Latest News: Technology |  Celebrity |  Movies |  Apple |  Cars |  Business |  Sports |  TV Shows |  Geek

Trending

Filed under: News | Technology News

 

Netflix Wants the Benefits of the Net Without Its Costs

11 Updates
Netflix Wants the Benefits of the Net Without Its Costs
 
 

YouTube Videos Comments

Full Story

Netflix Wants the Benefits of the Net Without Its Costs

Netflix CEO Reed Hastings doesn’t like paying for Internet connectivity. He has a new idea, which he calls “strong net neutrality,” that could significantly reduce one of his big input costs. For decades, content providers, websites, ISPs, and consumers have paid fees to connect to the next level of the network. Call it Internet access, or call it “transit” or “paid peering.” The business of network firms is transporting bits in exchange for money. But Hastings has a better idea. “Instead,” Hastings demands in a new blog, “they must provide sufficient access to their network without charge.”

Why didn’t General Motors think of that? Steel without charge!

Hastings’ novel proposal caps a series of recent disputes over Internet “interconnection.” The first high-profile row came in 2010 when Level 3 (with Netflix at its side) wrangled, and then came to an agreement, with Comcast. Then a few months ago Netflix, having changed its network architecture, once again began complaining about Comcast. That dispute was settled in late February when Netflix agreed to pay Comcast to connect directly to the broadband service provider’s network.

At the time, Columbia law professor Tim Wu, a chief advocate of “net neutrality” and coiner of the term, erupted, demanding such agreements be blocked. “This is the first-ever direct interconnection deal between a broadband provider, like Comcast, and a content company, like Netflix or Google,” Wu insisted. But he was flat out wrong. Firms like Google, Amazon, and Microsoft have connected directly to broadband providers for years.

Hastings is back, however, perhaps angling for Washington’s support in his negotiations with other broadband providers. The FCC net neutrality rules, twice thrown out by courts, only covered last-mile transmissions and explicitly did not cover interconnection and peering. Thus Hastings’ invention of super duper strong net neutrality.

His proposal is odd for a number of reasons. From the beginning, interconnection has been a competitive and cooperative arena. Unlike the highly regulated old telecom world, with its government-set tariffs and tolls, the interconnection market is unregulated and “just works.” Consumers and websites pay ISPs for access, who, in turn, pay even larger ISPs for access to the global Internet. As networks grow, new technical and business arrangements evolve to accommodate the new technology and economics. Like any industry, companies haggle, but serious disputes are rare. In this unregulated interconnect arena, moreover, bandwidth supply has boomed and prices have plummeted. Now, however, Netflix and Level 3 want new government rules to change the way network firms interact with each other. If there’s one thing in our economy that emphatically is working, it’s the Internet. And the last thing we need is Congress or the Federal Communications Commission posing as network architect. (Our recent report “How the Net Works” is a primer and brief history on interconnection.)

If you are confused by the uproar over the fact that Netflix (and others) used to pay an Internet backbone provider for an arguably inferior connection to the network but now pay broadband providers for a better, more direct connection to the network, you are not alone. This is part of the natural evolution of the network. It’s precisely what allows this industry to grow so fast. As I like to say, the dynamism of the Internet is its chief virtue.

Netflix appears to want consumers to pay for both their own connections and Netflix’s connections. Moreover, depending on the pricing plans of the broadband providers, lots of consumers who are not Netflix subscribers will be subsidizing its business. Shouldn’t Netflix subscribers pay Netflix’s costs?

But Hastings proposal is even more radical than that. He seems to be saying that all network firms connect to all content firms via “settlement free peering.” He’s talking about the practice whereby networks of roughly similar size who exchange roughly equal amounts of data (“peers”) trade traffic at no charge (“settlement free”). Some relationships on the Internet do use this form of barter — but only when it makes sense for both parties. Hastings apparently wants the law to mandate a zero price for interconnection no matter how big or small the parties, no matter how much value each side is bringing to the table.

Hastings says he’s willing to accept equal amounts of traffic from the broadband providers. But that is a silly notion. Netflix is essentially a one-way service. Nobody would have any need to send exabytes of data to Netflix. It’s not just the direction of the traffic but the value the other network provides in its reach to other points on the Internet.

At a zero price, demand would explode. The supply of interconnection bandwidth would shrink. Every website and content provider on the planet would insist on being inside the broadband providers’ networks — for free! But if every website and content provider demands premium connectivity, then no one will actually get premium connectivity.

