements.
Sometimes the IRS points an accusing finger at corporate conduct and denies tax deductions. Even if the company is a named defendant, it may not be enough to make a settlement payment–or even legal fees–tax deductible. That’s what happened in Cavanaugh v. Commissioner.
James Cavanaugh was CEO and sole shareholder of Jani-King, a successful janitorial-services franchisor. He vacationed in St. Maarten one Thanksgiving with his girlfriend, Jani-King employee, Claire Robinson. It wasn’t a business trip, but they were accompanied by Cavanaugh’s bodyguard, and another Jani-King employee.
While on the trip, Robinson suffered fatal cardiac arrest after ingesting a large amount of cocaine. Her mother sued Cavanaugh and Jani-King. Jani-King’s board worried that losing the case would trigger a backlash from franchisees so settled for $2.3 million. Cavanaugh contributed $250,000, which Jani-King reimbursed. Jani-King deducted it all as a business expense.
The IRS challenged the deductions, but the Tax Court agreed with the IRS. See Which Corporate Lawsuits Are Personal and Nondeductible? Why? The employees were on vacation, not Jani-King business, and were far from company property.
The courts have allowed business deductions where the claims are at least part business, as in Kopp’s Co. v. United States. There, a company deducted a settlement after the CEO killed a child in a company car on the way to the office. But Cavanaugh’s case was different.
For Cavanaugh, only the consequences of the suit–not its origin–were business-related. Even naming Jani-King as a defendant didn’t automatically make legal fees or settlement costs deductible. The deductibility of Jani-King’s payment turned on the claim (that Jani-King employees negligently provided illegal drugs resulting in Robinson’s death) and whether its origin lay in Jani-King’s business.
Here are some cases where deductions were allowed despite personal conduct:
You can reach me at Wood@WoodLLP.com. This discussion is not intended as legal advice, and cannot be relied upon for any purpose without the services of a qualified professional.
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.
blog comments powered by Disqus
The “geek mind” is concerned with more than just the latest iPhone rumors, or which company will win the gaming console wars. I4U is concerned with more than just the latest photo shoot or other celebrity gossip.
The “geek mind” is concerned with life, in all its different forms and facets. The geek mind wants to know about societal and financial issues, both abroad and at home. If a Fortune 500 decides to raise their minimum wage, or any high priority news, the geek mind wants to know. The geek mind wants to know the top teams in the National Football League, or who’s likely to win the NBA Finals this coming year. The geek mind wants to know who the hottest new models are, or whether the newest blockbuster movie is worth seeing. The geek mind wants to know. The geek mind wants—needs—knowledge.
Read more about The Geek Mind.