Introduction:
We reported about Toshiba's iPod contender back in August 2003
the first time. The ultra-thin and very lightweight 20GB HDD Music
Player Toshiba Gigabeat G20 (MEG200J) is now available
in Japan. Dynamism sent
us this slick gadget to review it. Which after our Sony
DSC-T1 Review is again an I4U exclusive Review. I did not find
another review about Toshiba's Gigabeat G20 on the web. (Update 07/02/04: There is one other Review by Adrian Flitcroft.) If you have
found others please email us.
I was
looking forward to get my hands on this player for quite a while.
It's clean elegant look, small dimensions but large storage make it
a very attractive MP3 Jukebox. Apple sold 2 million iPods already,
which makes it a "boring gadget" for gadget addicts. You
cannot stand out with an iPod anymore. Products like the Toshiba Gigabeat G20 are a promising alternative to
differentiate from the iPod crowd. Toshiba will eventually sell
directly on the US market and European market, for now Japanese import is the only way. Dynamism
is a trusted source for getting Japanese market released Gadgets.
Read on to see how the Toshiba Gigabeat G20
(Japanese product page) is holding up against
the iPod.
We don't have an iPod lying around in our I4U Lab, so we waltzed
into the next Apple store to make some comparison shots. In the last
section of this review you also find a head-to-head comparison on
key aspects between iPod and G20.
 |
 |
| The
Toshiba MP3 Player is thinner and has a different form factor.
It also takes 20 cm3 less space. |
Overview:
 |
At the first
glance the G20 is impressing me right away. It is extremely
light (138g) and it has only the size and format (76.5mm x
12.7mm x 89.5mm) of those silver cigarette cases. Compared to
the (new) iPod, which measures 101.6x15.7x67mm and weighs
159g. The iPod is longer which when put in a shirt pocket
makes it head heavy and easier to fall out. The Toshiba G20
actually fits exactly in a shirt pocket. Looks like Toshiba
made this on purpose. The metal finish on the casing is
typical Japanese electronics style. The design is very clean
and elegant. The buttons are all on one side of the player. On
the front is only the logo and the LCD display with blue
backlight. On top is the headset plug and the lock button. On
the right upper corner is a hole to connect a wrist band. |
 |
| The Toshiba Gigabeat G20 fits
perfectly into a shirt pocket. Most likely that
drove the form factor. I had to stick something under the
player in the pocket so the player still sticks out for the
photo. It normally completely disappears in the shirt pocket. |
What's in the Box:
Gigabeat G20 20GB HDD Music Player
Docking Station
USB Cable
Power Cable for Docking Station
Earphones
Remote Control
Two Manuals
Software CD
First thing is to charge the Player by putting
it into the docking station. Charging takes a couple of hours. The
DC power adapter can also be plugged directly into the player to
charge it. Which is nice for travel. The Gigabeat G20 has a playback
time of 11 hours. Note, on the back of the player is a slider to
switch off the built-in battery. Make sure its set to on.
In the meantime I installed the software
provided on the CD. There is a proprietary music management software
(TOSHIBA Audio Application Ver2.0) to upload music files to the
player. This program is very basic and I did not find it that useful.
The good thing is that Toshiba has bundled a driver for the Windows
Media Player 9. After installing the G20 shows up as a device on the
Windows Media Player. Copying individual files or copy whole CDs is
a snap with Media Player. I will go into more details on managing
and downloading music to the G20 later in the review.
After charging was done I connected the player with the USB Cable to
my Windows XP Notebook. To power-on the player, the big wiggle
button on the side has to be pressed for about two seconds. The
display lights up and the Gigabeat logo is displayed. The MP3 Player
is immediately recognized as a drive and I can browse the file
system on the players 20GB 1.8" hard-drive. You can upload any
file to the player's hard-drive to use it as a portable 20GB
hard-drive.
Music files however need to be uploaded
either through the bundled simple music program or through the
Microsoft Windows Media Player Driver. Why ? Because the player is
wrapping music files with meta code and adds the extension SAT to
each file. Without that extension the player does not see the file
and does not play it back.
To test the sound I uploaded one MP3 file through the windows Media
Player. I put on the bundled earphones and press the big wiggle
button on the side to start navigating through the directory. On the
uploaded file I press again the wiggle button and music starts
playing. The sound is full and clear. I try the built-in equalizer
and switch to bass++, which makes the sound even better for my
taste. Volume is
controlled by small buttons arranged on top and bottom of the wiggle
button. Pushing the wiggle button will pause the play-back. To push
the button up will move to the previous song or previous menu item.
Pushing it down will move to the next entry. This button interface
is very intuitive and I had no problem to figure it out right away.
It is also very tactile. Once I am in a submenu the upper volume
button becomes the back button. To get into the menu a small menu
button is placed on the upper area of the player's right side.
I go in more detail on all the features in the next section.
 |
| Right side of Player with all
buttons. Besides the hold button which is on the top side of
the player all buttons are on this side. You also see here the power adapter plug and the
USB plug. Every button is nicely marked with an icon. |
Remote Control:
 |
The
bundled remote control can be plugged between the player and
the headset. It has a clip on the back to fasten it on a shirt
collar. The remote features volume control buttons, a button
to cycle through the equalizer modes, skip forward and
backwards and a play/pause button. On the side is a hold
button to lock the buttons. The remote is conveniently small
(12x65x8mm) and lightweight and its case is black plastic. |
This concludes the overview, press the next button below to dive into the features of the Toshiba Gigabeat G20.
|