Prices are a way that we rationally allocate resources — not excepting bandwidth, interconnect capacity, data center space, and all the other costs of network transport and content. For some content providers, like high-end video streaming services, capacity, latency, and reach are important. And they have always been willing and able to pay to improve performance. YouTube has done so for years. So has Netflix. For other services, like my little website, it doesn’t make sense to pay for high throughput or CDN services or paid peering. All I’m doing is delivering vanilla webpages. But if a law or regulation mandated that my little website (and a million like it) get the same access as Netflix to every network service, with no ability to differentiate how much interconnection capacity or CDN service we or they can buy, then Netflix, which is much larger and more sensitive to network constraints than I am, could suffer in quality.

Hastings’ rhetorical expansion of net neutrality to “strong” net neutrality is one of many reasons we opposed the regulation from the beginning. As we wrote in The Wall Street Journal in 2009, “This regulation could expand bureaucratic oversight to every bit, switch and business plan on the Internet.”

Netflix wants all the advantages of high capacity and low latency but none of the cost. Hastings’ proposed rule, if fully implemented, however, could actually degrade his own service. The Internet is changing many things in our economy, but not the most basic laws of supply and demand.

Source: Forbes

 

iPad Air Giveaway. Win a free iPad Air.

You Might Also Like

Updates


Sponsored Update

Update: 11

America's cartoon cat Garfield gets TV makeover in Indonesia

Source: Asia One

JAKARTA/SINGAPORE - The comic strip cat Garfield was created in America, but the animated television series based on the famous Jim Davis cartoon character is produced at a sprawling studio on the Indonesian resort island of Batam.Infinite Studios started in 1997 as a film post-production company with 13 people. In part building on the success of Garfield, it has diversified into creating its own content production as well as animation ...
Source: Asia One   Full article at: Asia One 4 days ago, 7:35am CDT
 


Advertisement


Update: 10

Uzo Aduba's Big Emmy Win

Source: Mail.com

Uzo Aduba wins an Emmy for best guest actress in a comedy series for her breakout role as 'Crazy Eyes' in Netflix's 'Orange is the ...
Source: Mail.com   Full article at: Mail.com 4 days ago, 5:56am CDT
 

More From the Web

Update: 9

Orange Is The New Gold: Uzo Aduba Wins Emmy For Best Guest Actress

Source: Bossip.com

Uzo Aduba’s eyes looked anything but crazy as she received a Creative Arts Emmy last night for Best Guest Actress. Unfortunately, that means we won’t get to see her accept her award at the primetime Emmys, but it is an honor that is well-deserved nonetheless. Anyone who is a fan of the show knows that Aduba steals whatever scene she’s in on the Netflix series Orange Is The New Black playing the random “Crazy Eyes” who can often be found chasing her “dandelion”…. Continue ...
Source: Bossip.com   Full article at: Bossip.com 5 days ago, 10:39am CDT
 

Update: 7

Viewers turning against “Reality crap”

Source: TV Tonight

Viewers are frustrated by Reality Television taking over their TVs according to a wave of responses in the TV Tonight Audience Inventory for 2014. While numbers for some Reality shows have been down lately, viewers completing the annual survey have vented in the survey’s General Comments section. Many are making it known they are bored by Reality Television’s dominance and overruns, and are turning to Timeshifted viewing and sourcing television from overseas in ...
Source: TV Tonight   Full article at: TV Tonight 6 days ago, 1:58pm CDT
 

Update: 6

See the latest slang that has been included in the Oxford dictionary

Source: MyFox 8 WGHO

NEW YORK — This is truly “cray:” the Oxford Dictionary publishers are totally plugged in to pop culture. They must be “hyperconnected.” The iconic dictionary has updated its online edition and published a list — one that could be described as “baller” or even “amazeballs” — of new words that seem unlikely candidates for an Oxford University syllabus. For those who haven’t been keeping up, it looks like a “hot mess.” Among the 50 new words the dictionar ...
Source: MyFox 8 WGHO   Full article at: MyFox 8 WGHO 6 days ago, 1:30pm CDT
 

Update: 5

Leonardo DiCaprio Is More Than A Pretty Face, Mission Blue's Sylvia Earle Says

Source: Just Jared

Leonardo DiCaprio keeps it casual in a white v-neck while heading to lunch on Friday (August 15) in Beverly Hills, Calif. The 39-year-old actor was accompanied by two pals, who walked a few paces behind him. PHOTOS: Check out the latest pics of Leonardo DiCaprio Earlier in the week, Leonardo sported a nice blazer to host a screening of Netflix documentary Mission Blue, which centers on the work of Dr. Sylvia Earle. “Leonardo is more than a pretty face,” ...
Source: Just Jared   Full article at: Just Jared 6 days ago, 11:45am CDT
 

Update: 4

Most Popular Baby Names List Taken Over By Breaking Bad, Game Of Thrones And Twilight

Source: The Huffington Post: UK Edition

The most popular names given to babies in England and Wales have been revealed, and some unusual names have made an appearance in the charts for the first time. Four baby girls were named Daenerys and three boys were named Tyrion in 2013. Another 11 were named Theon. The new names are apparently in homage to characters in the HBO TV series Game of Thrones, set in the fantasy land of Westeros. Daenerys in Game Of Thrones: four babies now share ...
Source: The Huffington Post: UK Edition   Full article at: The Huffington Post: UK Edition Aug 15 2014, 10:57am CDT
 

Update: 3

Roundup: Best of TechRadar: this week's best features and hottest reviews

Source: Tech.co.uk

25 Google search tips and tricks you need to knowSearch smarter with our expert guide to GoogleEverybody knows Google, but not everybody knows its secrets, the little things that make finding what you want faster, that make searches more specific and that uncover entertaining Easter eggs. Here are 25 of our favourite ways to find Google's G spotsMeet Slice: the Raspberry Pi-powered media player with a differenceTurn your media files into a personal Netflix libraryAnyon ...
Source: Tech.co.uk   Full article at: Tech.co.uk Aug 15 2014, 3:05am CDT
 

Update: 2

TV Club: Battlestar Galactica: Miniseries, Part 1

Source: The A.V. Club

Here we are, at the beginning.A miniseries is a weird way to start an hourlong show—it’s a deliberately irregular pace compared to what the rest of the show is going to do, and it requires an awful lot of investment from first-time viewers trying to get into the series. So it’s weirder still that it works for Battlestar Galactica. Partly that’s because the show has so much it needs to establish in the first few episodes. Partly, there’s som ...
Source: The A.V. Club   Full article at: The A.V. Club Aug 14 2014, 1:00pm CDT
 

Update: 1

Hands-on review: Updated: Alienware Steam Machine review

Source: Tech.co.uk

Alienware Alpha Steam Machine at E3 2014Update: During a pre-Gamescom briefing in San Francisco, the company finally showed off the Alpha's Alienware exclusive user interface - but only through screenshots. Keep reading below to see the rest of the screens from the Alpha.Original article below ...The Alienware Steam Machine finally has a name: Alpha. But more importantly, the Dell-based company has also finalized specs on the St ...
Source: Tech.co.uk   Full article at: Tech.co.uk Aug 13 2014, 6:07pm CDT
 

Shopping Deals

 
 
 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/31" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Jim Parsons Talks About &quot;The Big Bang Theory&quot; and Upcoming Nominations
Jim Parsons Talks About "The Big Bang Theory" and Upcoming Nominations
Proud of being nominated for his role in HBO movie "The Normal Heart."
 
 
Benedict Cumberbatch Takes &quot;Ice Bucket Challenge&quot; To New Level
Benedict Cumberbatch Takes "Ice Bucket Challenge" To New Level
The Brit Star is nominated five times for the challenge.
 
 
Kari Byron, Tory Belleci and Grant Imahara Exit MythBusters
 
 
Microsoft set to unveil Windows 9 on September 30th
Microsoft set to unveil Windows 9 on September 30th
While Threshold is likely to be named Windows 9, it’s unlikely that Microsoft will name its upcoming Windows release at its press event.
 
 
 

About the Geek Mind

The “geek mind” is concerned with more than just the latest iPhone rumors, or which company will win the gaming console wars. I4U is concerned with more than just the latest photo shoot or other celebrity gossip.

The “geek mind” is concerned with life, in all its different forms and facets. The geek mind wants to know about societal and financial issues, both abroad and at home. If a Fortune 500 decides to raise their minimum wage, or any high priority news, the geek mind wants to know. The geek mind wants to know the top teams in the National Football League, or who’s likely to win the NBA Finals this coming year. The geek mind wants to know who the hottest new models are, or whether the newest blockbuster movie is worth seeing. The geek mind wants to know. The geek mind wants—needs—knowledge.

Read more about The Geek Mind.